Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Has West Virginia’s tourism industry been going gangbusters recently? Gov. Jim Justice suggested that it had.
Justice wrote in a tweet, "WV's tourism industry grew at a rate 30% above the national rate in 2017. This increase reversed a four-year decline in which travel-generated spending fell more than $600 million. This is a landmark day for our tourism industry and our economy as a whole!"
In a follow-up tweet, Justice cited a Sept. 9 press release from his office that offered figures from 2012 to 2017 to support his claim.
We decided to zero in on the first part of his assertion -- that "WV's tourism industry grew at a rate 30% above the national rate in 2017." Is that correct?
Let’s start with the percentage comparison.
According to a West Virginia Press report published in the Herald-Dispatch, the data comes from the 2017 West Virginia Travel Impacts study undertaken by the firm Dean Runyan Associates. The study was prepared on behalf of the state tourism office.
The study supports the specific figures Justice cited in his tweet. In the nation as a whole, the report said, spending by resident and foreign visitors increased by 3.0 percent over 2016. In West Virginia, by contrast, total travel spending increased by 3.9 percent.
If you do the math, 3.9 percent is 30 percent higher than 3.0 percent.
That said, it’s worth noting a few additional bits of context.
First, a chunk of these increases stem from inflation. Nationally, the inflation rate was 2.2 percent in 2017. This wouldn’t affect the comparison of West Virginia to the nation as a whole -- both increases were boosted by inflation -- but it does make the 3.9 percent increase in West Virginia less impressive.
Second, Justice chose to highlight the most favorable data in the report. He chose not to highlight the fact that, according to the report, local tax revenue from tourism fell by 2.7 percent over the same period, while state tax revenue fell by 1.2 percent.
How about Justice’s assertion that "this increase reversed a four-year decline in which travel-generated spending fell more than $600 million"?
The report shows that tourism fell by $695 million from 2012 to 2016, a four-year period.
Justice’s office did not respond to the data critiques we sent them.
Justice said, "WV's tourism industry grew at a rate 30% above the national rate in 2017. This increase reversed a four-year decline in which travel-generated spending fell more than $600 million."
He’s right about the comparison of West Virginia and the nation as a whole, and he’s also correct about the decline from 2012 to 2016. However, he engaged in a bit of cherry-picking of the data and glossed over the role of inflation in the state’s tourism spending increase.
We rate the statement Mostly True.
Jim Justice, tweet, Sept. 19, 2018
Dean Runyan Associates, "West Virginia Travel Impacts," September 2018
Beckley Register-Herald, "WV tourism growth above national rate," Sept. 19, 2018
Office of the Governor, "Gov. Justice announces that in 2017 state had first increase in traveler spending since 2012," Sept. 19, 2018
West Virginia Tourism Office, annual report, 2017
Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, annual inflation increases, accessed Dec. 13, 2018
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.