Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
Looking to take over former presidential candidate Marco Rubio’s soon-to-be-vacant Senate seat, U.S. Rep. David Jolly wants to educate voters about his conservative bona fides in Congress — including his opposition to Common Core.
The Indian Shores Republican has been in the House of Representatives for two years after winning a 2014 special election to replace his mentor, the late Rep. C.W. Bill Young. In that short span, he said, he has helped change federal education policy.
"Last year, I worked with my colleagues to end funding for federal Race to the Top grants, which require participating states to adopt the Common Core standards as a condition for receiving federal funding," he said on his campaign website.
The Common Core State Standards are a set of shared guidelines in English and math designed to prepare students for college and to unify educational goals nationwide. They’ve become an unpopular subject with many conservatives.
We decided to test Jolly’s assertion that states had to adopt the Common Core in order to win federal grants.
Race to the Top
Our lesson begins with a primer on Common Core.
In 2007, the Council of Chief State School Officers considered creating state-based standards that could be shared nationwide. The idea was that a high school diploma from Tennessee would then have the same value as one from Idaho or New Mexico.
Two years later, the council and the National Governors Association agreed to develop what was called Common Core with input from teachers, parents and education experts.
President Barack Obama’s signature education program, Race to the Top, invited states to compete for grant money from the 2009 federal economic stimulus. States had to show they were committed to improving educational standards and performance and implement reforms to win the cash.
The final Common Core guidelines came out in 2010, and states could decide to use them or ignore them. Forty-five states decided to accept the standards. Minnesota adopted the English standards, but not the math guidelines. Indiana, Oklahoma and South Carolina agreed to use Common Core at first, but later backed off the plan.
Jolly’s assertion is that the application process demanded states adopt Common Core to get a grant. That isn’t the case. Committing to Common Core was not a stipulation of winning a grant, but it did factor into the application process.
The Education Department gave states that had adopted a set of standards extra points (40 of a possible 500) when competing for grants. The shorthand was, if you had adopted Common Core, you had a better chance at hitting the federal grant lottery.
Jolly’s campaign pointed out the guidelines for the grant process that said applicants had to show a "commitment to adopting a common set of high-quality standards." They reasoned that almost all of the 19 eventual grant winners (including Florida, which won $700 million in August 2010) had adopted Common Core before winning grants.
But experts told us there was no demand that states adopt Common Core before Washington would hand over funding. And even then, there was no requirement for actually implementing them.
Delaware, for example, won its grant in March 2010, but didn’t adopt Common Core until August of that year. Tennessee also won in March 2010, but adopted them in July of that year.
Daniel Thatcher, a senior policy specialist at the National Conference of State Legislatures, said Washington has subsequently been accused of coercing states into adopting Common Core. In 2015, a federal judge rejected former Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal’s coercion claims in a lawsuit he brought against the Education Department, which his successor has since ended.
Common Core did have supporters in Washington, although they often were careful about not using the term Common Core. But many state legislators and teachers unions and education reformers approved of Common Core at the time, too. (For the record, even Jindal once was a Common Core advocate before changing his mind and suing the federal government.)
"For any single state, it's difficult to know whether Race to the Top merely rewarded an applicant for doing something it was already inclined to do, or whether the competition changed behavior in any material way," University of Chicago political science professor William Howell said in an email.
He noted the timing of the grants during the recession may have potentially spurred some states into action to shore up finances, leading them to adopt Common Core to get a leg up.
"It's hard not to conclude that features of the competition were at least partially responsible," Howell said.
His campaign said Jolly helped keep funding out of the following year’s bill after he joined the House Appropriations Committee in January 2015. Obama did not ask for Race to the Top funding in his FY 2016 budget proposal. The remaining funds for the grant program expired in September 2015.
In December 2015, Jolly also voted in favor of the Every Student Succeeds Act. That bill, signed by Obama, specifically said the Secretary of Education "shall not attempt to influence, incentivize, or coerce State adoption of the Common Core State Standards."
Jolly said Race to the Top grants "require participating states to adopt the Common Core standards as a condition for receiving federal funding."
Adopting education guidelines — Common Core or otherwise — was an element of a state’s overall application score and would add to point totals. Common Core critics have since accused Washington of coercing states.
But there was no concrete requirement to adopt standards in exchange for grant money. Experts told us the promise of federal money during the recession may have spurred Common Core adoption in some places, but there’s no way to know that for sure.
We rate Jolly’s statement Mostly False.
U.S. Rep. David Jolly, On the Issues: Education, accessed April 4, 2016
WhiteHouse.gov, "Fact Sheet: The Race to the Top," Nov. 4, 2009
U.S. Department of Education, "Delaware and Tennessee Win First Race to The Top Grants," March 29, 2010
Tampa Bay Times, "In stunner, Florida doesn't win Race to the Top education grant," March 29, 2010
Federal Register, "Race to the Top Fund: Notice Inviting Applications for New Awards for Fiscal Year (FY) 2010," April 14, 2010
U.S. Department of Education, "Race to the Top Program Guidance and Frequently Asked Questions," May 27, 2010
Tampa Bay Times, "Florida wins $700 million in federal grant money," Aug. 24, 2010
National Conference on State Legislatures, "For the Common Good?," September 2010
PolitiFact Wisconsin, "How much is the federal government involved in the Common Core school standards?," Oct. 24, 2013
Tampa Bay Times, "Florida Board of Education approves Common Core tweaks during heated meeting," Feb. 18, 2014
U.S. News & World Report, "Common Core: Myths and Facts," March 4, 2014
PolitiFact Florida, "Florida has been teaching Common Core since 2010, says Janet Adkins," March 28, 2014
Washington Post, "How Bill Gates pulled off the swift Common Core revolution," June 7, 2014
Washington Post, "How Arne Duncan talked about Common Core without mentioning ‘Common Core’," June 24, 2014
PolitiFact Wisconsin, "Federal government required states to adopt Common Core school standards, congressional hopeful says," July 25, 2014
U.S. News & World Report, "Jindal Sues Obama Administration Over Common Core," Aug. 27, 2014
Tampa Bay Business Journal, "Jolly gets seat on critical U.S. House appropriations committee," Nov. 20, 2014
Washington Post, "Obama’s Race to the Top loses all funding in 2015 omnibus spending bill," Dec. 10, 2014
Washington Post, "What’s in the spending bill? We skim it so you don’t have to," Dec. 10, 2014
New York Times, "House Narrowly Passes Bill to Avoid Shutdown; $1.1 Trillion in Spending," Dec. 11, 2014
U.S. House of Representatives, Roll call vote 563, Dec. 11, 2014
Government Printing Office, FY 2016 proposed budget, February 2015
Washington Examiner, "Obama's budget abandons Race to the Top," Feb. 2, 2015
Education Week, "Evaluating Race to the Top As It Nears the Finish Line," April 13, 2015
National Conference on State Legislatures, "Common Core State Standards FAQ," May 13, 2015
PolitiFact, "Bobby Jindal's change of position on Common Core," June 8, 2015
Education Week, "A 'Common-Core Math' Problem: How Many States Have Adopted the Standards?," June 30, 2015
Politico New York, "As Race To The Top ends, controversy continues," July 16, 2015
Education Next, "Results of President Obama’s Race to the Top," Fall 2015
Associated Press, "Judge rules against Bobby Jindal's Common Core suit," Oct. 21, 2015
U.S. House of Representatives, Roll call vote 665, Dec. 2, 2015
FiveThirtyEight, "How Arne Duncan Lost The Common Core And His Legacy," Dec. 10, 2015
USA Today, "The Every Student Succeeds Act vs. No Child Left Behind: What's changed?," Dec. 11, 2015
Associated Press, "Jindal lawsuit against Common Core scrapped by new governor," Feb. 4, 2016
PolitiFact Arizona, "Is Common Core no more?," Feb. 29, 2016
PolitiFact, "Common Core is 'education through Washington, D.C.,' Trump says," March 10, 2016
U.S. Department of Education, "Education Department Releases Proposals for Consideration by ESSA Negotiated Rulemaking Committee," April 1, 2016
U.S. Department of Education, "Race to the Top Fund," accessed April 5, 2016
Congress.gov, "H.R.83 - Consolidated and Further Continuing Appropriations Act, 2015," accessed April 5, 2016
AcademicBenchmarks.com, "Common Core State Standards Adoption Map," accessed April 5, 2016
U.S. Department of Education, "Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA)," accessed April 7, 2016
Interview with William Howell, University of Chicago political science professor, April 6, 2016
Interview with Daniel Thatcher, National Conference of State Legislatures senior policy specialist, April 5-6, 2016
Interview with Dorie Nolt, U.S. Department of Education spokeswoman, April 5 & 7, 2016
Interview with Max Goodman, Jolly campaign spokesman, April 7, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.