Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Filing legislation that would require someone selling property to disclose whether a home swimming pool or hot tub has a hazardous drain, state Sen. Leticia Van de Putte, D-San Antonio, said in a press release: "Too many Texas children are harmed and killed in pools."
"Since 1980, over 145 incidents have been documented of suction entrapment in swimming pools and spas, including 36 deaths of children," according to her Feb. 16 press release.
Her proposed legislation amends the state’s seller’s disclosure notice so that sellers say whether the property has a single blockable main drain in a pool, hot tub or spa, which "may cause a suction entrapment hazard for an individual."
Van de Putte spokeswoman Sarah Gomez told us the senator has offered pool safety legislation the past three sessions. In 2009, the Senate approved her measure requiring residential pools and spas built or installed in Texas to be enclosed by barriers preventing small children from entering unsupervised, among other stipulations. It died in the House.
Responding to our request for back-up for the senator’s numbers, Gomez sent us the background from a 2007 federal law, an earlier study of entrapment dangers and articles indicating a federal agency has long tracked entrapment incidents and resulting deaths.
The background section of the 2007 Virgina Graeme Baker Pool and Safety Spa Act, a federal law setting tougher safety standards for public pools and spas, says that at least 33 children 14 and younger died from 1985 through 2000 as a result of drain entrapment.
Gomez also provided a May 2006 study by Safe Kids Worldwide, a Washington-based group which launched in 1988 to advocate childhood injury prevention. The group joined with Nancy Baker to advocate for the act named after her daughter, who drowned in a hot tub at a family friend’s home in Virginia after she was entrapped by the drain’s suction.
The study states that "entrapment occurs when part of a child’s body becomes attached to a drain as a result of the powerful suction of the water circulation system, or an arm or leg is inserted into a drain with a missing or broken cover." A child can drown if the suction overpowers his or her ability to disengage.
According to an October 2003 Pool & Spa News article, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission confirmed 147 suction entrapment incidents from 1985 and March 2002, resulting in 36 deaths — not all of them children. We asked Gomez about the senator’s reference to 36 child deaths, Gomez said Van de Putte misread that statistic. "It was 36 total deaths," she said. "It was not intentional and she was not trying to mislead anyone."
Next, Tanya Chin Ross, director of policy for Safe Kids Worldwide, pointed us to a May 2010 memo from the product safety commission tracking drain entrapments and deaths each year from 1999 to 2009, listing 94 entrapments in pools, spas and whirlpool tubs — including 49 incidents in residential facilities. The agency’s tally suggests that at least six entrapped children died from 2001 through 2009, a result that would make the total of confirmed child deaths from such incidents since 1985 at least 39.
According to the memo, the commission eliminated reports that didn’t involve drain entrapments or were duplicates. Commission spokeswoman Kathleen Reilly told us that the agency investigates incident reports it receives directly. Otherwise, the agency tries to confirm claims "by getting as much data as possible," including hospital and police reports, she said.
Reilly told us that between 1985 and 2009, the agency received reports of 154 incidents resulting from pool, spa, hot tub or whirlpool entrapments, including 54 deaths; she didn’t have a count for children who died.
Finally, we sought Texas-specific data. Carrie Williams, a spokeswoman with the Texas Department of State Health Services, told us the agency tabulates pool drownings, but not yet drain entrapments.
All told, it looks like Van de Putte understates the 154 people, at least, who have been sucked into a U.S. pool or spa drain. While her backup information didn’t prove that 36 children died as a result, the sources we culled suggest that at least 39 children have perished.
We rate her statement as True.
Press release: Senator Van de Putte files legislation to increase swimming pool safety, Feb. 16, 2011
S.B. 710 relating to the disclosure of a hazardous drain in a swimming pool or spa by a seller of residential real property, filed Feb. 15, 2011
S.B. 96 relating to swimming pool and spa safety, filed Nov. 10, 2008
S.B. 971, relating to swimming pool safety, filed Feb. 27, 2007
E-mail interview with Sarah Gomez, communications director for Sen. Leticia Van de Putte, March 9, 2011
Virginia Graeme Baker Pool and Spa Safety Act, enacted Dec. 19, 2007
Safe Kids Worldwide, Pool and spa drowning: A national study of drain entrapment and pool safety measures, May 2006
CNN.com, Larry King Live interview with Jim and Nancy Baker transcript, May 2, 2006
Article for Common Ground (Jan/Feb 2009 issue, December release) by Paul Clapper, vice president of Greater Houston Pool Management, Inc.
Business Wire, Press release: Simulation of water circulation improves safety of swimming pools, April 27, 2006
Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, New safety law pushes pools to retrofit, Feb. 13, 2009
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, 1999-2009 report circulation/suction entrapments associated with pools, spas and whirlpool tubs, 2010 memorandum, May 24, 2010
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Hair entanglement, entrapment and disembowelment associated with spas, swimming pools and wading pools since January 1, 1990 Oct. 25, 1996
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, CPSC issues warning for pools, spas and hot tubs, June 3, 1996
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Draft: guidelines for entrapment hazards: Making pools and spas safer, November 2004
Texas Department of State Health Services, Statutes and Laws: Public swimming pools and spas, accessed March 15, 2011
The New York Times, New laws try to keep swimmers safe, June 15, 2008
Interview with Tanya Chin Ross, director of public policy, Safe Kids Worldwide, March 11, 2011
E-mail interview with Kathleen Reilly, spokeswoman, U.S. Consumer and Product Safety Commission, March 14, 2011
E-mail interview with Carrie Williams, press officer, Department of State Health Services, March 14, 2011
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.