A group backed by the Koch brothers is arguing a proposed constitutional amendment that would change Florida solar energy regulations will lead the Sunshine State down a dark path.
Americans For Prosperity Florida says a petition being circulated by solar advocates Floridians for Solar Choice is the wrong move for the state, and will result in higher costs and decreased competition.
The proposal needs nearly 700,000 signatures to get on the 2016 ballot, allowing voters to decide on an amendment that would change current Florida law that says customers can only buy electricity from a utility. If the amendment is approved, customers could buy electricity from solar installers and not just utility companies. We’ve written about it before here.
At a March 10, 2015, news conference, AFP members said the amendment was misguided. They backed up their point of view by implying Georgia’s solar policies are "burdensome and expensive government mandates" that shouldn’t be emulated, and cited a Louisiana study that solar power would be very expensive to implement.
AFP Florida followed up the conference with a release that read, "In Georgia, similar net metering policies have resulted in rate hikes and did not result in solar becoming any more economically viable."
Is it true that energy regulations in Georgia -- often cited as a leader in implementing new solar policies -- have made electric rates go up? Time to rate the rates.
It turns out we’ll be taking a quick look at Louisiana, too, because that’s the state AFP meant to name when citing net metering. They apologized and said they would correct the release, thanking PolitiFact for pointing out the error. We’ll be discussing both states for this check.
What is net metering, anyway? In simplest terms, it’s the process of selling self-generated electricity, such as the power made by solar panels on your house, back to a utility company for a credit. The proposed Florida amendment doesn’t really concern itself with that, but rather removes a roadblock to buying power from someone other than a registered electric provider, like Duke Energy or Florida Power & Light. Right now, if a solar provider wants to sell its power, it must sell it to one of these utilities.
Critics say being able to end this monopoly is key to expanding solar efforts in Florida, which is ranked 13th in solar installations by the Solar Energy Industries Association. Florida also is one of five states that specifically outlaw buying solar power directly from a provider. The others are Kentucky, North Carolina, Oklahoma and Georgia.
While Georgia isn’t trying to open the market the same way the Florida amendment would, the Peach State is enjoying its own moment in the sunshine on the subject of solar.
The state in 2008 offered homeowner tax credits to boost solar installations, a program that expired in 2014.The Georgia Public Service Commission worked with the state’s largest utility, Georgia Power, to create the Georgia Power Advanced Solar Initiative in 2012.
The utility created programs to let businesses and homeowners sell solar energy to Georgia Power, as well as working out power-purchase agreements with big solar developers. The plan has been called a success by advocates, the state’s PSC and electric providers, and plans for expanding the amount of solar power in the state are in the works.
Georgia Power has said there has been no "upward pressure on consumer rates." Spokesman John Kraft told PolitiFact Florida that from the beginning, part of the initiative was that the company would be able to buy solar-generated electricity at or below rates it would cost the company for traditional means, such as electricity generated by burning fossil fuels or using nuclear power. The program was voluntary from the beginning and not a state mandate.
"There isn’t a regulation per se that says you have to do this amount," Kraft said. "The PSC had been asking us for ways to do more solar."
So what about Louisiana? AFP Florida told us that’s really the place that saw higher electric rates because of solar policies. They cited a 2015 study for the Louisiana Public Service Commission, which was debating what to charge solar power customers for electricity. The report focused on the state’s 50 percent tax credit for installing new solar panels, and said those credits cost the state at least $89 million.
The study became controversial because the study’s author -- consultant and Louisiana State University energy studies professor David Dismukes -- had written favorably about the oil and gas industries before. Solar advocates called the report biased for not focusing on the jobs the industry had created and misrepresenting how the state’s tax credits work.
Setting aside the controversy over the study, Louisiana customers outside of New Orleans did see a base rate hike in 2014, which cost the average ratepayer about 47 cents per month. But that increase was approved by the PSC in 2013 and was over several issues, including the cost of maintaining an aging power grid. Electric utility company Entergy did not specifically mention solar as being an issue when announcing the base rate change.
Last year, Louisiana voted to end its 50 percent tax credit for solar installations in 2017. Gov. Bobby Jindal is considering cutting it sooner to fill a $1.6 billion budget gap this year.
So while Louisiana did see a rate increase, we don’t see evidence that it was specifically related to a solar initiative.
Americans for Prosperity Florida said recent solar energy policies in Georgia "have resulted in rate hikes and did not result in solar becoming any more economically viable."
The group admitted it meant to say Louisiana, which is having its own debate on the issue. But the program in Georgia is thriving. Part of Georgia's implementation plan was that using solar power wouldn’t affect rates, and it hasn’t, Georgia’s largest utility said. Louisiana did see a rate increase, but it doesn't seem to be specifically related to a solar initiative.
The statement is completely wrong. We rate it Pants on Fire.
Americans For Prosperity, "Proposed solar policies are not free market," March 10, 2015
YouTube, "Americans For Prosperity Press Conference," March 10, 2015
Augusta Chronicle, "Georgia Power price plan rattles solar companies," Sept. 13, 2014
New Orleans Times-Picayune, "Entergy Louisiana proposes raising residential electric rates by $8 per month," Feb. 15, 2013
Entergy Louisiana LLC, "Settlements of Electric Base Rate Cases Approved for Entergy’s Louisiana Utilities," Dec. 16, 2013
Augusta Chronicle, "Georgia Power rate hike approved, costing average customer $100 a year by 2016," Dec. 18, 2013
Louisiana Weekly, "Some Louisiana customers to see Entergy rates increase," Dec. 23, 2013
Georgia Power, "Georgia Power publishes draft RFP for 2014 Advanced Solar Initiative," Dec. 26, 2013
Utility Dive, "How Georgia Power became a top 10 solar utility," May 22, 2014
New Orleans Times-Picayune, "Consultant tapped for state solar study too close to fossil fuels industry, companies say," July 1, 2014
Athens Banner-Herald, "Georgia Power unveils plan to more than triple the state's solar power," Sept. 26, 2012
New Orleans Times-Picayune, "Entergy rates rising for customers outside New Orleans," Dec. 1, 2014
The Advocate, "Giving Away Louisiana: Solar energy tax credit," Dec. 6, 2014
PolitiFact Florida, "Florida is one of five states that ban certain solar sales, petition group says," Jan. 16, 2015
Tampa Bay Times, "Florida utilities say solar doesn't work in the Sunshine State, but it sure does in Georgia," Jan. 30, 2015
Louisiana Public Service Commission, "Estimating the Impact of Net Metering on LPSC Jurisdictional Ratepayers," Feb. 27, 2015
Charlotte Business Journal, "Utility says latest delays to Georgia nuclear plant to cost additional $1B," March 2, 2015
WWLTV, "Commissioner uses study to attack solar subsidies," March 5, 2015
PR Newswire, "Louisiana Solar Industry Responds to Unorthodox Solar Net Metering Study," March 10, 2015
Atlanta Business Chronicle, "PSC signs off on more solar power," March 17, 2015
Tampa Bay Times, "The Koch brothers say solar energy will flop; Georgia says they're wrong," March 18, 2015
Acadiana Business, "Big Oil's behind-the-scenes role in LSU's 'legacy lawsuit' study," March 19, 2015
Floridians for Solar Choice, Constitutional amendment form, accessed March 19, 2015
Interview with Susan Glickman, Southern Alliance for Clean Energy Florida director, March 18-19, 2015
Interview with Ken Johnson, Solar Energy Industries Association spokesman, March 19, 2015
Interview with Jennifer Rennicks, Floridians for Solar Choice spokeswoman, March 19, 2015
Interview with john Kraft, Georgia Power spokesman, March 20, 2015
Interview with Andres Malave, Americans For Prosperity Florida spokesman, March 19-20, 2015
Interview with Debbie Dooley, Conservatives For Energy Freedom founder, March 19, 2015
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.