Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
In the middle of Black History Month, the Missouri Legislative Black Caucus held a press conference where Rep. Tommie Pierson Jr. claimed no African-Americans have presented the state budget to the House Budget Committee this year.
"As I have been sitting in the budgetary process here in the Missouri House, we have been reviewing facts and figures and numbers as we have been looking at the $28 billion Missouri budget," Pierson said. "And those folks who have been coming before us – statewide elected officials, directors, deputy directors, analysts, and on and on – I have been trying to keep a tally of a number. And the number is how many African Americans have presented this $28 billion Missouri budget, and that number is zero."
Pierson said, when talking about diversity and inclusivity, who is in state leadership should be taken into consideration. He is concerned by the lack of African-American representation in decisions on how to allocate $28 billion of state money.
We wanted to know if Pierson is correct.
First, a little backstory on how the state budget process works: Heads of state departments make presentations to the budget committee in the House and the appropriations committee in the Senate. In these presentations, leaders of departments in the executive branch discuss the financial needs of their departments with the legislators in charge of appropriating funds to the departments. The executive branch is made up of 16 executive departments and six statewide elected officials.
State Rep. Cody Smith, R-Carthage, is the chair for the House Budget Committee. His chief of staff Chris Dunn explained that directors of state departments or elected officials and their director of finance usually present the budget for their department. He emphasized that the budget committee does not choose who presents the budget, the departments presenting make that decision internally.
According to the minutes from the Missouri House of Representatives, every state department direction but one presented their department budget to the House Budget Committee. Chlora Lindley-Myers is the director of the Department of Insurance, Financial Institutions and Professional Registration and an African-American, but she did not present the budget for her department.
Lori Cory, a spokeswoman for the department, said in an email, "Director Lindley-Myers was unable to be present at the Jan. 31 presentation to the House Budget Committee due to a previous commitment. She was attending a National Association of Insurance Commissioners Meeting."
The deputy director and department budget officer presented in her absence, but Lindley-Meyers did present to the Senate Appropriations Committee, Croy said.
The lack of African-Americans presenting the state budget reflects a larger concern: the lack of African-Americans in high ranking positions in statewide offices. Of the 22 offices in the executive branch, only two are headed by non-white people.
We spoke to Steele Shippy, the communications director for Gov. Mike Parson. Shippy defended the racial diversity in the governor’s cabinet, pointing to Lindley-Myers and Anna Hui, director of the state Department of Labor.
The Department of Labor’s website says Hui is the first Asian-American to serve in the governor’s cabinet. She was appointed in March 2017 and confirmed in January 2018.
The directors of the executive departments are appointed by the governor. Department directors do not always leave their position with the turnover of the governor, so many of the current department directors were appointed by former Govs. Jay Nixon and Eric Greitens.
Parson’s office declined to answer questions in regards to the office’s awareness of the lack of diversity or efforts to promote diversity.
Pierson said no African-Americans presented the state budget to the House Budget Committee.
According to records from the House of Representatives and other sources, he is correct.
The only African-American state department director, Chlora Lindley-Myers, did not present to the House Budget Committee due to a prior commitment in her schedule.
We rate this statement True.
Rep. Tommie Pierson Jr., Legislative Black Caucus Press Conference, Feb. 18, 2019
Interview with Chris Dunn, Chief of Staff for Budget Chiar Cody Smith, Feb. 25, 2019
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.