Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
A first-time-ever claim will almost always get our attention.
Bryce, a union ironworker, was interviewed by CNN talk show host Don Lemon on March 14, 2018. Asked about the surprise win that night by Democrat Conor Lamb in a special House election in Pennsylvania, Bryce said:
Well, he ran a very pro-union campaign. Being a union member, that’s something that’s been very important for me, standing up for working people. I mean, our campaign staff was the first to unionize in the history of politics. So, that’s something I’m very proud of.
Bryce’s campaign spokeswoman, noting it’s hard to prove something has never occurred before, told us she was not aware of any previous campaign staffs that unionized before Bryce’s campaign workers joined the Campaign Workers Guild and forged a contract with Bryce in December 2017. The deal was announced three months later.
The union itself is new, having started organizing in early 2017. So we sought out experts in labor history.
Asking the experts
Of the 12 labor history experts we contacted (see the list of sources accompanying this article), none said they were aware of any previous campaign staffs that had been unionized.
But none could say for sure that it had never happened.
More fact checks on unions:
Here are some of their responses:
I suspect there have been staff who joined unions, but he (Bryce) may be the first to recognize and bargain with them. I don’t know of anyone who’s studied this question. -- University of Minnesota history professor William Jones
I think we can say it’s true for contemporary politics. I am not going to vouch for anything prior to the National Labor Relations Act (signed in 1935) because I’m not sure we would know. -- Kate Bronfenbrenner, labor education research director at Cornell University
I don’t know for sure, but it seems unlikely that in 200+ years no one did this before. -- Ruth Milkman, sociologist of labor and labor movements at City University of New York Graduate Center
I don’t know of any, but that doesn’t mean they don’t exist. There is no central database for local unions, and many do not affiliate with a national union. Campaign staffs could have been unionized and we would never know. -- Rutgers University labor studies professor Dorothy Sue Cobble
We also checked with the National Labor Relations Board, which also does not keep such records.
The Office and Professional Employees International Union wasn’t able to help us and we didn’t hear back from the American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations (AFL-CIO).
Bryce says: "Our campaign staff was the first to unionize in the history of politics."
The dozen experts we consulted said they were not aware of any previous campaign staff unionizing, though they could not state flatly that it had never occurred.
If new information surfaces, we’ll reconsider this rating. For now, we rate it Mostly True.
CNN, Don Lemon interview of Randy Bryce (2:00), March 14, 2018
Email, Randy Bryce campaign spokeswoman Lauren Hitt, April 16, 2018
Campaign Workers Guild, "Our Victories," accessed April 23, 2018
Campaign Workers Guild, news release, Feb. 12, 2018
Email Campaign Workers Guild spokeswoman Meg Reilly, April 22, 2018
Huffington Post, "Why The First Unionized Political Campaign Is A Game-Changer For The Left," Feb. 13, 2018
Bloomberg, "Campaign Workers Unionize Just in Time for Midterm Elections," Feb. 12, 2018
The Nation, "Randy Bryce’s Campaign Is Not Just Pro-Union—It’s Unionized," Feb. 12, 2018
Email, University of Minnesota history professor William Jones, April 20, 2018
Email, National Labor Relations Board staff, April 24, 2018
Email, University of Iowa history professor and labor history expert John McKerley, April 22, 2018
Email, Georgetown University history professor, Joseph McCartin, expert on U.S. labor, social and political history, April 20, 2018
Email, University of Washington political science professor and labor studies director Michael McCann, April 22, 2018
Email, Office and Professional Employees International Union spokeswoman Nicole Korkolis, April 23, 2018
Email, University of Toledo law professor and labor expert Joseph Slater, April 20, 2018
Email, Northwestern University professor of American history and labor union history expert Kevin Boyle, April 22, 2018
Email, City University of New York Graduate Center sociologist of labor and labor movements Ruth Milkman, April 20, 2018
Email, Cornell University labor education research director and industrial and labor relations professor Kate Bronfenbrenner, April 22, 2018
Email, University of Maryland history professor Julie Greene, expert in labor history, April 22, 2018
Email, Cornell University Institute for Public Affairs visiting professor and former deputy U.S. secretary of labor Seth Harris, April 21, 2018
Email, Vanderbilt University history professor and labor history expert Jefferson Cowie, April 22, 2018
Email, Rutgers University labor studies and history professor Dorothy Sue Cobble, April 21, 2018
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.