Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
School is starting for most Georgia students. And a group of parents and education leaders is warning about changes to the state’s class credit policies.
A reader asked us to check out a claim that has been making the rounds, including in a posting found on the Lilburn Patch website.
The posting, by Nancy Gordeuk, claims that the state Department of Education is implementing a policy change that will limit parents’ choices of education options.
"Do you realize that the Georgia Department of Education has implemented a new policy beginning in August that states that public schools will no longer accept credits from home school entities or non-traditional education?" Gordeuk writes in the Patch item.
That seemed like a rather significant policy for the state to change, and we investigate the claim further.
Gordeuk, a teacher, founded and operates TNT Academy in Lilburn. According to its website, TNT Academy is a nontraditional education center serving middle and high school students engaged in independent study. The academy also provides credit recovery for public school students who have failed a class.
TNT Academy lists its accreditation from the Georgia Accrediting Commission along with the Chancellor’s Office of the University of Georgia and the Georgia HOPE scholarship program for nontraditional study centers.
Gordeuk and other parents and nontraditional educators have started a petition to change the new policy they say will force parents to use only public schools.
She said she was notified about the policy change in May when a television reporter came to her academy claiming the facility’s testing standards were not tough enough. (Gordeuk says Gwinnett County was trying to shut down her school). That story, reported by Channel 2 Action News, notes that Gwinnett, where TNT Academy is located, was changing its policies to ensure all students -- including home school and private academy students -- were held to the same academic standards.
So, was the policy change a county or state effort? Sort of a mixture of both.
In April, the Georgia Department of Education updated its policies for accepting high school transfer credits and grades. The new rules require local school systems to develop their own policies for validating credit for courses taken through home study programs, nontraditional educational centers and non-accredited schools.
The local systems are required to outline procedures for determining whether transfer courses meet the state-adopted curriculum, among other items.
"What we’re saying in the policy is at the local level they have to develop policy around who they accept courses from," Matt Cardoza, a spokesman for the state Education Department, told us.
The state rules do not include a provision grandfathering existing centers and home school.
Cardoza could not provide information on how Gwinnett’s school system was handling the state requirements, so we went to the source.
Two months after the state Education Department approved its new policy, Gwinnett changed its policy on awarding units of credit and accepting transfer credits.
The policy, approved by the Gwinnett school board on June 20, does not change the requirements for home schooled students, Gwinnett schools spokeswoman Sloan Roach told us. But students at nontraditional educational centers, such as Gordeuk’s TNT Academy, will have to follow the process currently in place for home schooled students. They will now have to take a state-mandated test or one provided by a local school system in order to validate the credit.
Grades for course credit awarded through this process will be "pass" only and not appear as letter or number grades on report cards. High school transfer students must take any state-mandated tests including End-of-Course Tests.
"In the past, (Gwinnett schools) would accept credits from anybody accredited by the Georgia Accrediting Commission," Gordeuk said. With the changes, "I think it all comes down to an issue of Gwinnett not wanting people to know how many of their kids are failing their classes."
To sum up, Nancy Gordeuk, founder of a nontraditional education academy in Gwinnett County, said that the state Education Department changed its policies and will no longer accept class credits from home schools and facilities like hers.
In April, the Georgia Department of Education did update its transfer credit policy. But the changes pass the decisions about accepting credits to local school districts. The local districts can determine which credits they will accept and from which education centers.
In Gwinnett County, where Gordeuk’s facility is located, students seeking transfer credits from these centers must first pass a county-issued test.
Gordeuk is correct in noting that the transfer credit policy has changed. But the local school districts can make the decisions on how that process is handled.
We rated Gordeuk’s claim Half True.
(If you have a claim you’d like PolitiFact Georgia to check, email us at [email protected] Follow us on Twitter: @politifactga; and like us on Facebook: Politifact Georgia.)
Lilburn Patch announcement, "Parent Choice in Education," June 22, 2013
Phone interview, Nancy Grodeuk, director, TNT Academy, July 24, 2013
TNT Academy website
Change.org petition, "Stop the discriminition of non-traditional school credits"
Phone, email interviews, Matt Cardoza, spokesman, Georgia Department of Education, July 22, 25, 2013
WSB-TV, "Gwinnett academy criticized for testing standards," Richard Belcher, May 22, 2013
Georgia State Board of Education rule 160-5-1.15: Awarding Units of Credit and Acceptance of Transfer Credit and/or Grades, adopted April 5, 2013; effective April 29, 2013
Phone interview, Carvin Brown, former executive director, Georgia Accrediting Commission, July 24, 2013
Email interview, Sloan Roach, spokeswoman, Gwinnett County Public Schools, July 29, 2013
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.