Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
A widespread Internet post claims Democratic presidential candidates Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders have opposing views on a number of issues, including the Trans-Pacific Partnership, a proposed trade deal involving the United States and 11 other nations.
The image says Sanders opposes the deal, but Clinton supports it.
As part of a couple of fact-checks on the post, we looked into whether the two candidates differ on support for the deal, which has divided Democratic leaders on the Hill.
President Barack Obama, the deal’s primary advocate, has sparred with Sen. Harry Reid, D-Nev., a longtime ally, and received praise from Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., a frequent opponent, over the deal.
So where do the leading Democratic presidential candidates stand on the Trans-Pacific Partnership?
Sanders sides with other members of the Senate’s progressive caucus in vehemently opposing the deal. In January 2014, he said he’s against it primarily because it will allow corporations to move jobs overseas.
Clinton’s position on the proposal is complicated by her time as secretary of state, and she’s been careful as a presidential candidate not to express a firm position.
There’s evidence to suggest Clinton was deeply involved in the deal’s formation and promotion as the country’s lead diplomat. In 2011, she told a congressional committee that even though the State Department was not in charge of the negotiations, "we work closely with the U.S. (Trade Representative)." Leaked diplomatic cables show Clinton’s deputies specifically discussed the TPP with foreign heads of state.
Clinton openly pushed for the deal at least 45 times during her tenure as secretary of state, according to CNN’s tally.
In 2012, she touted the trade deal, also called TPP, to a group of American and Australian officials as a way to "lower trade barriers, raise labor and environmental standards, and drive growth across the region."
But since entering the race for president, Clinton has distanced herself from those remarks.
"I did not work on TPP," she told reporters in July, saying the deal was "the responsibility of the United States Trade Representative."
At times, Clinton has echoed Sanders’ concerns about outsourcing.
"Any trade deal has to produce jobs and raise wages and increase prosperity and protect our security," she told a reporter from MSNBC in April. "We have to do our part in making sure we have the capabilities and the skills to be competitive. It's got to be really a partnership between our business, our government, our workforce, the intellectual property that comes out of our universities, and we have to get back to a much more focused effort in my opinion to try to produce those capacities here at home so that we can be competitive in a global economy."
Hopeful comments about job creation and increased wages do not signal a clear position on the Trans-Pacific Partnership.
Clinton’s campaign website lists no official position on the deal.
The graphic claims Bernie Sanders opposes the Trans-Pacific Partnership, and Hillary Clinton supports it.
Sanders has said on multiple occasions that he would oppose the trade deal. Clinton supported it as secretary of state, and there’s even evidence to suggest she was an advocate for the deal within the Obama administration. But she has taken a neutral stance on the deal during her campaign for the presidency, voicing some of Sanders’ same concerns yet refusing to explicitly criticize the proposal.
Clinton spoke often in support of the Trans-Pacific Partnership — until that backing irritated parts of her Democratic base.
We rate the post’s claim Mostly True.
Huffington Post, "Harry Reid Calls Trade Push By Obama And GOP 'Insanity'," May 20, 2015
Huffington Post, "Mitch McConnell Says Obama 'Has Done An Excellent Job' Pushing Trade Deal," May 17, 2015
Sen. Bernie Sanders, "The Trans-Pacific Trade Trade (TPP) Agreement Must Be Defeated," 2014
The Atlantic, "Hillary Clinton’s Hard Choice on Free Trade," Apr. 23, 2015
Bloomberg Politics, "Courting Unions, Hillary Clinton Says She Didn't Work on Trans-Pacific Partnership," Jul. 30, 2015
CNN Politics, "45 times Hillary Clinton pushed the trade bill she now opposes," Jun. 15, 2015
Wikileaks.org, "Deputy Secretary Steinberg's September 27, 2009 Meeting With Deputy Foreign Minister Pham Binh Minh," Sep. 27, 2009
International Business Times, "Cables Show Hillary Clinton's State Department Deeply Involved in Trans-Pacific Partnership," Jul. 31, 2015
Email interview with Warren Gunnels, Bernie 2016, Aug. 27, 2015
Email interview with Josh Schwerin, Hillary for America, Aug. 27, 2015
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.