Stand up for the facts!

Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.

More Info

I would like to contribute

By Dan Clark November 18, 2016

Salary worth less today for state lawmakers than when first passed

Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie believes members of the New York State Legislature deserve a pay raise. It will be 18 years without one when state lawmakers return to Albany in January.

Lawmakers who live in areas with higher costs of living are especially pressing for an increase from the current $79,500 salary, which took effect in 1999.

"When the salary was $79,500, that purchasing power has now been reduced to $53,000," Heastie told WBFO last month. "Legislators have children that they need to help go to college. They have real lives."

Their prospects for a raise look dim after the State Commission on Legislative, Judicial and Executive Compensation this week denied a proposal to boost their salaries by 47 percent to $116,900.

It remains unclear when the pay issue will come up again. The Legislature has the power to reinstate the commission, or lawmakers can even vote to increase their own pay.

We looked into whether Heastie is right about how far lawmakers’ current pay goes today compared with when they first received their $79,500 salary.

The politics of pay

The last pay raise, adopted by the Legislature in late 1998, took effect in January 1999. It did not come easily. Lawmakers got a 38 percent increase in pay from $57,500 to $79,500, but only after the Democratic-controlled Assembly passed a bill supported by then-Gov. George Pataki, a Republican, allowing charter schools in New York State.

After the commission rejected the proposed pay raise last week, a member of the commission said the governor’s appointees would support a meaningful raise if the Legislature held a special session before the end of this year to limit lawmakers’ outside income.

The commission is made up of appointees from the governor, the Legislature and the judiciary. Two appointees from the Legislature voted in favor of the pay increase. Two appointees from the governor did not vote on measure. An appointee of the judiciary also abstained. The proposal failed by one vote.

What’s it worth now?

The $79,500 base salary that lawmakers receive today ranks as the third highest for state lawmakers in the country. That doesn’t include stipends lawmakers receive for taking on leadership positions, which range anywhere from $9,000 to $41,500 for the highest-ranking lawmakers in each chamber.

The purchasing power of that salary has fallen as the cost of living rises. One dollar in 1999 now has the purchasing power of just 68 cents according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.

The calculation proves Heastie’s point: $79,500 in January 1999 has the same buying power as $54,060 in October 2016.

Our ruling

While visiting Buffalo, Heastie said the purchasing power of a state lawmaker’s $79,500 salary "has now been reduced to $53,000" since that salary took effect 18 years ago.

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, Heastie is slightly off in his comparison. Inflation actually pegs the purchasing power of the current salary at $54,060.

We rate this claim as Mostly True.

https://www.sharethefacts.co/share/dcea594d-995a-4fd0-829f-2c81a7d5e407

Our Sources

Email conversation with Kerri Biché from Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie’s office

Statute for NYS Commission on the Legislative, Judicial, and Executive Compensation

Information on 1998 bills found using the Legislative Retrieval System. From the Laws of 1998:

  • A.11464 authorizes the pay increase

  • S.7880 amends that law to include the late budget rule

  • S.7881 authorizes charter schools in New York

Email conversation and data calculation from Gary Steinberg at the Bureau of Labor Statistics

"Senate Passes Charter Plan For Schools", New York Times, Dec. 18, 1998, Accessed Nov. 14, 2016

U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Inflation Calculator, Accessed Nov. 14, 2016

"NY legislator pay hikes in jeopardy; panel running out of time", New York Upstate, Nov. 11, 2016, Accessed Nov. 14, 2016

"NY commission starts work on what are likely to be hefty raises for state lawmakers", The Daily Freeman, Feb. 22, 2016, Accessed Nov. 14, 2016

"Will NY lawmakers get a 47% raise?", Gannett Albany, Aug. 7, 2016, Accessed Nov. 14, 2016

"Legislative pay raise commission created", Politico New York, April 1, 2015, Accessed Nov. 14, 2016

"Governor Cuomo and Legislative Leaders Announce Agreement on 5 Point Ethics Reform Plan", June 17, 2016, Accessed Nov. 14, 2016

National Conference on State Legislatures Fact-sheet on state lawmaker pay, Accessed Nov. 15, 2016

"New York Lawmakers Will Not Get Raise, Commission Decides", New York Times, Nov. 15, 2016, Accessed Nov. 18, 2016

"Housing Affordability in New York State" 2014, State Comptroller’s Office, Accessed Nov. 18, 2016

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Dan Clark

Salary worth less today for state lawmakers than when first passed

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up