Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
U.S. Sen. John McCain’s attempt to smooth over a contentious phone call between President Donald Trump and Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull was against the law, according to several bloggers.
But their ire toward the Arizona Republican relies on a hard-to-establish link to a highly politicized law that no one has ever been convicted of violating.
"McCain caught making highly illegal phone call to foreign country," blared the Facebook headline on several Internet posts critical of the senator on or after Feb. 3, 2017. The social media site flagged at least one undated example as part of its efforts to squash fake stories in users’ news feeds. In this case, the post isn’t fake in that details were made up, rather just inaccurate in how the details are portrayed.
The posts reference an initial phone call Trump made to Turnbull on Jan. 28. That call allegedly turned sour when Trump balked over an agreement former President Barack Obama struck to take in 1,250 refugees that Australia held in offshore detention centers.
But the "highly illegal phone call" that McCain made was on Feb. 2, when he contacted Australian ambassador to the United States Joe Hockey to assure Hockey of McCain’s "unwavering support for the U.S.-Australia alliance."
"I asked Ambassador Hockey to convey to the people of Australia that their American brothers and sisters value our historic alliance, honor the sacrifice of the Australians who have served and are serving by our side, and remain committed to the safer, freer, and better world that Australia does far more than its fair share to protect and promote," McCain said in a statement.
That caused an uproar in some corners of the Internet. Several websites repurposed or made reference to an undated post that appears to originate at AngryPatriotMovement.com, which carried the same headline about McCain breaking the law.
The post linked to a Feb 3 BizPacReview.com article that said McCain was "undermining" Trump, and said McCain’s call to Australia’s ambassador "might be a violation of the Logan Act."
"The Logan Act says ANY citizen of the United States who ‘without permission of the United States’ either directly or indirectly ‘commences or carries on correspondence’ with any foreign government or any officer of another government, to ‘influence the measures or conduct of any foreign government or of any officer’ in ongoing controversies or disputes with America, shall be fined or sent to prison for three years — or both," the AngryPatriotMovement.com post read.
But really, McCain wasn’t "caught" doing anything. His office put out the press release about contacting Hockey. And the Logan Act isn’t necessarily a law designed to root out near-treasonous behavior, the way the blogs make it sound.
The Logan Act dates back to 1798, when a Pennsylvania state legislator named George Logan went to France to negotiate a peace settlement over debts with the United States during the French Revolution, according to the Washington Post. You’ll recall Paul Giamatti agonizing over the issue in HBO’s John Adams.
Adams’ Federalist Party had opposed Logan’s efforts, so they passed a law that said private citizens couldn’t work on foreign policy issues without the government allowing it.
No one has ever been charged with a crime under the Logan Act, but its name comes up from time to time, usually when a lawmaker has contacted a foreign official for some purpose the opposing party doesn’t like.
Some brought up the act when U.S. Rep. Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., went to Syria as Speaker of the House to attempt to wheel and deal with President Bashar al-Assad in 2007. It also was mentioned when 47 Republican senators wrote a letter to Iran in 2015 to try to scuttle Obama’s nuclear treaty. It even came up when Trump, as the GOP presidential nominee, asked Russia to find Hillary Clinton’s missing emails last year.
It’s highly doubtful that McCain, who has made a habit of serving as a foil for Trump, actually violated federal law. Stanford law professor Michael McConnell doubted the Logan Act could be used to keep a senator from talking to a country’s envoy about foreign affairs, which senators often do.
"So far as publicly available information indicates, Sen. McCain spoke with the Australian ambassador to assure the nation of his own unwavering support — not to influence any ‘measures or conduct,’" McConnell told us in an email.
Bloggers claim McCain was "caught making highly illegal phone call to foreign country."
The claim reads as if McCain tried to break federal law by influencing a foreign official, perhaps by secrecy. That’s not the case at all, but a reader wouldn’t get that impression.
We rate it False.
TheTrumpMedia.com, "McCain Blamed For Sabotaging Trump," February 2017
AngryPatriotMovement.com, "ALERT – McCain Caught Making HIGHLY ILLEGAL Phone Call to Foreign Country. Should He Resign?," February 2017
The Hill, "House Republican wants to restrict Pelosi’s travel," Jan. 21, 2007
CNN, "Did 47 Republican senators break the law in plain sight?," March 11, 2015
Des Moines Register, "Trump's Russia comments could be a felony, Vilsack charges," July 28, 2016
Washington Post, "‘This was the worst call by far’: Trump badgered, bragged and abruptly ended phone call with Australian leader," Feb. 2, 2017
CNN, "US-Australia refugee deal: What you need to know," Feb. 2, 2017
New York magazine, "John McCain Makes Nice With Australia After Trump’s ‘Unnecessary’ Dispute," Feb. 2, 2017
Politico, "McCain looks to assure Australia after Trump call," Feb. 2, 2017
U.S. Sen. John McCain, "Statement by SASC chairman John McCain on U.S.-Australia alliance," Feb. 2, 2017
BizPacReview.com, "McCain blasted for undermining Trump; calls Australian Ambassador to express ‘unwavering support’," Feb. 3, 2017
CNN, "John McCain basking in Trump tormentor role," Feb. 3, 2017
Washington Post, "Democrats think Donald Trump just violated the Logan Act. What is that?," July 28, 2016
Interview with Michael McConnell, Stanford law professor, Feb. 19, 2017
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.