Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
Wisconsin has lost more than 90,000 manufacturing jobs since 2001
The trade deficit with China did influence the loss of manufacturing jobs
One study blamed nearly all U.S. manufacturing job loss on China, but several others say factors such as productivity played an equal or greater role.
Is China to blame for all the manufacturing jobs Wisconsin lost in recent decades?
That’s the claim from a Facebook video making the rounds in the runup to the November 2020 presidential election.
President Donald Trump and former Vice President Joe Biden are ramping up their own campaign ads, but an avalanche of outside groups are trying to get their own messages across.
A June 4, 2020 Facebook video from conservative SuperPAC America First Action attacks the former vice president for not understanding "the threat" China poses to the United States.
The video features Biden and then-Secretary of State Hillary Clinton at a State Department luncheon on January 19, 2011, toasting Hu Jintao, who was president of China at the time.
The caption of the video reads: "China Has Been Stealing Our Manufacturing, Costing Wisconsin Almost 90,000 Jobs! Joe Biden Doesn't Understand the Threat. To Stop China, You Have to Stop Joe Biden."
This post was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook).
We are going to focus on the first part of that caption.
Has China really cost Wisconsin 90,000 jobs?
When asked to back up the claim, America First Action spokesperson Kelly Sadler pointed to a January 30, 2020, report from the Economic Policy Institute, a left-leaning think tank.
The report argues the United States’ trade deficit with China has cost Americans millions of jobs since China joined the World Trade Organization in 2001. It estimates 88,900 Wisconsin jobs were displaced due to the "goods trade deficit with China" from 2001 to 2018.
The report claims the growing trade deficit over the 17-year period "was responsible for the loss of 3.7 million U.S. jobs," including 2.8 million manufacturing jobs.
The deficit is substantial. In 2019 alone, the U.S. imported $345 billion more in goods from China than it exported.
And the manufacturing climate has certainly changed in the last two decades.
An analysis of Census data by PolitiFact found that the U.S. lost more than 60,000 factories from 2001 to 2017.
What’s more, Federal Reserve Economic data shows the number of employees in manufacturing jobs in Wisconsin decreased from about 584,400 in January 2001 to around 483,400 in January 2020.
So Wisconsin did lose about 100,000 manufacturing jobs since 2001, but is it reasonable to attribute that all to China?
China has had a significant negative effect on Wisconsin’s manufacturing workforce, but that doesn’t mean it is the only factor in job loss.
David Hummels, a professor of economics at Purdue University, said trade deficits do not "cause" job losses. Instead, he pointed to specialization, saying trade can cause particular sectors of the economy to expand or contract.
He noted people tend to buy things that have a lower cost and higher quality. Since production in certain industries tends to be cheaper in China, U.S.-based manufacturers are sometimes left out of the competition.
Hummels also said that while some changes in unemployment can be attributed to China, technological changes also influence employment rates.
Michael Hicks, a professor of economics at Ball State University, echoed this idea. Hicks noted Wisconsin’s factory employment rate rose after 2010, even as the U.S.’s trade deficit with China continued to increase.
Hicks led a 2017 study that found productivity increases had resulted in 88 percent of job losses in manufacturing in the United States. The study estimated trade accounted for just 13.4% of losses between 2000 and 2010.
While Wisconsin’s factory employment shrank from 2001 to 2018, non-factory employment rose by more than 400,000, he noted in an email.
"If you are going to blame China for the lost factory jobs, you need to also credit them with the gain of 409,000 non-factory jobs," he said.
Kurt Bauer, president of industry trade group Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce, attributed the loss of Wisconsin manufacturing jobs to trade, as well as demographics, in a fall 2019 magazine column
Bauer claimed that 81% of WMC members said they are having trouble finding workers "because there are simply fewer people of working age in Wisconsin."
"I would argue that demographics may be impacting job numbers just as much as economic factors," he wrote in the column.
That’s not to say China had no role, of course.
"It is reasonable to say that trade with China, along with changes in mechanization and automation, led to a pretty sharp contraction in manufacturing employment in the U.S. since 2000," said Hummels, the professor from Purdue.
America First Action on Facebook said China has cost Wisconsin almost 90,000 jobs.
The state has in fact lost around 90,000 manufacturing jobs since the early 2000s. While this shift in the number of jobs can be partially attributed to the trade deficit with China, experts say that is not the only factor.
Our definition of Mostly False is "the statement contains an element of truth but ignores critical facts that would give a different impression."
That fits here.
America First Action, Facebook, June 6, 2020
America First Action, Facebook video #2, June 2020
Email with David Hummels, professor of economics, Purdue University, June, 30, 2020
Email with Kelly Sadler, Communications Director, America First, June 30, 2020
Email with Michael Hicks, professor of economics, Ball State University, July 1, 2020
Email Interview Menzie David Chinn, professor of economics and public affairs, University of Wisconsin–Madison, July 1, 2020
CSPAN, President Hu Luncheon Toasts, Jan. 19, 2011
Economic Policy Institute, Growing China trade deficit cost 3.7 million American jobs between 2001 and 2018, January 30, 2020
PolitiFact National, Trump: Since China joined WTO, U.S. has lost 60,000 factories, March 24, 2017
U.S. State Department, China: WTO Accession and Permanent Normal Trade Relations (PNTR), May 24, 2000
Federal Reserve Economic Data, All Employees: Manufacturing in Wisconsin, May 2020
U.S. Census Bureau, Trade in Goods with China, Accessed June 30, 2020
Hicks and Devaraj, Ball State University study, April 2017
PolitiFact Wisconsin, Dissecting the spin on manufacturing numbers, November 13, 2019
Wisconsin Business Voice, Manufacturing Slowdown Has Multiple Causes, Fall 2019
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.