Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Two days after the November 2016 elections, Texas Agriculture Commissioner Sid Miller took note on his Facebook page of a web post suggesting a Texas A&M University campus was offering counseling and "safe spaces for students who are afraid of President-elect Trump."
Did the cowboy-hatted Republican, who was Donald Trump’s most-cited Texan in the days before the vote, highlight accurate information?
Trump unexpectedly defeated Democrat Hillary Clinton on Nov. 8, 2016, after more than 18 months of a bitter campaign--and nationally after the election, at least 43 colleges and universities offered support services, according to news reports, with some reporting spurts in students seeking counseling.
Miller, who gleefully received news on Nov. 9, 2016, that he was among individuals under Trump’s consideration for U.S. secretary of agriculture, carries a reputation for provocative social media posts, including a Facebook post suggesting a nuclear strike on "the Muslim world" and a Twitter post he later deleted and attributed to an outside employee calling Clinton a vulgar name.
For our part, we noticed that on Nov. 10, 2016, Miller shared an article from the website IAmATexan.com, headlined "Texas university offers counseling, safe spaces for students who are afraid of president-elect Trump;" five days later, Miller’s pass-along had been shared by others more than 4,400 times.
Web post refers to 'pinko-commie-coddling letter'
"I never thought I’d see this in Texas," said the post from I Am A Texan, a right-leaning news blog that posts daily articles on Texas culture and national issues.
The website’s article said that an email with an attached "pinko-commie-coddling letter" had been sent to the entire student body at Texas A&M University - Commerce. The university, which enrolled about 12,300 students in fall 2015, is in Hunt County, which Trump carried with 76 percent of the vote to Clinton’s 20 percent.
And according to I Am A Texan, the letter offered counseling services to students with election-related stress, "outlining all the ways that the university was prepared to help its fragile students who can’t bear the thought of living now that Donald Trump has won the election."
Administrator: No intent to focus on fears of Trump
And did the university spell out ways for students to deal with fears of Trump?
To get a fix on that, we reached out to Tomás Aguirre, the university's assistant vice president and dean of students; Aguirre’s digital signature was stamped on the email that included the attached letter.
By phone, Aguirre confirmed the authenticity of the posted email, which was blank save this subject line: "An Open Letter to Students: How to De-Stress from Election."
Aguirre also insisted there was no administration intent to focus on students fearful of the president-elect, who was not mentioned in the letter.
Miller spokesman bemoans student 'wusses'
We also emailed Miller’s office, and got a phone call in response from spokesman Todd Smith, who said, "Who else would they be offering emotional counseling to if not people opposed to Donald Trump being president?" Smith’s point: Trump fans would have been happy--not in need of counseling--after election day.
"Commissioner Miller believes that the mere fact that college students need counseling after a presidential election is a sad commentary on the state of our nation and many of its young people," Smith said. "Commissioner Miller thinks they’re a bunch of wusses."
So exactly what offer did the university make?
By email, Aguirre sent us a copy of the original "open letter," pictured below, which he said was emailed to students on Nov. 10, 2016.
The letter doesn’t mention Trump or any candidate by name.
It opens by calling the national election cycle "a particularly stressful one." Next, it says the Counseling Center staff "wants to acknowledge a range of reactions you might be experiencing Including excitement, joy, relief, fear, sadness, anger, dread, hopelessness, anxiety, and numbness."
The letter’s second paragraph opens: "We are here to listen and support you as our nation works through this election transition." It goes on to offer services especially to students "struggling with the impact of the election or the tone of the national discussion" and students who have experienced negative treatment because of "race or ethnicity, sexual orientation, gender identity, religious affiliation, country of origin or other aspects of your identity."
The letter closes with tips for students at "this highly emotional time for our nation" to remain productive. That comes after a sentence stating the center "provides a safe space for discussions on identity, empowerment, intercultural competency, and the impact of the election."
By phone, Aguirre described the letter as a reminder of services available year-round. Also, he said, it was similar to letters distributed to students through the school year such as at mid-term exams and around Valentine’s Day.
Aguirre said he put the letter in motion after the election because the school’s Counseling Center had seen an uptick in student visits during the fall 2016 semester. Aguirre said, though, that he he didn’t know if the spike related to the election; confidentiality constraints bar the university from saying why students seek counseling.
A student's comment
We wondered if students saw eye to eye with Aguirre regarding the undertones of the open letter. So we messaged the Facebook page for the College Republicans at Texas A&M University - Commerce, and got a response from Michael Faz, the group’s vice president.
Faz, a senior majoring in political science, said by phone that Aguirre "sends those emails out all the time," up to a few times a month. Faz said he read the letter himself but doubted that most students did. The College Republicans on campus, Faz said, did not feel the reminder of support services was a message catered to students fearful of Trump.
"We didn’t think anything of it," Faz said.
Miller posted an article saying Texas A&M University - Commerce was offering counseling and "safe spaces for students who are afraid of President-elect Trump."
After the election, the university sent a letter to students describing its counseling center as a "safe space." Yet that letter didn’t specifically mention Trump while offering services for students experiencing varied reactions.
We rate Miller’s statement Half True.
HALF TRUE – The statement is partially accurate but leaves out important details or takes things out of context. Click here for more on the six PolitiFact ratings and how we select facts to check.
Facebook post, "Texas university offers counseling, safe spaces for students who are afraid of president-elect Trump," posted by I Am A Texan Nov. 10, 2016, shared by Texas Agriculture Commissioner Sid Miller, Nov. 10, 2016
Commentary, "Herman: Trump says a Lone Star star is born," Ken Herman, Austin American-Statesman, Oct. 31, 2016
News story, "Colleges try to comfort students upset by Trump victory," The Wall Street Journal, Nov. 9, 2016
News story, "Here’s how universities are offering support to students after Trump’s election," USA Today, Nov. 15, 2016
News story, "Universities offer counseling and ‘healing spaces’ to students distraught over Trump win," The Sacramento Bee, Nov. 9, 2016
News story, "ITT Offers students counseling to ‘help process of the election," DNAinfo, Nov. 9, 2016
News story, "Following Donald Trump election, UMass offers students grief counseling," MassLive, Nov. 10, 2016
News story, "Controversial Texas Ag Commish Sid Miller reportedly eyed for Trump cabinet Post," San Antonio Express-News, Nov. 9, 2016
News stories, The College Fix, "Universities help students cope with election day stress," Nov. 8, 2016; "Counseling, vigils, safe spaces used to calm college students distressed by Trump victory," Nov. 10, 2016
News story, "A collection of all the college emails and messages offering safe spaces to process a Trump presidency," Barstool Sports, Nov. 9, 2016
Opinion article, "Emotional coddling doesn’t help college students--it hurts them," National Review, Nov. 10, 2016
Telephone interview and emails, Tomás Aguirre, assistant vice president and dean of students, Texas A&M University Commerce, Nov. 11-15, 2016
Telephone interviews, Michael Faz, vice president, Texas A&M University - Commerce College Republicans, Nov. 15-16, 2016
Telephone interview, Todd Smith, spokesman, Sid Miller campaign, Nov. 16, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.