Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
As thousands marched in the streets of London recently to protest funding cuts to the British National Health Service, President Donald Trump took to Twitter to criticize the idea of universal health care.
"The Democrats are pushing for Universal HealthCare while thousands of people are marching in the UK because their U system is going broke and not working. Dems want to greatly raise taxes for really bad and non-personal medical care. No thanks!"
Trump’s Feb. 5 tweet came shortly after Nigel Farage, the former UK Independence Party leader, talked about the NHS march and universal health care on Fox & Friends, warning Americans it would be "politically impossible" to remove such a system once introduced. Trump thanked the network on Twitter for "exposing the truth" shortly after Farage’s appearance.
We wondered how accurate Trump’s claim was that people joined the NHS march because the UK’s universal health care system "is going broke and not working."
We looked at the origins of the march and recent polling statistics about British public opinion on the National Health Service, commonly called the NHS. We also looked at the current funding situation, since Trump’s claim suggests it’s losing money. We found that Trump’s tweet gives a misleading impression about how the British public feels about its health care system.
University of North Carolina health policy professor and deputy director of the Cecil G. Sheps Center for Health Services Research, Thomas C. Ricketts, told PolitiFact that the NHS probably has higher public support than any other government program in the UK.
Public support for the NHS being maintained in its current form remains high according to a poll by Ipsos; 77 percent of people support this, while 9 in 10 people think the founding principles of the NHS should still apply to services today. Two-thirds of adults are willing to pay more of their own taxes to pay for the NHS.
In a poll by YouGov last year, 84 percent of people were in favor of the service continuing to be run by the public sector.
Helen Howson, the director of the Bevan Commission, an independent think tank for health in Wales, is working to find ways to improve the system while maintaining the principles set out at its founding.
"The NHS is a service which was set up to ensure that no one would be disadvantaged on the basis of their ability to pay, and people are passionate about these principles," she said.
The NHS march, officially named, "NHS in crisis: Fix it now" was organized by the People’s Assembly, an independent, national campaign against austerity and Health Campaigns Together, a coalition defending the NHS.
This year marks 70 years of NHS existence in the U.K., but the health care system has gone through what has been described as the worst winter in its recent history. The lack of funding is often blamed on austerity measures put forth by the Conservative Party and there have been concerns raised over privatizing parts of the system.
Trump’s comments regarding the demonstration received immediate response by British officials, such as Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn, who said people were marching because they love the NHS and hate what is being happening to it by the current party in power.
Health minister Jeremy Hunt, who was largely blamed for the severe lack of winter funding, hit back at Trump’s remarks, writing on Twitter that not one of the marchers "wants to live in a system where 28m people have no cover."
This is not to say that people don’t have concerns about the NHS. In a poll released last summer by the British Medical Association, more people are unhappy with the NHS than satisfied for the first time in the public poll run by British doctors. It showed that 70 percent of people think the health service is going in the wrong direction.
The poll shows that 43 percent of respondents are dissatisfied with the service, which is double the number of dissatisfaction percentage in only two years. About 33 percent of respondents say they are satisfied. The poll also concluded that 82 percent of people are worried about the future of the NHS, 62 percent expect the NHS to get worse in the coming years and only 13 percent think that it will improve.
The leading concerns of the respondents included a lack of funding, the possibility that the NHS may cease to be free at the point of use, increased waiting times and a lack of attention given to the service because of Brexit.
Trump also claimed that Democrats are pushing a similar health care plan to the NHS in the United States. Democrats have devised plans ranging from a total-government "Medicare for all," also known as a single-payer health system, to a more limited "public option" that pits individual government-run plans up against private insurance for people who weren’t able to find affordable coverage in Obamacare. The latter allows Americans to gain access to government insurance alongside private health care plans.
The current version of Obamacare, more formally known as the Affordable Care Act, has little resemblance to the NHS, where the government owns most of the hospitals and clinics, and doctors and nurses are government employees.
Trump said, "The Democrats are pushing for Universal HealthCare while thousands of people are marching in the UK because their U system is going broke and not working. Dems want to greatly raise taxes for really bad and non-personal medical care. No thanks!"
While the NHS has lost funding over the years, the march that took place was not in opposition to the service, but a call to increase funding and stop austerity cuts towards health and social care. The march resulted because people want universal health care to work better, not because they want it taken over by the private sector.
We rate this Mostly False.
Twitter, @realDonaldTrump tweet, Feb 5, 2018
Twitter, @realDonaldTrump tweet, Feb 5, 2018
Twitter, @jeremycorbyn tweet, Feb 5, 2018
Twitter, @Jeremy_Hunt tweet, Feb 5, 2018
The Guardian, NHS protest: thousands march to demand more cash for NHS, Feb 4, 2018
The Guardian, Nigel Farage says Brexit and Trump win are "beginning of global revolution", Feb 24, 2017
Sky News, Thousands march to Downing Street over NHS "crisis", Feb 3, 2018
BBC, £72,500 social care cap to be scrapped, MPs told, Dec. 7, 2017
The Independent, NHS cuts blamed for 30,000 deaths in new study, Feb 17, 2017
The Hill, British health secretary fires back at Trump over universal health care claims, Feb 5, 2018
The Evening Standard, Donald Trump’s attack on NHS slapped down by Theresa May and health chief Simon Stevens, Feb 5, 2018
BBC, Missed NHS targets spell trouble, Feb 5, 2018
The Daily Mirror, Doctors are attacking Jeremy Hunt as he FINALLY admits "winter crisis" in the NHS in tweet attacking Tony Blair, Jan 4, 2018
The Daily Telegraph, NHS chief hits back at Donald Trump over Twitter attacks on "broke" NHS, Feb 5, 2018
The Guardian, UK public are more dissatisfied than ever with NHS, poll shows June 26, 2017
University of Oxford, 30,000 excess deaths in 2015 linked to cuts in health and social care Feb 20, 2017
Ipsos, What do the public think about the NHS?, September 16, 2017
YouGov, Nationalisation vs privatisation: the public view, May 19, 2017
Interview with Thomas C. Ricketts, University of North Carolina health policy professor and deputy director of the Cecil G. Sheps Center for Health Services Research, February 6, 2018
Interview with Ian Shaw, Professor of health policy at the University of Nottingham, February 6, 2018
Interview with Christopher Newdick, professor of Health Law at the University of Reading. February 7, 2018
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.