Morning Joe co-hosts Mika Brzezinski and Willie Geist tried a number of ways recently to get Howard Dean — former Democratic National Committee chairman and ardent Hillary Clinton supporter — to admit Clinton erred in using a private email server as secretary of state.
Each time, Dean stood firm in his support for the Democratic presidential candidate. Geist then asked Dean how he would feel about a Republican doing what Clinton did.
"Howard, is it fair to say if this were a Republican secretary of state, and someone you were not supporting for president," asked Geist, "you would be troubled by a secretary of state having a private email server in his or her home?"
"No, I wouldn’t," Dean replied, cutting Geist off, "because I used to do that as governor, and I know there’s a tremendous other number of public officials who have done the same thing."
Geist followed up, "And would only use a private server for State Department emails?"
Dean demurred, saying whatever she was done was within the constraints of the law at the time. (Whether Clinton violated State Department protocols or the law is unclear.)
We wanted to check Dean’s claim that he used a private server during his days in office and that the practice is widespread among politicians.
Clinton has drawn criticism for conducting government business through an email address privately hosted on a server at her home in Chappaqua, N.Y., instead of through the State Department's system.
On Morning Joe, Dean equated her actions with his own, as well as a "tremendous" other number of officials.
So we looked into Dean’s record for insight into his past email practices. We reached out to Dean through Democracy for America, the grassroots organizing group he founded, but didn’t get a response for the story.
Dean, who was governor of Vermont from 1991 through 2003, faced questions about his email in 2001 when a concerned citizen requested to see his correspondence with a ski resort developer, according to an article in the Rutland Herald.
Dean’s lawyers at the time said the emails were exempt from release because they were conducted through the governor’s private account. The article also mentions that Dean used neither a government-issued email address nor the computer supplied to him by the state. Vermont state archivist Tanya Marshall said Dean’s administration did not transfer any emails to the state records office at the end of his tenure.
So Dean clearly used a private email account while he was governor. But we could find no evidence that he used a private server as well. And there's a difference.
In fact, only one other politician is on record as doing the same: Clinton’s Republican presidential rival Jeb Bush.
Account vs. server
Many politicians use private addresses, but private servers like the one Clinton had in her basement are rarely seen, said John Wonderlich, a policy director of the Sunlight Foundation, a nonpartisan group focused on government transparency.
And there’s a big difference between a private account, which is generally free and simple to start, and a private server, which requires a more elaborate setup.
Two other presidential candidates, Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal and former Texas Gov. Rick Perry, used private email accounts hosted by large services like Google during their time in office. With services such as Gmail, messages they sent would have been stored on Google’s own servers around the world. While Google has a high level of security, email data stored on these kind of large commercial servers is often mined internally, for marketing purposes, for example, Wonderlich said.
The Atlantic speculated the Clintons "may have wanted to be in control of the encryption of their correspondence, ensuring that no third parties — whether commercial, hacker, or government — were able to snoop on them."
The unorthodox approach has opened up questions about her system’s level of security.
Because the server was set up outside the State Department’s proverbial security fence, "any protection … aside from the physical protection of the Secret Service — would have been limited to the Clintons’ own personal resources," according to a March 2015 article in Wired.
If the server was managed without the help of a third party, "you would have to have a staff that’s keeping up with all the latest fixes," said Clifford Neuman, director of the University of Southern California’s Center for Computer System Security.
"That can be hard with a small staff," he said.
Clinton’s campaign says she used the private account and server out of convenience, and that "it enabled her to reach people quickly and keep in regular touch with her family and friends more easily given her travel schedule."
While Clinton’s immediate predecessor, Condoleezza Rice, did not email extensively during her time in office, Colin Powell did use a private email address while he was secretary of state from 2001 to 2005. Powell, however, did not operate his own server.
In the context of discussing Hillary Clinton’s private email server for handling government business, Dean said, "I used to do that as governor, and I know there’s a tremendous other number of public officials who have done the same thing."
It’s possible that Dean was trying to say that many public officials have used private email accounts. But by failing to mention that Clinton also set up her own server, he completely misses the point of Geist’s question.
Besides Clinton, Jeb Bush is the only other official who used a personal server during his time in office. That does not speak to a "tremendous" trend.
We rate Dean’s claim Mostly False.
Morning Joe, Aug. 12, 2015
New York Times, "Key Events in the Hillary Clinton Email Controversy," July 2015
PolitiFact, "Four pressing questions about Hillary Clinton’s State Department email," Jul. 29, 2015
Rutland Herald, "Dean’s e-mails questioned," Nov. 12, 2001
ProPublica, "Email Escapades MuckReads Edition: Hillary is Just the Latest Politician to Avoid Official Email," March 13, 2015
Ars Technica, "How to run your own e-mail server with your own domain, part 1," Feb. 16, 2014
The Guardian, "Jeb Bush and Scott Walker among 2016 hopefuls who have used private emails," Mar. 7, 2015
PolitiFact Florida, "Jeb Bush edited his own emails, says liberal PAC," Mar. 13, 2015
The Atlantic, "How to Set Up a Clinton-Style Home Email Server," Mar. 16, 2015
Phone interview with John Wonderlich, policy director, Sunlight Foundation, Aug. 13, 2015
Phone and email interviews with Tanya Marshall, Vermont state archivist, Aug. 13, 2015
Email interview with Gregory Sanford, former Vermont state archivist, Aug. 13, 2015
Phone interview with Neil Sroka, communications director, Democracy for America, Aug. 12, 2015
Interview with Josh Schwerin, Hillary Clinton campaign spokesman, Aug. 17, 2015
Phone interview with Clifford Neuman, director, University of Southern California Center for Computer System Security, Aug. 17, 2015
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.