Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
Bernie Sanders condemned Wall Street for creating and now profiting off Puerto Rico’s debt crisis during a campaign stop on the island.
Puerto Rico is currently $72 billion in debt and, in the words of its governor, in "a death spiral." Unlike other states and cities, it cannot legally declare bankruptcy. So Sanders called for the Federal Reserve to help the U.S. territory out, just as it bailed out the financial sector responsible for imperilling 3.5 million Puerto Ricans in the first place.
"I think all of us understand and your government understands that Puerto Rico’s $70 billion debt is unsustainable and it is unpayable," Sanders said May 16 at a town hall in San Juan. "And the reason why it is unsustainable has everything to do with the greed of Wall Street vulture funds."
So is Wall Street to blame for the island’s economic woes?
Sanders has a point that hedge funds and banks are certainly exacerbating the situation and, in some cases, attempting to block a solution. However, experts told us and the research shows that Puerto Rico has been accumulating debt long before Wall Street got involved.
Origins of the debt
This $72 billion debt did not appear solely thanks to the maneuvers of Wall Street. Rather, it’s been building up for decades, resulting from a combination of U.S. policy, local mismanagement and economic decline.
The local government has essentially maxed out a very special credit card given to it and other U.S. territories. When the island became a commonwealth in 1917, Congress also made bonds issued by the Puerto Rican government "triple tax-exempt" (meaning they can’t be taxed at the federal, state or local level) and thus very attractive to investors.
For decades, this allowed the government to overspend, in part out of necessity and in part out of sheer irresponsibility.
Puerto Rico has had to pick up a disportionate chunk of the tab for federal social programs. More than 60 percent of its residents receive Medicare or Medicaid, but federal funding is considerably lower than the states. (For example, $3 billion for Oklahoma’s Medicaid program and $3.6 billion for Mississippi’s compared to $373 million for the island, a fraction of its $2.9 billion in expenses.)
Disparities in funding aside, the local government has also made some poor management and spending decisions. Inefficient public utilities have been running up the tab since the 1940s and now account for the largest portion of Puerto Rico’s debt ($20 billion). Meanwhile, the state-run power authority continues to dole out free electricity. Similarly, public employees enjoy "lavish pension benefits" like holiday bonuses and loans for international travel but the pensions remain severely underfunded ($1.9 billion in assets versus $45.5 billion in liabilities).
Now add in changes in federal policy, economic depression and population decline and you’ve got a recipe for even less revenue and total debt unsustainability.
For decades, U.S. businesses operating in Puerto Rico received significant tax breaks, an economic boon for the island. But that all ended in 1996, when President Bill Clinton signed legislation phasing out the incentives over 10 years. By 2006, Puerto Rico was already $43 billion in debt and fell into a recession that, compounded by the global financial crisis, continues to this day.
Marc Joffe, the principal consultant at Public Sector Credit Solutions, tracked Puerto Rico’s debt from 1910 to 2015. Here’s a chart we made using his data:
Wall Street’s role
The island was already knee-deep in debt by the time the financial industry got involved, but Wall Street is certainly profiting off of the situation.
According to Sanders in his San Juan address and his campaign, hedge funds now hold about 50 percent of Puerto Rico’s debt. This is the high end of estimates we found, which range from 20 percent to 50 percent. But this is a relatively recent development.
Prior to 2014, most of Puerto Rico’s bonds were owned by traditional mutual funds and retail investors, according to Brad Setser, a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations who previously worked in the Obama administration's Treasury Department. Morningstar, the research investment firm, estimated that some 180 mutual funds had Puerto Rican bonds in their portfolios in 2013.
In 2014, multiple credit ratings agencies downgraded Puerto Rico’s bonds to junk status. Because of the high risk associated with this low grade, most traditional investors were unable or unwilling to invest. Enter Wall Street.
Hedge funds and other non-traditional buyers "eyeing fat yields and possible trading gains" purchased $3.5 billion worth of junk bonds at a tax-free interest rate of just under 9 percent (the high rate reflecting the high risk). As Puerto Rico’s debt had already topped $70 billion in 2013, $3.5 billion wouldn’t have made much of a difference.
"The combination of Puerto Rico’s decision (to sell more bonds) and the availability of Wall Street financing helped Puerto Rico dig itself into a bigger hole," said Setser.
In fact, if the hedge funds hadn’t purchased these bonds, which were after all issued to pay off old debt, "the crisis would have come a little earlier since the level of debt was already unsustainable," said Joffe of Public Sector Credit Solutions.
That being said, Wall Street should be held accountable for its opportunism as some hedge funds and banks have certainly chosen to take advantage of the situation, said Rafael Fantauzzi of the National Puerto Rican Coalition.
Since 2014, hedge funds have been buying up bonds on the cheap in the secondary market (those previously owned by traditional investors). Sanders’ campaign provided PolitiFact an example of bonds bought for 29 cents on the dollar yielding an interest of 34 percent. Bloomberg has reported yields ranging from under 10 percent to as high as 80 percent.
Sanders in his San Juan speech and his campaign also noted that banks like Goldman Sachs, Citigroup and UBS have received hundreds of millions of dollars in fees to manage the island’s bond sales.
The exact figure, according to the Wall Street Journal, is $1.4 billion for $61 billion worth of bond sales since 2006. That’s the equivalent of a service charge of 2.3 percent, double the average rate for municipal bond sales but quadruple the rate for corporate bond sales.
Exacerbating the situation
The most damning evidence for "the greed of vulture funds" is Wall Street’s efforts to prevent Puerto Rico from digging itself out of the hole.
The Sanders campaign forwarded us a New York Times report of a letter representatives of BlueMountain, a hedge fund that holds Puerto Rican bonds, sent to Republican staff members urging against allowing debt restructuring.
The Center for Individual Freedom, a dark money group, has also spent $2 million on issue ads against debt relief efforts in Congress, supporting the hedge funds’ position.
"That’s very concerning that financial interests, specially these so-called ‘vulture funds,’ are disrupting the political process and preventing Puerto Rico having a smoother landing in this situation they got themselves into," said Joffe, adding that that’s what they did in Argentina as well.
In lieu of debt restructuring, Wall Street recommends cutting spending. A report commissioned by 34 hedge funds advises Puerto Rico to raise taxes, lay off teachers, close schools, and cut wages and worker benefits, Medicaid, and welfare. (About 45.4 percent of Puerto Ricans live below the poverty line and the commonwealth already closed 150 schools in the last five years and increased its sales tax.)
So while the hedge funds and banks "have played a relatively modest role in creating the need for a comprehensive debt solution," said Setser, they are "playing a more important role in hindering a bipartisan solution."
Sanders said, "Puerto Rico’s $70 billion debt is unsustainable and it is unpayable. And the reason why it is unsustainable has everything to do with the greed of Wall Street vulture funds."
Puerto Rico’s debt was already unsustainable by the time Wall Street hedge funds and banks began playing a role as a result of decades of local mismanagement, U.S. policy and economic misfortune.
But Sanders has a point that the financial sector has taken advantage of and is excerbating the situation. What's more, they're effectively preventing crisis relief by actively working to stop Puerto Rico from restructuring its debt.
We rate his claim Half True.https://www.sharethefacts.co/share/569f5ee5-ad45-4c6b-aa2e-370eeada25bf
Youtube, "Bernie Sanders San Juan Puerto Rico Rally," May 16, 2016
Washington Post, "As Puerto Rico’s fiscal crisis grows into a humanitarian one, health care looks like the first big casualty," Nov. 5, 2015
New York Times, "Puerto Ricans Brace for Crisis in Health Care," Aug. 2, 2015
New York Times, "How Free Electricity Helped Dig $9 Billion Hole in Puerto Rico," Feb. 2, 2016
Reuters, "Puerto Rico’s other crisis: impoverished pensions," April 7, 2016
PolitiFact, "Treasury Secretary Lew says about 100,000 people left Puerto Rico last year," May 17, 2016
Mercatus Research, "Origins of the Puerto Rico Fiscal Crisis," April 2016
Centro de Periodismo Investigativa, "Vulture funds have Puerto Rico cornered," April 9, 2015
Bloomberg, "NYC Pension Urges Hedge Funds to Ease Puerto Rico Crisis," Nov. 13, 2015
The Fiscal Times, "Why Hedge Funds May Not Get a Windfall from Puerto Rico," April 26, 2016
Business Wire, "Fitch: Shifting Investor Mix Bifurcates Puerto Rican Bond Market," Aug. 13, 2014
CNN, "Who owns Puerto Rico's debt?," Aug. 6, 2015
Fortune, "This hedge fund manager just lost millions on Greece and Puerto Rico," June 29, 2015
CNN, "Puerto Rico's credit rating cut to junk by S&P," Feb. 24, 2014
CNBC, "Moody's downgrades Puerto Rico GO debt rating two notches to 'junk' status," Feb. 7, 2014
Reuters, "Fitch becomes third agency to cut Puerto Rico to junk," Feb. 11, 2014
Reuters, "UPDATE 4-Puerto Rico's 'junk' label no hurdle in $3.5 bln bond sale," March 11, 2014
Washington Post, "Puerto Rico, with at least $70 billion in debt, confronts a rising economic misery," Nov. 30, 2013
Electronic Municipal Market Access, "GOVERNMENT DEVELOPMENT BANK FOR PUERTO RICO $1,399,045,000 SENIOR NOTES, 2011 SERIES H (PR)," May 11, 2016
Wall Street Journal, "Banks Rack Up Big Fees From Puerto Rico Bond Deals," Oct. 22, 2013
Bloomberg, "Muni Charges Eat Up Interest as Yields at 40-Year Low," Aug. 25, 2010
Wall Street Journal, "Muni Bond Costs Hit Investors in Wallet," March 10, 2014
PunditFact, "Mystery: Strom Thurmond, Puerto Rico and bankruptcy protection," April 27, 2016
Congress.gov, "S.2676 - Puerto Rico Stability Act of 2016," March 14, 2016
New York Times, "Inside the Billion-Dollar Battle for Puerto Rico’s Future," Dec. 19, 2015
Politico, "Republicans writing Puerto Rico fix face attack ads," April 13, 2016
Centennial Group International, "For Puerto Rico, There is a Better Way," July 2015
The Guardian, "Hedge funds tell Puerto Rico: lay off teachers and close schools to pay us back," July 28, 2015
Census Bureau, "Poverty: 2012 and 2013," September 2014
Associated Press, "Puerto Rico closes dozens of schools as economic woes deepen," May 14, 2015
PricewaterhouseCoopers, "Puerto Rico adopts VAT tax system and broadens sales and use tax," June 26, 2015
New York Times, "Puerto Rico Debt Crisis Explained," May 10, 2016
Marketplace, "Stranded: Puerto Rico in debt with no end in sight," April 11, 2016
American Prospect, "How Hedge Funds Deepen Puerto Rico’s Debt Crisis," Dec. 11, 2015
Washington Post Fact Checker, "A dark money group’s misleading claim that the Puerto Rico debt plan is a ‘bailout’," May 10, 2016
Investopedia, The Origins of the Puerto Rican Debt Crisis, Sept. 9, 2015
Bloomberg, Puerto Rico’s Slide, May 3, 2016
Roll Call, "Puerto Rico Debt Crisis Could Lead to Catastrophe," March 7, 2016
Bloomberg, "Here Are the Winners and Losers of Puerto Rico's Debt Crisis," May 19, 2015
Email interview with Warren Gunnels, policy director for Bernie Sanders, May 17, 2016
Email interview with Tim Samples, professor of legal studies at the Terry College of Business, May 17, 2016
Email interview with Stephen Park, professor of business law at the University of Connecticut, May 17, 2016
Email and phone interview with Brad Setser, senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, May 17, 2016
Interview with Marc Joffe, principal consultant at Public Sector Credit Solutions, May 18, 2016
Email interview with Rafael Fantauzzi, president and CEO of the National Puerto Rican Coalition, May 17, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.