Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Lawmakers led away in handcuffs seem like clear signs of a corruption problem in New York State. But the worst in the nation? Elaine Phillips says that’s the case. The Republican is running for a vacant State Senate seat on Long Island, and she has made public corruption in Albany the centerpiece of her campaign.
She outlined her plan for state ethics reform in a Facebook post, in which she claimed New York State leads the nation in lawmakers in trouble with the law.
"Over the past decade in Albany, more than 30 current and former state officeholders have been convicted, sanctioned or accused of wrongdoing — more than any other state," Phillips said in the post. She referenced the number from an article in the New York Times. Phillips took that claim a step further by saying New York led the pack in corruption among other states.
In Albany, running afoul of the law is bipartisan, and not just for backbenchers. Two of the state’s legislative leaders were convicted of corruption charges, former Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver, a Manhattan Democrat, and former Senate Majority Leader Dean Skelos, a Long Island Republican.
Phillips, mayor of the Nassau County village of Flower Hill, faces Adam Haber, a Democrat who most recently served with the Nassau Interim Finance Authority Board, which monitors the county’s finances.
So is Phillips right? Can New York State be the worst in a nation that includes politicians from Illinois - think Rod Blagojevich - and Louisiana, where a recent headline read "New Orleans FBI chief calls political corruption in Louisiana ‘robust’"?
Struggle with corruption
The New York Times, The Buffalo News and other publications have chronicled more than 30 corruption cases in the past decade.
Dr. Jeffrey Milyo and Scott Delhommer from the University of Missouri have compiled a database that focuses specifically on public corruption at the state level across the country. Their research focuses on state legislators, high-ranking executive branch officials, and supreme court justices. They tracked bribery, influence peddling and theft of public funds among other charges.
Other studies have looked solely at federal convictions or public officials at all levels of government. The Missouri researchers are the only ones who looked at corruption through a state lens, the kind of cases Phillips talks about.
From 2006 - 2015, the Missouri researchers identified 28 corruption cases dealing with state officials in New York. Include 2005, and that number rises to 30.
That puts New York first for the number of public corruption cases, followed by Pennsylvania, where 24 cases have been filed over the past decade. New Jersey ranks third with 12 corruption cases.
Look further back, and New York State has topped the list since at least 1986, Milyo said.
"Historically, New York has struggled with corruption and continues to do so," said Jennifer Rodgers, executive director of the Center for the Advancement of Public Integrity. "While measuring corruption is a challenge, I think it's fair to say that New York remains one of the most corrupt states if not the most corrupt state."
The corruption in New York State is likely rooted in culture, Rodgers says.
"Much of corruption is cultural, and in New York that means that you have to think about the way the New York political system has developed over more than 200 years," Rodgers said. "So you start with these corrupt political machines like Tammany Hall, and over time the problem replicates itself as the next generation figures out how things work and how much corruption will be tolerated, and so on down the line. We've made some progress, of course, but not enough."
In her pitch for ethics reform, Phillips said in a Facebook post that "over the past decade in Albany, more than 30 current and former state officeholders have been convicted, sanctioned or accused of wrongdoing — more than any other state."
She’s right. The analysis from the University of Missouri researchers shows New York State has had more state lawmakers and statewide officials running afoul of the law. She could have gone further. The data shows New York State has led the nation in public corruption for decades.
We rate this claim as True.https://www.sharethefacts.co/share/5c62d79f-6d1b-4be6-a625-932fed3951d8
Facebook post from Elaine Phillips, Republican running for State Senate, Aug. 26, 2016
Phone conversation with the Elaine Phillips campaign
Email conversation with Dick Simpson from the University of Illinois at Chicago
Phone conversation with Jennifer Rodgers from the Center for the Advancement of Public Integrity
Email conversation with Dr. Jeffrey Milyo from the University of Missouri
Campaign website for Elaine Phillips, Accessed Sept. 8, 2016
"Haber to make second run for state Senate", The Island Now, Feb. 18, 2016, Accessed Sept. 8, 2016
"As Skelos heads to prison, Albany’s corruption story never ends", The Buffalo News, May 12, 2016, Accessed Sept. 2, 2016
"Blagojevich awaits his ‘final number’ at re-sentencing", Chicago Sun Times, Aug. 7, 2016, Accessed Sept. 2, 2016
"Supreme Court overturns corruption conviction of former Va. governor McDonnell", Washington Post, June 27, 2016, Accessed Sept. 2, 2016
Chicago: Still the Capital of Corruption, Anti-Corruption Report Number 8, University of Illinois at Chicago, May 28, 2015, Accessed Sept. 2, 2016
Data compiled by Dr. Jeffrey Milyo and Scott Delhommer on state-level public corruption in the last decade. Data provided to PolitiFact New York Sept. 1, 2016
Poll: National: Most corrupt state? New York, Monmouth University, April 16, 2015, Accessed Sept. 7, 2016
The Many Faces of New York’s Political Scandals, May 3, 2016, New York Times, Accessed Sept. 19, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.