As the gubernatorial campaign season gears up, Gov. Rick Scott and Charlie Crist are trading shots over their records on education spending, with each accusing the other of making bad decisions. One such series of volleys has been over college tuition.
"While Gov. Scott is fighting to keep college tuition low and has challenged all state colleges to offer $10,000 degrees to make college more affordable for Florida families, Charlie Crist signed into law an automatic 15 percent annual tuition increase that put college further out of reach for many Floridians," a campaign email to the media said on March 26, 2014. It preceded a Scott visit to Jefferson High School in Tampa, where Scott met with students to discuss college costs.
We wanted to see whether Crist approved automatic 15 percent tuition increases.
High cost of learning
Back in 2009, Sen. Ken Pruitt, R-Fort Pierce, sponsored a bill to increase tuition at all 11 state universities by up to 15 percent a year, an idea Crist supported. It was an extension of a plan approved by the Legislature in 2007 that allowed the largest state research universities to charge an annual increase up to 15 percent. (Prior that, the Legislature set undergraduate tutition with no cap, while the Board of Governors set graduate and out-of-state rates, not to exceed 15 percent over the previous year.)
The plan, known as tuition differential, allows universities to raise undergraduate tuition beyond any legislative base tuition hike as long as the total increase does not exceed 15 percent each year. The universities may keep raising tuition until reaching the national average, which for 2012-13 was $8,893. The Legislature approved the measure during the 2009 session. Crist signed both the budget and the differential law, which went into effect that year.
Prior to the announcement, Crist had been an opponent of hiking tuition, vetoing a 5 percent tuition increase in 2007 and opposing a plan for higher rates at some universities.
The argument for the increase was that Florida universities needed to raise tuition in order to pay for need-based scholarships, keep top professors and be competitive with other states -- Florida public universities were 45th in tuition costs in 2011 (the state was 43rd last year, according to the College Board). Some university officials have since complained that decreased post-secondary education funding from the Legislature has necessitated the need for massive tuition increases.
There are a couple of inaccuracies in the way Scott’s campaign worded its claim. First, the increase is not automatic. The Legislature sets base tuition each year. If the state budget doesn’t provide a base increase, tuition goes up at the rate of inflation. Individual universities then may ask the Florida Board of Governors for another increase, known as the tuition differential.
The base increase by the Legislature and the differential, if approved by the board, can total no more than 15 percent. It can be less, and has been several times since the 2009 law was passed. The final increase takes effect in the fall term of the year it is approved.
Lawmakers approved an 8 percent increase in 2009. The Board of Governors followed with a 7 percent differential increase, bringing the total to 15 percent. The Legislature and the board repeated the numbers in 2010 and 2011 -- 8 percent from Tallahassee, 7 percent from the board.
But in 2012, the Legislature did not set a base tuition increase. Instead of asking for the maximum allowable amount from the board, universities asked for a wide range of differential hikes. This was done in part to protest the continued cuts in state funding to universities.
The following year, Scott vetoed a 3 percent increase from the Legislature, and the Board of Governors voted to prevent universities to even raise fees, though students supported some of the hikes. Tuition statewide increased by an inflation-based 1.7 percent, which Scott had opposed. The governor appoints the Board of Governors and is allowed to voice his opinion in regards to the potential increase.
When we contacted Scott’s campaign, spokesman Greg Blair took responsibility for the remark, and admitted it was not worded correctly.
"It’s not automatic in the sense that it happens year over year no matter what," he told PolitiFact Florida. "However, it did take the increase out of the hands of the Legislature and the governor and allowed every school in Florida to raise tuition by 15 percent."
Scott’s campaign said in an email to reporters, "Charlie Crist signed into law an automatic 15 percent annual tuition increase."
It’s true that Crist did sign a law allowing tuition increases, but they were neither automatic nor always 15 percent. The legislation allowed the Board of Governors to supplement whatever increase lawmakers provided in the state budget by increasing tuition up to a total of 15 percent.
While the tuition differential was used to its fullest extent for several years, a Board of Governors vote was required each year. The governor has no say over what the board decides, but does pick the members. The amount by which the board has voted to change tuition has varied the past two years.
The statement is partially accurate, but leaves out important details. We rate it Half True.
Rick Scott for Florida campaign email to media, March 26, 2014
Tampa Bay Times, "Scott visits Tampa high school, blames Crist for college tuition increases," March 26, 2014
Tampa Bay Times, "Crist to announce plan to raise tuition statewide," Nov. 19. 2008
South Florida Sun-Sentinel, "Crist plan would let schools raise tuition up to 15 percent," Nov. 21, 2008
South Florida Sun-Sentinel, "Crist signs university tuition hike bill, vetoes delay for condo sprinklers," June 2, 2009
Miami Herald, "Florida's public universities set to hike tuition," June 14, 2010, accessed via Nexis
Tampa Bay Times Gradebook blog, "It's official, students to see 15 percent total tuition hike," June 23, 2011
PolitiFact Florida, "Florida ranks 45th in the nation for tuition costs, Denise Grimsley says," Feb. 27, 2012
Tampa Bay Times, "USF board votes to seek 11 percent tuition differential increase," June 14, 2012
Tampa Bay Times, "Without Scott's blessing, new tuition increases are all over the map," June 21, 2012
South Florida Sun-Sentinel, "Gov. Scott vetoes 3% tuition hike, $368M in projects," May 20, 2013
PolitiFact Florida, "Rick Scott 'increased tuition at our state colleges and universities by double digits,' Florida Democratic Party says," Aug. 2, 2013
Miami Herald, "With tuition rising slightly, Gov. Rick Scott asks board to be tough on fees," June 19, 2013
WFSU, "Board of Governors Rejects University Fee Hikes, OKs Tuition Increases," June 20, 2013
Palm Beach Post, "Gov. Scott to call for repeal of Florida’s differential tuition law," March 3, 2014
St. Augustine Record, "Scott seeks to end 15-percent tuition hikes," March 4, 2014, accessed via Nexis
College Board, "Trends in College Pricing 2013," accessed March 28, 2014
Florida Senate, Text of SB 1710, accessed March 28, 2014
Florida Board of Governors, State University System of Florida Tuition & Fees, accessed March 28, 2014
Florida Board of Governors, Tuition and Fees Fact Sheet, accessed March 28, 2014
VoteSmart.org, SB 762 - Allowing Universities to Levy "Tuition Differential" Charges, accessed March 28, 2014
Interview with Greg Blair, Rick Scott campaign spokesman, March 28, 2014
Interview with Brittany Davis, Florida Board of Governors spokeswoman, March 31, 2014
Interview with Steve Geller, informal adviser to Charlie Crist, April 1, 2014
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.