Get PolitiFact in your inbox.

By Sean Gorman May 6, 2013

Cuccinelli says Virginia legislature has never failed to pass a budget

Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli recently cited "a real world example" of how Virginia’s General Assembly functions better than Congress.

State lawmakers always pass a budget while the U.S. Senate, until recently, went four years without approving a spending plan, he said during an April 18 speech at the Shad Planking in Waverly.

"We have never gone a year in Virginia -- ever -- without passing a budget -- ever," Cuccinelli, the GOP nominee for governor, said. "Whatever we all may have disagreed on or agreed on, we passed that budget."

We’ve never gone a year in Virginia without passing a budget -- ever?

Virginia’s record may be good, but it’s not perfect.

The Old Dominion works on a two-year budget cycle. During even years, a biennial spending plan is adopted. During odd years, the plan is adjusted to address changing needs and to conform to the ebb or flow of revenues because state law requires a balanced budget.

In 2000, the General Assembly passed a two-year plan that complied with then-Gov. Jim Gilmore’s signature campaign pledge to phase out the personal property tax on cars. That year, 45 percent of the levy was eliminated.

But in 2001, the nation was entering recession and the General Assembly split over Gilmore’s insistence that they proceed with the next step of phase out, which would have eliminated 70 percent of the car tax. The House approved the plan; the Senate refused, arguing that the state could not afford the step -- estimated to cost close to $400 million.

The General Assembly adjourned late that February without a budget agreement. It held a special session in May and again did not come to accord. The impasse marked "the first time, the legislature couldn’t agree on a budget," according to a May 13, 2001 article in the Richmond Times-Dispatch.

The stalemate played into Gilmore’s hands. Under state law, he was allowed to cut spending to keep the two-year budget plan balanced, but he could not appropriate money for new programs. Gilmore, a Republican, sliced $421 million in spending and kept his car tax cut on schedule.

Later that year, Democrat Mark Warner was elected governor with a stump speech that criticized the political climate in Richmond for being no better than Washington’s. And in 2002, the General Assembly capped car tax relief at $950 million a year, which was the cost of the 70 percent Gilmore phased out.

Now, let’s return to Cuccinelli at the Shad Planking. After the speech, Richmond Times-Dispatch columnist Jeff Schapiro reminded him of the 2001 stalemate. "That was before I was in the (Virginia) senate," said Cuccinelli, who was elected to the General Assembly later that year.

Cuccinelli’s campaign declined our invitation for additional comments.

Our ruling

"We have never gone a year in Virginia -- ever -- without passing a budget -- ever," Cuccinelli said.

Never, that is, except in 2001.

We rate Cuccinelli’s statement False

Our Sources

Richmond Times-Dispatch recording of Ken Cuccinelli’s speech at the Shad Planking, April 18, 2013.

Richmond Times-Dispatch, video of Ken Cuccinelli at the Shad Planking, April 18, 2013.

Virginia Department of Planning and Budget, "Virginia’s budget," accessed April 30, 2013.

Virginia Department of Planning and Budget, "Frequently asked questions" accessed April 30, 2013.

Richmond Times-Dispatch, "Budget Talks Collapse -- Assembly leaves without agreement," May 10, 2001.

Richmond Times-Dispatch, "Budget impasse meets reality -- museums, labs cope with cuts," July 1, 2001.

Richmond Times-Dispatch, "Car-tax relief plan put on hold -- Gilmore cites recession, flat growth in state income," Nov. 16, 2011.

Richmond Times-Dispatch, "Tax fight: Government adrift?" May 13, 2001.

Richmond Times-Dispatch, "Car-tax fight: No exit in sight -- Senate rejects Gilmore plan a fourth time," May 8, 2001.

Richmond Times-Dispatch, "Budget deal doomed? -- Senate balks at bill passed by delegates," May 9, 2001.

Virginian-Pilot, "More budget gridlock may be on the way in 2002 over the car tax," June 23, 2001.

Virginian-Pilot, "State’s May revenues could prevent more cuts, Gilmore says," June 15, 2001.

Virginian-Pilot, "Stymied Va. lawmakers call it quits," May 10, 2001.

New York Times, "Senate passes $3.7 billion budget, setting up contentious negotiations," March 23, 2013.

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Sean Gorman

Cuccinelli says Virginia legislature has never failed to pass a budget

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up