Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
At a Senate campaign debate with U.S. Rep. David Jolly, R-Indian Shores, in Orlando on April 25, 2016, Grayson said the Social Security payroll tax cap on earnings needs to be lifted in order to make the program solvent. He used the mind-boggling salary of professional basketball superstar LeBron James to illustrate his point.
"Let's talk about LeBron James. Do you know when he stops paying his Social Security taxes? He stops paying his Social Security taxes at the beginning of the second quarter of the first game of the season," Grayson said. "Rest of the game, pays nothing. Rest of the 81 games of the season, pays nothing. The offseason, still pays nothing. That's ridiculous."
The Cleveland Cavaliers forward rakes in an average of $23.5 million per year as part of his current two-year contract, so it’s not like he’s going to depend on Social Security in his twilight years.
But is Grayson right that James is done paying into the program before halftime of the first game of the season? It’s not a slam dunk, but the Orlando Democrat does score points with this one.
Let’s start by reviewing what Grayson is talking about. The federal government imposes a payroll tax of 6.2 percent on wages to pay into the Social Security fund. But there’s a limit of how much income can be taxed. This maximum amount, which is periodically adjusted upward, was $118,500 in 2016.
That means the most any employed person pays into Social Security annually is $7,347 (6.2 percent of $118,500). If you make less than $118,500, you obviously are taxed on that amount and pay less. Employers match that amount, so a single worker’s total contribution to Social Security is essentially a maximum of $14,694 per year. Benefits, for the record, also are capped.
In the case of self-employment, the person pays both halves of the $14,694 contribution, or 12.4 percent of $118,500. We’ll come back to this in a moment.
If you make more than $118,500 in salary from an employer — say, $23.5 million or so — you’re still only on the hook for taxes on the maximum of $118,500. That’s the highest amount on which the government can tax anyone, LeBron James or otherwise.
Grayson has said that this limit is exacerbating projected Social Security deficits as more people retire. Not only would lifting this cap keep the program solvent, it would allow the government to increase benefits for seniors. President Barack Obama also has proposed lifting this cap, which has rated a Promise Broken on our Obameter. Some argue that raising the maximum taxable wage base wouldn’t fix the system on its own.
For his James example, Grayson broke down the NBA 82 regular-season games into their 328 respective quarters, then divided that against James’ $23.5 million average salary. That amounts to $71,646.34 per quarter, which is almost $6,000 per minute, with 12-minute quarters. Not bad for a night’s work.
Using that math, James hits the $118,500 taxable earnings cap somewhere before the eighth minute of the second quarter of the first game of the season. You’re probably only on your second (maybe third) $11 beer by then.
Now, this interpretation is obviously just to make Grayson’s point easier to understand. It’s kind of like Tax Freedom Day, ostensibly the day people earn enough to pay their total tax bill. How James gets paid depends on the structure of his contract.
We'll also note that the NBA season starts in October, with the playoffs running through June. The tax year starts Jan. 1 and runs the calendar year. That makes the actual timing of when taxes are deducted from James' pay different than what Grayson said — a minor detail in a broad example. The Cavaliers' first game of 2016 was on Jan. 2, and was their 31st contest of the 2015-16 season. They beat the Orlando Magic, 104-79, by the way.
It may sound minor to those of us not making millions annually, but while Grayson is sticking to the game clock, he understates James’ time commitment. This example doesn’t include the hours James spends practicing, traveling, giving interviews, attending team events or anything else that goes along with a superstar athlete’s life. It also doesn’t include preseason games, overtime, playoff games (which bring in more money) or the value of his endorsements, which Forbes estimated at $48 million.
PKF O’Connor Davies sports accountant Robert Raiola also cautions that Grayson’s example doesn’t mention other taxes James must pay. Raiola pointed out James faces a 1.45 percent Medicare tax that includes no cap, plus a 0.9 percent Medicare surcharge on all the income he makes over $250,000. Which is a lot.
And don’t forget that self-employment tax. James possibly also must pay that in some form, depending on how his income is structured, Raiola said. How that affects James depends on how he conducts his finances, so it’s not really possible to say without getting a peek into his books.
(LeBron, if you’re reading, email us and we’ll talk.)
But Grayson’s talking point — that no matter how much the mega-rich earn, they are only taxed on the maximum of $118,500 in income — holds up. If you make less than that, you pay less, but James isn’t required to pay Social Security payroll taxes on his income beyond $118,500.
Grayson said James "stops paying his Social Security taxes at the beginning of the second quarter of the first game of the season."
That’s a broad statement meant to draw attention to the fact that Social Security taxes are capped at $118,500 of a person’s income, no matter how much they make. There are a lot of factors that go into how much James is paid, and how much of that goes to various taxes. But the bottom line is that the athlete only faces Social Security taxes for a relative sliver of his income.
We rate the statement Mostly True.
UPDATE, April 28: An astute reader pointed out a minor flaw in Grayson's specific talking point. The NBA season starts in the fall, while the tax year begins Jan. 1. As such, James hypothetically would hit the threshold in the second quarter of the first game he played in the new calendar year, not the first game of the season. We've added that information to this story. But Grayson's point that the uber-wealthy quickly hit the Social Security tax cap remains just as valid.
U.S. Rep. Alan Grayson, "Florida Open Debate Live," April 25, 2016
New York Times, "For Social Security, A Birthday Makeover; Employers Should Pay Up," Aug. 22, 2010
PolitiFact, "The Obameter: Lift the payroll tax cap on earnings above $250,000," April 30, 2012
National Review, "Eight Reasons We Shouldn’t Raise the Cap on Social Security Taxes," Feb. 25, 2015
The Motley Fool, "What Is the Maximum Social Security Tax for 2015?," Jan. 12, 2016
Forbes, "LeBron James Tops The NBA's Highest-Paid Players 2016," Jan. 20, 2016
The Motley Fool, "Here's How Bernie Sanders Plans to Fix Social Security," Jan. 24, 2016
Tampa Bay Times Buzz blog, "Alan Grayson endorses Bernie Sanders," Feb. 29, 2016
Internal Revenue Service, "Questions and Answers for the Additional Medicare Tax," accessed April 27, 2016
Internal Revenue Service, "Social Security and Medicare Withholding Rates," accessed April 27, 2016
Internal Revenue Service, "Self-Employment Tax (Social Security and Medicare Taxes)," accessed April 27, 2016
Spotrac.com, LeBron James: Current contract, accessed April 27, 2016
Social Security Administration, "Benefits Planner: Maximum Taxable Earnings (1937 - 2016)," accessed April 27, 2016
Larry Coon’s NBA Salary Cap FAQ, 2011 Collective Bargaining Agreement, accessed April 27, 2016
Social Security Administration, "2016 Social Security Changes," accessed April 27, 2016
ESPN, NBA salaries, accessed April 27, 2016
Interview with David Damron, Grayson campaign spokesman, April 27, 2016
Interview with Robert Raiola, PKF O’Connor Davies accountant, April 27, 2016
Interview with Patti Patterson, Social Security Administration spokeswoman, April 27, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.