Thurmond
Says Marshall Tuck "is backed by Donald Trump’s education advisor" pictured as Betsy DeVos. 

Tony Thurmond on Thursday, October 11th, 2018 in a campaign ad

False

Ad wrongly implies Marshall Tuck is ‘backed’ by Betsy DeVos

A Tony Thurmond campaign ad falsely suggests U.S. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos supports Marshall Tuck.

An attack ad in the race to be California’s next schools chief strongly suggests candidate Marshall Tuck is "backed" by U.S. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos, a polarizing Trump administration appointee.

Tuck is a Democrat and former education executive. He’s running for State Superintendent of Public Instruction against State Asm. Tony Thurmond, also a Democrat, whose campaign produced the ad. The incumbent, Tom Torlakson, will be termed out in January after serving two four-year terms.

Here’s what the ad claims, as a photo of President Trump standing next to DeVos appears on the screen and then zooms in on DeVos.

"Tuck is backed by Donald Trump’s education advisor and financed by the same billionaires behind Betsy DeVos."

Ad by Tony Thurmond campaign

Both Tuck and DeVos support charter schools. Meanwhile, Thurmond is a strong advocate for public schools.

Tuck has said he supports nonprofit charter schools in areas with few quality public school alternatives, though he wants to implement some changes. According to his website, he wants to make for-profit charter schools illegal, require greater school transparency and open charter schools to all students.

But we wanted to know whether DeVos really supports Tuck in the race, as the ad suggests.

Our research

DeVos’ office did not respond to our requests for comment.

We asked Thurmond’s campaign about the claim. Instead of providing evidence that DeVos supports Tuck, they said he’s backed by Bill Evers.

Evers is a research fellow at the Hoover Institution who specializes in education policy. He was also "head of the ‘agency action team’ for the U.S. Department of Education in the Trump transition from early September 2016 through January 2017," according to his biography.

In June, Evers posted a pro-Tuck campaign ad on Facebook and supported Tuck four years ago in his run for the same office. He’s not, however, on the long list of supporters on Tuck’s website. A spokesman for Tuck's campaign said Evers probably supports Tuck but hasn't made any financial contributions.

Tuck's website includes a news article by the Independent Voter Network website that refers to Evers as a supporter of Tuck. 

Evers did not respond to a request for comment. 

Perhaps more importantly, the ad never mentions Evers’ name or shows his photo. Its primary focus is on DeVos.

A spokesman for the Tuck campaign called the claim "a false and misleading attack by Tony Thurmond." He pointed to examples of Tuck criticizing DeVos.

"I’d rate Betsy DeVos extremely low. I think she is not qualified really for that job," Tuck said in a video posted in March by the news website gvwire.com.

"I’ve been very clear: My agenda is strongly against the Trump/DeVos agenda," he added at a campaign forum in May.

Our ruling

State Asm. Tony Thurmond, a candidate for California schools chief, left the strong impression in a recent ad that his opponent, Marshall Tuck, "is backed" by U.S. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos.

The ad zooms in on a photo of DeVos as it says Tuck "is backed by Donald Trump’s education advisor."

But Tuck has criticized DeVos and the Thurmond campaign offered no evidence she supports Tuck. They did say that Bill Evers, who advised Trump on education during his transition, supports Tuck. But he’s not mentioned by name or shown in the ad, and Tuck doesn’t list him as a supporter on his website.

In the end, we agreed the ad is misleading. It gives the impression DeVos supports Tuck. But there’s zero evidence to back that up.

We rate the claim False.


FALSE – The statement is not accurate.

Click here for more on the six PolitiFact ratings and how we select facts to check.

UPDATE: We have updated our fact check to show that Tuck's website includes a news article by the Independent Voter Network website that refers to Evers as a supporter of Tuck. 
 
Share the Facts
2
1
7
PolitiFact rating logo PolitiFact Rating:
False
Says Marshall Tuck "is backed by Donald Trump’s education advisor" pictured as Betsy DeVos.
Thursday, October 11, 2018

Related fact checks:

FALSE: Attack ad’s claim Tony Thurmond was ‘reprimanded’ by Obama

FALSE: Attack ad’s claim Tony Thurmond was ‘sued by the ACLU’

x

THE FACTS

Delivered to your inbox weekly

x

This donation will make you a Inside Voice member.

For Membership benefits click here