Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
Senior citizens care a lot about drug prices and the future of Medicare, so it was no surprise that at a July 15 AARP-sponsored presidential candidate forum in Iowa the first question posed to Sen. Amy Klobuchar was on those topics.
As president, Klobuchar said, she would unleash the bargaining power of Medicare to lower drug prices. But she noted what she would be up against: "There are, literally, two pharmaceutical lobbyists for every member of Congress. They think they own Congress. They don’t own me."
The Minnesota Democrat’s comment tapped into ongoing concern about the political power of drugmakers in the ongoing debate over U.S. drug prices, which are the highest in the world for brand-name products.
Congress and the president say they want to lower them, but so far there’s been little demonstrable action or results.
We decided to take a look: Are lawmakers in Washington that outnumbered by pharma lobbyists?
We contacted Klobuchar’s campaign to find out the basis for her statement. They quickly sent over information from OpenSecrets — a website that tracks the number of lobbyists and the spending on lobbying — and promised to get back in touch with confirmation that the site was the senator’s source. We haven’t heard any more.
By the numbers
Still, the OpenSecrets information became our starting point. Their data comes from reports filed quarterly by lobbyists, lobbying firms and organizations with the secretary of the Senate. Lobbyists must register with the secretary’s office if they are paid to lobby on behalf of a client, make more than one contact with government officials regarding the client’s issues and spend at least 20% of their time on lobbying and related activities.
OpenSecrets counted 1,451 pharmaceutical/health products lobbyists in 2018, the last full year of data available. That category goes beyond just prescription drugs to include lobbyists for medical device makers and producers of over-the-counter health products.
Using a narrower definition that included only lobbyists representing pharmaceutical manufacturing interests, the group’s count came to 828.
So then we did the math. There are 535 members of Congress; 100 serve in the Senate and 435 in the House of Representatives.
It turns out Klobuchar is either over- or undercounting, depending on how broadly one defines the pharmaceutical industry.
There are 2.7 lobbyists per member of Congress if one looks at the broader pharmaceutical/health products industry, but only 1.5 per member when considering only drugmakers.
"It’s a lot either way," said Steven Knievel, the access-to-medicines advocate at Public Citizen.
And how do these tallies stack up against other industries?
The 1,451 pharma/health products lobbyists outnumbered lobbyists in all 89 other categories, according to an analysis by Daniel Auble, a senior researcher at OpenSecrets. The electronics manufacturing and equipment industry came in second, with 1,121 lobbyists last year. Education was third, with 1,027. Tied for last place — with eight each — were lobbyists for women’s issues and those lobbying for or against abortion rights.
Industry lobbyists outnumber consumer lobbyists across the board, said experts. And that means members of Congress and their staffers are "hearing over and over again from industry because it has more lobbyists than anyone else," said Lee Drutman, senior fellow at the think tank New America and author of The Business of America Is Lobbying.
Many of those lobbyists are more experienced than the young staffers they meet with, he noted. When lawmakers and staff members hear far more from one side of an issue, it can lead to a "distorted picture of how regulations might work or affect public health," said Drutman.
Knievel agreed. When he heads to Capitol Hill to talk with lawmakers, they’ve generally heard more from industry than "from people who are trying to lower health costs," he said. "Having the resources and human power to do that makes them formidable and influential."
The second part of Klobuchar’s statement — that drug company lobbyists "own Congress" — brings up another element of this issue: In Washington, money and lobbying go hand in hand. The drug industry certainly has one of the biggest war chests for spending on lobbying.
Last year, lobbying spending by pharmaceutical groups and health product providers, which includes makers of medical devices and other health-related items, totaled $283 million, according to OpenSecrets.
The amount spent by drugmakers alone is huge: $169 million lobbying last year. That’s the most since 2009, in the heat of the debate over the Affordable Care Act.
The second-place finisher, the insurance industry, spent $158 million.
So what’s the drug industry lobbying on? Its latest concerns revolve around drug prices. Whenever it perceives a threat or an opportunity — such as when Congress was debating the ACA in 2009, or now, with candidates, the president and Congress all focused on the high price of prescription medicines — the industry ramps up spending.
"Companies are somewhat responsive to the political environment," said Drutman.
And, of course, the drug industry funnels millions of dollars in campaign contributions directly to members of Congress each year.
Klobuchar said: "There are, literally, two pharmaceutical lobbyists for every member of Congress."
We found that there are more than twice as many pharma lobbyists per member of Congress if one looks at the broader category that includes representatives of health products, but only 1.5 per member if the comparison is restricted only to those lobbying for drug companies.
We rate her statement as Mostly True.
Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-Minn.), at an AARP/Des Moines Register candidate forum July 15.
Email interview with Klobuchar campaign spokeswoman Carlie Waibel, July 17.
Health Affairs, "Using External Reference Pricing in Medicare Part D to Reduce Drug Price Differentials With Other Countries," May 2019.
OpenSecrets data on pharmaceutical industry/health products lobbying, 2018, accessed July 17.
OpenSecrets data on pharmaceutical manufacturer lobbying, 2018, accessed July 17.
Email interviews with Dan Auble, a senior researcher at OpenSecrets, July 17 and July 19.
Telephone interview with Steven Knievel, an advocate for Public Citizen’s access-to-medicines program, July 18.
Telephone interview with Lee Drutman, senior fellow in the political reform program at New America; author of The Business of America Is Lobbying (Oxford University Press, 2015), July 19.
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.