Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Job creation was one of the main issues in Gov. Nathan Deal’s successful re-election bid last year, with wins from the state’s focus on recruiting automakers a key element of the talk.
Years of effort paid off with big headlines when Porsche North America expanded its headquarters here.
The headlines got bigger earlier this year when Mercedes-Benz announced metro Atlanta would become the new home of its U.S. headquarters.
But in May, the tone of the big news changed when Volvo rejected Georgia and went with South Carolina for a new $500 million factory that will employ 4,000 workers.
State leaders were disappointed but called it a speed bump, not a crash, and pledged to focus on other economic development projects.
This month, Deal’s chief of staff, Chris Riley, repeated the point. Since the May 11 Volvo announcement, Riley said those other projects have brought more than $800 million in investments and the promise of 3,455 jobs.
"Sometimes the home runs look good," Riley said. "But it’s the singles and doubles that really add up."
Mixed sports and driving metaphors aside, did Georgia really manage to bring in even more investment than the Volvo factory promised? We wanted to see the details.
Riley was unavailable for comment, but a spokeswoman for Deal’s office said the governor’s top aide drew the numbers from the state’s Department of Economic Development.
The agency is responsible for planning and mobilizing state incentives and other resources to attract new business and expand existing operations.
The big pitches generate big numbers, in dollars and in jobs, and big headlines. With Mercedes-Benz, for instance, the state offered an incentives package worth $23.3 million.
Taken with Fulton County’s property tax break worth $4 million for the next decade, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution calculated that package translated into incentives of $28,750 per job for the 950 total employees that will work in the new Sandy Springs headquarters.
The smaller headlines, if they made news at all, were the smaller projects that Riley mentioned.
The Economic Development Department keeps track of all of its work, though it only announces named projects when firms agree. Some expansions, for instance, are kept mum so competitors don’t learn of investments that put a firm at a disadvantage, department spokeswoman Stefanie Paupeck Harper said.
But the department showed PolitiFact Georgia its tally, broken down by region and type of work when firm names are not released.
Between May 11 and Riley’s statement, the department tallied 3,728 jobs – or 273 more than Riley claimed.
Of that total, 300 came on the same day that Volvo spurned Georgia. Half of them are with an unnamed food processing expansion project in the 10-county region south and west of metro Atlanta.
Named on the list: 100 manufacturing jobs coming with the expansion of MI Metals in Jenkins County; 100 software/tech jobs from Courion moving its headquarters from Massachusetts to Roswell; 200 automotive manufacturing jobs coming with German auto supplier NIFCO KTW’s construction of a plant in Toccoa; and 400 software jobs with the expansion of the Brazilian IT provider Stefanini in Atlanta.
We found one error in the tally. The Economic Development Department counts 450 jobs with the relocation of Sage, a British software firm, while the official press releases list 400 jobs.
Yet even without those 50 jobs, the tally grew to 3,871 jobs and $902 million in investment by the time we talked to Chris Carr, the state economic development commissioner, on July 23.
Among the latest jobs: 120 positions (and $5.5 million in investment) with the relocation of the Dutch firm CSM Bakery Solutions to Sandy Springs.
"Obviously, we tried to be aggressive with Volvo, but we are aggressive with smaller companies, too, because with the different regions, the impact is seen all over Georgia," Carr said. "It’s a fun thing to watch."
That means the data back up Riley's claim, with one notable caveat.
All the projects must invest and hire as promised to receive the incentives, but the timelines vary based on the project, Carr said.
None of those extend beyond about eight years, Carr said.
But the different deals mean that Georgia has not added nearly twice as many jobs since March, when Volvo said it was going to South Carolina.
Then again, it’s not as if Volvo has already set up shop in the Palmetto State and added those jobs. It has years to get to its promise, known in the paperwork as "up to 4,000 jobs."
So, in that frame, it means Riley was comparing apples to apples when he made his claim.
And the point, Deal spokesman Brian Robinson said, was clear.
"We all love the megadeals. They spread news about our state and our great business climate here," Robinson said.
"But the jobs that don’t make the headlines present just as much economic security and opportunity for some Georgians, somewhere," he added. "Every Georgian has a stake in each one of these deals."
State officials promised that Georgia’s momentum for attracting new business would not falter following the loss of a $500 million Volvo plant to rival South Carolina in May.
Gov. Nathan Deal’s chief of staff said in July that smaller deals since the Volvo project have led to the promise of 3,455 jobs and $800 million in investment statewide.
State economic development data show Chris Riley was low in his tally. Even with an error in the data, Georgia can count nearly as many jobs and significantly more in investment than was promised by Volvo.
We rate his claim True.
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, Political Insider blog, July 17, 2015
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "Georgia’s ‘aggressive’ Volvo pitch falls short," May 11, 2015
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "State incentives to Mercedes: $29K per job," Jan. 13, 2015
Georgia Department of Economic Development, Regional Services Map, accessed July 24, 2015
Office of Gov. Nathan Deal, press releases, MI Metals to create 100 jobs in Jenkins County, May 13, 2015
Atlanta Business Chronicle, "Courion moves international HQ to Roswell, will add 100 jobs," June 3, 2015
Office of Gov. Nathan Deal, press releases, Deal announces 200 automotive parts manufacturing jobs in Stephens County, June 9, 2015
Office of Gov. Nathan Deal, press releases, Sage to put North American HQ in Atlanta, June 12, 2015
Office of Gov. Nathan Deal, press releases, Brazilian IT service provider to create 400 jobs in Atlanta, June 17, 2015
Office of Gov. Nathan Deal, press releases, CSM Bakery Solutions to relocate to Sandy Springs, July 21, 2015
Review of Located Projects, Georgia Department of Economic Development, May 11 to July 24, 2015
Interview, Chris Carr, commissioner, Georgia Department of Economic Development, July 23, 2015
Interview with Stefanie Paupeck Harper, spokeswoman, Georgia Department of Economic Development, July 23 and July 24, 2015
Interview with Brian Robinson, spokesman, Office of Governor Nathan Deal, July 24, 2015
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.