Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
In his August Facebook Live video, Gov. Eric Greitens encouraged viewers to submit their questions. One viewer asked, "What do we do for our veterans except use them as our reason to get mad when it fits our agenda?"
In response, Greitens touched on providing jobs for veterans, in addition to citing the rate of veterans graduating from treatment courts in Missouri.
"Our veterans in our veterans court, are graduating — 73 percent of our veterans are graduating from drug courts," Greitens said. "By contrast, I think most of the people in the very good drug court program — the graduation rate’s like 53, 55 percent. The point of that is that drug courts are working for veterans."
We were wondering: Are 73 percent of veterans graduating from treatment courts? While we never heard back from Greitens’ spokesman, a Supreme Court of Missouri spokeswoman pointed us in the direction of where those numbers came from.
According to the Missouri Courts website, treatment courts began as a way to battle increasing substance abuse problems.
Treatment courts have existed in Missouri for nearly 25 years. The first treatment court was started in 1993 in Jackson County. Legislation in 2013 established the first veterans treatment courts programs, which "are hybrid drug and mental health court dockets that use the treatment court model to serve veterans struggling with addiction, serious mental illness and/or co-occurring disorders," according to a treatment courts fact sheet.
As of August 2017, there were 147 treatment court programs throughout the state. Of those, 12 are veterans treatment courts, with the remaining being adult, juvenile, family and DWI courts.
Veterans can be accepted into treatment courts for drug-involved offenses and DWI offenses, Beth Riggert, communications counsel for the Supreme Court of Missouri, wrote in an email.
According to the treatment courts fact sheet, "The graduation rate for all programs in fiscal 2017 exceeds 61 percent."
However, the most recent data on veterans treatment courts is from calendar year 2016, Riggert said.
In that time frame, there were a total of 247 veterans participating in veterans treatment courts in the state, Riggert said. However, because the program is rolling, only a total of 82 veterans exited the program in 2016.
Of those, 60 successfully graduated the program and 22 did not.
That translates to a success rate of 73.17 percent, or just about what Greitens said.
Since 2011, the graduation rate from veterans treatment courts has steadily been increasing as more veterans have gone through the program.
Greitens also said, "By contrast, I think most of the people in the very good drug court program — the graduation rate’s like 53, 55 percent."
Because we were unable to reach Greitens’ spokesman for comment, we are unsure which specific treatment courts program Greitens was referring to when he said "the very good drug court program." However, Riggert elaborated on the graduation for other treatment court programs.
In the same period, the graduation rate from adult drug courts was 52 percent, and the graduation rate from DWI courts was 90 percent, Riggert said.
While Greitens is correct that the veterans treatment courts’ graduation rate was higher than some, such as the adult drug court’s rate, it is still not as high as the DWI court’s graduation rate of 90 percent.
However, Riggert said it may not be accurate to compare graduation rates between treatment courts to prove one program’s success.
"The various types of treatment court programs are distinct, and so it is not helpful to try to make a side-by-side comparison," Riggert said.
While 73 percent of veterans exiting the program did graduate in 2016, it is unclear how many veterans who graduate from the program have to return for additional treatment.
"Because veterans treatment courts are relatively new, we do not yet have sufficient quantifiable data from which to determine recidivism rates for these programs," Riggert said.
Greitens said, "73 percent of our veterans are graduating from drug courts. By contrast, I think most of the people in the very good drug court program — the graduation rate’s like 53, 55 percent. The point of that is that drug courts are working for veterans."
While the overall numbers are small, Greitens is correct that in 2016, 73 percent of veterans successfully completed treatment court. Over the same time period, the overall graduation rate from adult treatment court was 52 percent, officials say.
However, officials also pointed out that the two programs are not identical, which makes comparing them imprecise. In addition, while graduation rate is one measurement of success, it’s not the only one, and as Riggert noted, veteran treatment courts are so new that no data on recidivism rates have been collected.
We rate Greitens’ claim Mostly True.
Facebook Live video, August 13, 2017
Email exchange, Beth Riggert, communications counsel for the Supreme Court of Missouri, Sept. 13-19, 2017
Phone interview, David Shakes, 4th Judicial District Judge, Colorado Judicial Branch, Sept. 18, 2017.
Treatment Court Facts, Drug Courts Coordinating Commission, last revised Sept 2017
Missouri Veterans Treatment Courts map, Office of State Courts Administrator, July 2017
2016 Year-End Report, Drug Courts Coordinating Commission
Treatment Court Reports webpage, Missouri Courts
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.