Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
As the battle over who should be able to use what bathroom rages on in North Carolina and nationwide, opponents of transgender-friendly rules say public opinion is on their side.
Tim Moore, the speaker of the N.C. House of Representatives, said it’s an overwhelming consensus.
"The one thing where we’ve seen nearly unanimous – well, nothing’s unanimous – but 80 percent support out there is the concept that men should not be in women’s restrooms, changing rooms, bathrooms, et cetera – that that shouldn’t happen," Moore said in a May 5 discussion with reporters.
We looked into polling on bathroom policy and found a wide range of results. Most don’t reach 80 percent, but clearly substantial numbers of people in North Carolina have told pollsters they oppose letting transgender people choose what bathroom to use.
Polls have found safety concerns are also on some people’s minds.
No one can say that there will never be any privacy or safety issues – of course there could be. But in a previous fact check, we looked for instances of sexual predators using the cover of transgender-friendly bathroom laws to dress up as the other sex and prey on people in bathrooms, the scenario many have said they’re concerned about.
We found it Mostly True that such a scenario has never happened. We didn’t give it a True because there have been a few unproven allegations in the U.S. and one conviction in Canada.
The Obama administration also hasn’t put stock in those concerns, and has said banning transgender people from the bathroom of the gender with which they identify is a civil rights violation.
It was in that context, along with the administration’s threat to withhold federal funding from North Carolina, that Moore made his "nearly unanimous," "80 percent" claim.
We did find one poll from the conservative Raleigh-based Civitas Institute that was close to backing up Moore’s claim. We’re not sure if it’s the poll he was citing or if he was citing a poll at all – Moore didn’t respond to our questions – but we’ll proceed anyway.
The poll asked: "Do you agree or disagree with a Virginia federal court ruling ordering girls and boys in public middle schools to share locker room, bathroom and shower facilities?
The poll did find that 80 percent of people said they disagreed with the court ruling. However, we have several issues with the question.
The question is not only leading and inflammatory but also fundamentally misconstrues what the court ruled.
No boys and girls were ordered to shower, change or use the bathroom together. Instead, a federal appeals court ruled that a judge in Virginia had to reconsider a transgender boy’s request to use the boys’ facilities at school.
The court also said the Obama administration acted legally in defining sex-based discrimination to include discrimination against transgender people. That’s the part that may have given rise to the poll question’s wording, since the student is likely to win now.
Yet the Obama administration has repeatedly said that although schools should recognize transgender students’ rights, schools should also recognize other students’ right to privacy and that no student should be forced to openly share a changing area.
In school districts around the country that have already recognized transgender students’ gender identities, officials have typically put private stalls in locker rooms and/or offered unisex one-person bathrooms.
Given the issues with that question, let’s look at another. Another earlier poll from Civitas asked people a more accurate and nuanced question about transgender people in bathrooms, describing the arguments on both sides. This poll came before the state overturned Charlotte’s LGBT ordinance.
"The Charlotte City Council passed a new bathroom ordinance for transgender people that allows biological men and biological women, who identify as the opposite sex, to use the bathroom or locker room of their choosing," the question stated, asking people to pick sides.
Nearly 70 percent said they opposed the idea. Not 80 percent, but close.
But what about polls from groups with less political bias?
According to a joint poll from SurveyUSA in partnership with Time Warner Cable News, 51 percent of North Carolinians think transgender people should not be able to choose which bathroom to use. That’s not "nearly unanimous" like Moore said; it’s barely a majority.
Another joint poll from SurveyUSA and a different TV station, WRAL, found 56 percent in agreement that transgender people shouldn’t be able to choose which bathroom to use – again, a majority, but not close to 80 percent.
A prominent conservative group, Civitas, did find 70 and 80 percent in two polls, although we had some serious doubts about the question that found the 80 percent support.
Two polls from the less partisan SurveyUSA in partnership with local TV stations have found 56 percent and 51 percent of North Carolinians support the idea. That’s still a majority, but it’s certainly not the "nearly unanimous," "80 percent support" that Moore claimed.
We rate this claim Half True.https://www.sharethefacts.co/share/49f0e634-7574-479d-ae14-5c89d8dee47e
The Chicago Daily Herald, Jan. 15, 2016 "Transgender student gains locker room access at Fremd High School"
The Los Angeles Times, Feb. 11, 2016, "Transgender student's use of locker room causes stir at San Diego high school"
The News & Observer, May 13, 2016, "US gives directive to schools on transgender bathroom access"
NC Civitas Poll, April 2016 results
NC Civitas Poll, March 2016 results
The New York Times, April 19, 2016, "Appeals Court Favors Transgender Student in Virginia Restroom Case"
Time Warner Cable News Central NC and SurveyUSA poll, May 13, 2016, "Exclusive Poll: Majority of Voters Approve of Overturning Charlotte Anti-Discrimination Ordinance"
WRAL-TV and SurveyUSA poll, April 12, 2016, "NC Voters Continue to Wrestle With HB2 Fallout: Majority in State Now Opposes New 'Bathroom' Law in General, But Supports Specific Birth-Gender Provision"
U.S. Department of Education Office for Civil Rights memo, Dec. 1, 2014, "Questions and Answers on Title IX and Single-Sex Elementary and Secondary Classes and Extracurricular Activities"
Office of the Attorney General memo, Dec. 15, 2014, "Treatment of Transgender Employment Discrimination Claims Under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964"
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.