Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
New York state has some of the highest property taxes in the country. But where in the state are property taxes highest?
Assemblyman Ray Walter, R-Amherst, says Western New York ranks high.
"Western New Yorkers pay some of the highest property taxes in the state," Walter said in a recent press release about Republican efforts to replace Obamacare. He supports a part of a congressional bill designed to reduce property taxes in New York state by shifting Medicaid costs from counties to the state.
Walter said he was talking about property taxes as a percent of home value in Western New York. He defines the region as the eight counties west of the Finger Lakes: Erie, Niagara, Chautauqua, Allegany, Cattaraugus, Orleans, Wyoming and Genesee counties.
"It’s off the charts as a percentage of home value," Walter told PolitiFact New York. "In real dollars it’s not as high just because our home values are not as high as other places in the state."
Is Walter right that Western New York has some of the highest property taxes in the state?
Percent of home value
U.S. Census Bureau data shows how property taxes compared with home values in each county in 2015, the latest figures.
It’s a better apples-to-apples comparison because some counties have higher home values but similar property tax bills. The home value in Brooklyn is more than triple that of Sullivan County, for example, but the property tax bills are within a few hundred dollars of each other.
All eight counties in Western New York rank among the 18 highest counties in the state for property taxes as a percent of home value.
• Orleans County ranks first out of the state’s 62 counties. Its median property tax of $3,055 is 3.35 percent of its $91,300 median home value.
• Allegany County ranks second. The $2,320 median property tax bill is 3.3 percent of the $70,300 median home value.
• Erie County ranks lowest in the region, but 18th highest in the state. Its median property tax bill is $3,499, which is 2.69 percent of its median home value of $130,000.
The data is only reported for owner-occupied housing units. It does not include property taxes on businesses or rented units.
Property taxes in dollars
The ten counties with the highest median property tax in dollar amounts are in New York City, the lower Hudson Valley and on Long Island. Western New York counties are lower in this category. Four of them rank in the bottom half.
• Erie County has the highest property tax in the region. The county ranks 21st in the state.
• Niagara County, where the median property tax bill is $3,255, is second highest in the region but 26th in the state.
• Allegany County has the lowest median property tax in dollars in Western New York. Only five other counties in the state are lower.
Three counties tie for highest property taxes in the state — and the country. Nassau, Rockland, and Westchester counties each have median property tax bills that exceed $10,000. That’s the highest amount in the country as well.
The Census Bureau does not report exact dollar amounts when the median tax exceeds $10,000.
Percent of income
Property taxes can also be measured as a share of median household income.
The eight counties in Western New York rank in the middle in this category.
• Wyoming County, where the tax bill is $2,871, is lowest in the region. Residents spend 5.29 percent of the median income of $52,564 on property taxes. Fifteen counties have lower property tax bills as a percent of median resident income.
• Erie County is again highest in the region. Residents there pay 6.83 percent of the median income of $51,247 toward property taxes. Twenty-one counties are higher.
Nassau, Rockland, and Westchester counties tie for first in this category. At least ten percent of the median income in each is spent on property taxes.
Walter said "Western New Yorkers pay some of the highest property taxes in the state."
His statement might come as a surprise to homeowners on Long Island and other counties near New York City, where median property tax bills exceed $10,000. To them, Erie County's median property tax bill of $3,499 doesn't look too high.
So, no, Western New Yorkers do not pay some of the highest property taxes in the state.
But Western New Yorkers shoulder a heavier burden paying the property tax.
Walter said he was talking about property taxes as a percent of home value. And in that sense, he’s right about the tax. Two Western New York counties lead the state in this category and all eight counties in the region are among the top third.
We rate his claim Half True.
"Collins and New York State Leaders Praise Inclusion of NYS Property Tax Reduction Language in Senate Obamacare Repeal Bill", June 23, 2017, Rep. Chris Collins’ Office
Phone conversation with Assemblyman Ray Walter
Email conversation with Ben Golub from Walter’s office
All data on median property tax, median home value, and median household income by county: U.S. Census Bureau American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates 2011 - 2015
Email conversation with Morgan Scarboro, policy analyst from the Tax Foundation
"Which Places Pay the Most in Property Taxes?" May 18, 2017, Tax Foundation
"Cuomo proposes 'Faso-Collins' tax to make up for lost county Medicaid revenue", The Buffalo News, June 26, 2017
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.