Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
In a recent TV attack ad in the California governor’s race, Gavin Newsom’s campaign claimed "the state auditor found (John) Chiang lost track of $31 billion," when he was state controller. But did the ad get its facts straight?
Here’s the full text of the TV spot:
Narrator: "As California Controller, John Chiang’s job was to count the money. But the state auditor found Chiang lost track of $31 billion dollars. That’s right. Billion with a "B." And Chiang made tens of billions in accounting errors.
What was John Chiang paying attention to? His special interest campaign contributors. The Sacramento Bee found Chiang gave millions in tax breaks to big developers who gave big money to John Chiang’s campaign.
John Chiang for Governor?
Doesn’t add up.
This is a screen shot from the ad. View the full ad by the Gavin Newsom for Governor campaign here.
In this fact check, we focused on the ad’s eye-popping claim: the state auditor found Chiang, who is now state treasurer, "lost track of $31 billion."
Background on candidates
Newsom is a Democrat, the state’s lieutenant governor and a former mayor of San Francisco. He has consistently led in the polls in the race for governor — a late May survey showed him 13 percentage points ahead of second place Republican businessman John Cox. He was 26 points ahead of Chiang, who was next-to-last among the race’s prominent candidates.
Recently, Newsom said he’d prefer to face a Republican in the November run-off, making his attacks on Democrats like Chiang appear to be part of his strategy.
Chiang has served as treasurer since January 2015. Before that, he was the state’s controller, akin to the state’s chief financial officer, for eight years.
The top two candidates in the June 5 primary, regardless of party affiliation, will move on to the November runoff.
Asked for evidence that "the state auditor found Chiang lost track of $31 billion," Newsom’s campaign pointed to a May 2014 news article by CBS13, a Sacramento TV station. It was headlined "$31.65 Billion: California Accounting Errors Higher Than Combined GDP Of Jamaica, Iceland."
The CBS13 article refers to a scathing May 2014 report by the California State Auditor’s Office that found deficiencies in the state’s internal financial reporting practices. The mistakes ranged from understating liabilities, to miscalculating debt payments, to a data-entry error that added three extra zeros to a revenue figure, changing it from millions of dollars to billions.
"The number and magnitude of errors we found indicate the Controller’s Office lacks a sufficient review process to prevent and detect significant errors," Deputy State Auditor John Collins concluded in the report, which was submitted to Gov. Jerry Brown and top state lawmakers.
Collins did not respond to requests for an interview.
Stacking up $31 billion
The state audit and a 2014 Sacramento Bee article, which summarized the audit, were both referenced in the ad. The Bee article used a less sensational headline: Audit: State Controller’s Office accounting riddled with errors, and had no mention of a $31 billion dollar figure.
The audit itself does not literally say Chiang "lost track of $31 billion."
The ad, however, overlays "$31 Billion" in large, bold numerals at the top of an image of the auditor’s report. The numbers even pop out at the viewer at one point.
That $31 billion figure comes from the TV station’s article, which added up the dollar amounts of key mistakes cited in the audit.
Here’s how CBS13 arrived at $31 billion:
"The audit revealed:
-- $7.7 billion – Understated federal trust fund revenues and expenditures
-- $653 million – Overstated general fund assets and revenues
-- $8 billion – Overstated California State University’s bond debt
-- $9.1 billion – Reporting error that understated a public building construction fund
Also there was a deferred tax-revenue figure posted as $6.2 billion when it was actually $6.2 million.
All told, that’s more than $31 billion in mistakes."
We checked and found all of those figures in the audit.
More to the story
There’s some truth to the ad’s claim, given the critical nature of the audit and the large dollar figure mistakes it found. But the use of the phrase "lost track of $31 billion" is somewhat questionable. It could leave the impression that Chiang’s actions led to the state actually losing that money, which it did not.
The spot also omits the fact that Chiang’s office acknowledged the problems and was taking steps to correct them.
"The (state controller’s office) concurs with the California State Auditor’s (CSAs) notation and believes that the challenges of high staff turnover and in recruiting qualified staff significantly contributed to the issues identified," the 2014 audit said. "Other contributing factors included budget cuts and denial of financial resources, as well as poor quality and late submission of the financial data by numerous agencies."
What did subsequent audits show?
In March 2015, the state auditor’s office released another report that "concludes that the State continues to experience certain deficiencies in its accounting and administrative practices that affect its internal controls over financial reporting."
That report blamed agencies such as the Department of Education for inaccurate financial reporting, though it did not directly criticize the controller’s office.
Subsequent auditor reports show apparent improvement in Chiang’s final years as treasurer and those immediately after.
In its March 2017 report, for example, the auditor’s report "did not identify material weaknesses or significant deficiencies" in financial reporting for the fiscal year that ended in June 2016.
Response from Chiang’s campaign
Chiang’s campaign downplayed the significance of the 2014 audit report. They said a separate document, called a Comprehensive Annual Financial Report, issued later that year was more reflective of the performance of the controller’s office.
"Nobody is more a financial expert in the state than John," Chiang’s campaign spokesman Fabien Levy said. "Nobody is more obsessed with getting the numbers right."
A TV attack ad by Gavin Newsom’s campaign for governor claims "the state auditor found Chiang lost track of $31 billion dollars," when he was state controller.
A 2014 state audit supports part of the claim. It criticized the state controller’s office for understating billions of dollars in liabilities, miscalculating debt payments and making other errors.
A TV news station added up some of the highest dollar figure mistakes and presented them as "$31.65 billion in errors."
The state audit did not literally say the controller’s office made "$31 billion" in mistakes, nor did it imply that the money was permanently lost under Chiang, but instead that his office made numerous accounting mistakes.
The ad also ignored that Chiang’s office, according to the audit, acknowledged the mistakes, worked to fix them and blamed the errors on staffing shortages.
Newsom’s claim is partially accurate. But it takes information in the audit out of context and ignores key details.
We rate it Half True.
HALF TRUE – The statement is partially accurate but leaves out important details or takes things out of context.
Gavin Newsom campaign attack ad, May 2018
Nathan Click, Newsom’s campaign spokesman, email exchange May 22, 2018
Fabien Levy, Chiang’s campaign spokesman, phone interview May 25, 2018
Hollie Andrus, financial audit director, State of Utah, phone interview, May 30, 2018
California State Auditor, Internal Control and Compliance Audit Report for the Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2013, May 2014
California State Auditor, Internal Control and Compliance Audit Report for the Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2014, March 2015
California State Auditor, Internal Control and Compliance Audit Report for the Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2015, March 2016
California State Auditor, Internal Control and Compliance Audit Report for the Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2016, March 2017
California Controller’s Office, Comprehensive Annual Financial Report, For the Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2013
Sacramento Bee, Audit: State Controller’s Office accounting riddled with errors, May 29, 2014
CBS13 Sacramento, $31.65 Billion: California Accounting Errors Higher Than Combined GDP Of Jamaica, Iceland, May 29, 2014
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.