Get PolitiFact in your inbox.

Tom Feran
By Tom Feran November 8, 2011

Retiring couples get $3 in Medicare benefits for each $1 paid in, Rob Portman says

The Joint Select Committee on Deficit Reduction, better known as the congressional "super committee," has a deadline of Nov. 23 to come up with a plan to reduce the federal budget deficit by $1.5 trillion over 10 years.

Democrats on the bipartisan, 12-member panel offered a proposal in late October that included about $400 billion in cuts to Medicare. While the plan had no chance of winning approval from the committee's Republicans, who have said they will not accept a package with tax increases, it underlined the point that any plan is certain to make cuts to federal entitlement programs, especially Medicare.

The super committee's co-chair, Texas Republican Rep. Jeb Hensarling, noted in a hearing on Nov. 1 that President Obama had called Medicare and Medicaid "the single biggest drivers of the federal deficit and the federal debt by a huge margin."

More attention focused on health care in the hearing, which featured testimony by the co-chairs of the National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform, former Wyoming Sen. Alan Simpson and former White House Chief of Staff Erskine Bowles.

Sen. Rob Portman at one point described Medicare now as an unsustainable program.

"A couple retiring today will pay about $119,000 in lifetime Medicare taxes and receive about $357,000 in lifetime Medicare benefits," the Ohio Republican said. "So that's about 3 bucks in benefits for every dollar in taxes. If you multiply this by the 77 million retiring baby boomers, it's not hard to see why we have an unsustainable program."

Featured Fact-check

PolitiFact Ohio knew the prospects for Medicare sustaining itself weren’t good, but we were surprised at the 3-to-1 ratio of benefits to taxes, particularly because of the popular belief among recipients that "you earned it, you paid for it."

We asked Portman's office for background.

They referred us to a study from the Urban Institute, a nonpartisan public policy organization. Authored by fellow Eugene Steuerle, a former Treasury Department official, the widely cited study was published early this year and subsequently updated.

It says a two-income couple in which both partners earned an average wage ($43,500 each in 2011) and retired in 2011 would pay $119,000 in Medicare taxes and receive $357,000 in benefits.

We looked more closely at the study and found that the ratio was even more skewed for a single-income couple.

"Over a wide range of scenarios, beneficiaries retiring at age 65 in 2011 can expect to receive dramatically more in total benefits than they have paid in dedicated taxes," it concluded. "If only one member of the couple had worked, we calculate a six-fold difference between contributions and benefits since both spouses are eligible for Medicare yet only one has paid taxes."

Looking at the bigger picture, the report said, "It is no wonder these programs now account for one-third of all federal spending each year."

The study, which was updated specifically to inform super committee discussions, concluded that "changes to entitlement programs are inevitable as part of a sound fiscal policy." It asserted that anything short of a comprehensive, overall view would merely be tinkering.

Its bottom line: "Tax rates that have not kept pace with ever-rising benefit levels, increasing years of support, spiraling health costs, and fewer workers per retiree all imply that current and future generations of workers are going to have to do something to get these elderly benefit programs into order, either by paying higher taxes or receiving fewer benefits for themselves."

We make no ruling on those difficult choices.

The difficult situation described by Portman is another matter. On the Truth-O-Meter his claim rates True.

Our Sources

Kaiser Health News, "Super Committee Dems Ready A $400 Billion Medicare Plan," Oct. 26, 2011

MSNBC, "Will 'super committee' be a turkey or a deficit cutting fixer?," Nov. 2, 2011

New York Times, "Joint Select Committee on Deficit Reduction," Nov. 3, 2011

PolitiFact, "Obama says Medicare and Medicaid are largest deficit drivers," June 25, 2009

CQ Congressional Transcripts, Joint Select Deficit Reduction Committee Holds Hearing on a Review of Previous Debt Reduction Proposals, Nov. 1, 2011

Email exchange with Portman Communication Director Jeffrey Sadosky, Nov. 2, 2011

Urban Institute, "Social Security and Medicare Taxes and Benefits Over a Lifetime," June 20, 2011

Urban Institute, "How Lifetime Benefits and Contributions Point the Way Toward Reforming Our Senior Entitlement Programs," Aug. 1, 2011

NPR, "Medicare's Math Problem: Taxes - Benefits = Trouble," April 30, 2011

U.S. News, "Seniors Don't Pay Full Medicare, Social Security Share," July 1, 2011

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Tom Feran

Retiring couples get $3 in Medicare benefits for each $1 paid in, Rob Portman says

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up