Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
When it comes to the fiscal cliff, U.S. Sen. Jeanne Shaheen is willing to consider anything to ease the fall. Everything, that is, except for one key federal program.
"I think we do need to take Social Security off the table because Social Security has not contributed to the debt and the deficits," Shaheen said Tuesday, Nov. 27 in an interview on MSNBC’s Jansing and Co.
"We do need to fix it for the long-term," she said. "But that's a different discussion than the one that we're having about those programs that are actually costing."
We’ve heard claims like this before. In August 2011, PolitiFact gave a Mostly True ruling to a claim that Social Security didn’t cause the debt crisis. At the same time, we ruled Mostly False on a claim that Social Security doesn’t contribute a penny to the deficit.
We decided to take another swing at it.
To start, we approached representatives from Shaheen’s Senate office, who reminded us that Social Security is a self-financed program, funded primarily through dedicated payroll taxes.
In most years, including the period from 1984-2009, the program takes in more money than it distributes in benefits, creating a surplus. Those surplus dollars add to the Social Security trust funds, which currently hold about $2.7 trillion in assets.
The two trust funds -- one dedicated to old age and survivors’ insurance and the other committed to disability insurance -- collect interest over time. And that interest only adds to the surplus, thereby reducing the deficit, according to Paul Van de Water, a senior fellow at the liberal Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.
Including interest, the Social Security trust funds held a surplus of $69 billion in 2011, $68.6 billion in 2010 and $121.7 billion in 2009, according to Social Security Administration records.
"To that extent, it’s actually reducing the overall federal deficit," Van de Water said.
But, other analysts argue the interest payments earned by Social Security only amount to a re-shuffling of government dollars.
As noted in the prior PolitiFact rulings, the Social Security trust funds may be considered separate, but, in reality, they are not "locked boxes" or closed-off savings accounts. Rather, Social Security is required by law to put its entire surplus into interest-earning government bonds.
The dollars invested in Treasury bonds are frequently mixed and invested with other revenue sources in the government’s general fund, and, together, the money is used for other government purposes, including spending, repaying debts and cutting taxes.
So, when the Social Security trust funds collect interest, they are merely accepting money from other parts of the government, according to Howard Gleckman, an analyst for the Tax Policy Center, a joint effort between the Brookings Institution and the Urban Institute.
Without considering interest, Social Security has actually been running a deficit over recent years, Gleckman noted. And, when Social Security runs a deficit, the program draws on interest from the Social Security bonds, forcing government officials, already operating at a deficit, to borrow more money from other sources to make up the difference.
"It’s an accounting fiction," Gleckman said of the interest payments. "It helps make the Social Security funds look more solvent, but really you've just taken (money) out of general fund. … The money is simply being transferred from one government account to the next."
In 2010, the program ran a "cash deficit" of $49 billion, according to the Social Security Administration’s summary of its 2012 annual report. The following year, the deficit stood at about $45 billion, and, looking forward, the program’s future doesn’t look much brighter.
Social Security trustees project the program’s cash deficit to exceed $60 billion over the next few years, and by 2033, the trust fund will no longer have enough money to cover full benefits for beneficiaries, according to the most recent estimates.
"The Trustees project that (the deficit) will average about $66 billion between 2012 and 2018 before rising steeply as ... the number of beneficiaries continues to grow at a substantially faster rate than the number of covered workers," according to the annual report.
Lawmakers from both parties have proposed ways to bridge the gap and salvage the program. But, with the insolvency date looming, Social Security stands to have an even greater effect on the debt moving forward, according to Laurence Kotnikoff, an economics professor at Boston University.
"Nobody can claim Social Security isn’t part of the overall problem," Kotnikoff said. "It’s all labeling games. … It absolutely contributes to the overall fiscal situation. It’s in terrible shape."
Social Security is designed as a self-supporting, pay-as-you-go program, in which current payroll taxes pay for current benefits. This played out for many years, and with interest, the program has built up an annual surplus, which appeared to help offset the national deficits.
But, in reality, Social Security is not closed off from the rest of the government. The program’s surplus funds are frequently invested in Treasury bonds, and during surplus years, the bonds earn interest paid with other government dollars. And in recent years, the amount of taxes collected have not equaled the benefits distributed, leaving the Social Security funds facing a cash deficit, which then forces the government to borrow more money to offset.
This was the case in 2010 and 2011, and Social Security trustees anticipate higher deficits looking forward.
While there’s a case for both interpretations, we see clear evidence that Social Security does affect the nation’s debt and deficit.
We rate Shaheen’s claim Mostly False.
MSNBC.com, Sen. Jeanne Shaheen on Jansing and Co., Nov. 27, 2012
PolitiFact.com, Rep. Dennis Kucinich says Social Security didn’t cause the debt crisis, Aug. 2, 2011
PolitiFact.com, Retiree group says Social Security doesn’t contribute a penny to U.S. deficit, Aug. 2, 2011
Social Security Administration, The 2012 Annual Report of the Board of Trustees of the Social Security Trust Funds, April 25, 2012
Social Security Administration, The 2011 Annual Report of the Board of Trustees of the Social Security Trust Funds, May 13, 2011
Social Security Administration, The 2010 Annual Report of the Board of Trustees of the Social Security Trust Funds, August 9, 2010
Social Security Administration, A Summary of the 2012 Annual Reports, Nov. 9, 2012
Social Security Administration, Social Security Board of Trustees: Projected Trust Fund Exhaustion Three Years Sooner Than Last Year, April 23, 2012
Interview with Laurence Kotnikoff, professor of economics at Boston University, Nov. 28, 2012
Interview with Paul Van de Water, senior fellow at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, Nov. 29, 2012
Interview with Howard Gleckman, analyst at the Tax Policy Center, Nov. 29, 2012
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.