Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
President Barack Obama recently announced a new initiative that was close to his heart: a national effort to close achievement gaps and create opportunities for minority boys.
"My Brothers Keeper," unveiled at the White House on Feb. 27, 2014, combines philanthropy and research to help move young men of color from the streets into schools and the workforce.
"I'm going to pen this presidential memorandum directing the federal government not to spend more money, but to do things smarter, to determine what we can do right now to improve the odds for boys and young men of color, and make sure our agencies are working more effectively with each other, with those businesses, with those philanthropies and with local communities to implement proven solutions," Obama said at the White House launch event.
Many Democrats in Congress voiced their support for Obama’s push to help young minorities. Among them was Rep. Louise Slaughter, D-N.Y., who joined the cause on Twitter.
"By 4th grade, 86 percent of African-American boys and 82 percent (of) Hispanic boys are reading below proficiency levels," she tweeted.
It’s an eye-opening statistic, and one that spoke to Obama’s new effort. But is it accurate?
The Nation’s Report Card
When we contacted Slaughter’s office, a spokesman pointed us to a White House fact sheet with an almost identical claim: "Large disparities remain in reading proficiency, with 86 percent of black boys and 82 percent of Hispanic boys reading below proficiency levels by the fourth grade – compared to 58 percent of white boys reading below proficiency levels."
In turn, the White House said the numbers came from The Nation’s Report Card, a federal assessment conducted by the National Assessment of Educational Progress. Since 1969, the National Assessment of Educational Progress has tracked student achievement in such subjects as reading, mathematics, science, writing, U.S. history, and by a variety of demographics, including race.
Broadly, proficiency is defined by the government as students being "able to integrate and interpret texts and apply their understanding of the text to draw conclusions and make evaluations."
According to the 2013 report card, there is a significant disparity between white and minority students in math and reading scores at the fourth-grade level.
While 46 percent of white students were proficient in reading, just 18 percent of black students and 20 percent of Hispanics meet the same benchmark.
For each group, those numbers have risen quite a bit since 1990, when 16 percent of white fourth-graders were reading at a proficient level, compared to just 1 percent of blacks and 5 percent of Hispanics.
Gaps in mathematic scores have been similar. Meanwhile, Asian/Pacific Islanders outpace all races and ethnicities in both reading and math in the fourth grade.
It’s also worth noting that there’s no improvement in proficiency levels by the time students finish the eighth grade. Similar numbers of students start behind and stay behind.
But Slaughter’s tweet specified black boys in particular. To get those statistics, we had to dive deeper into the report.
Using the government’s data, we found that 14 percent of black boys and 18 percent of Hispanic boys read at a proficient level in the fourth grade. This means that 86 percent of black boys and 82 percent of Hispanic boys were not proficient. So Slaughter’s numbers are right on.
By contrast, about 58 percent of white boys are considered proficient.
And what about girls? They perform slightly better across all races than boys.
Slaughter said that "by 4th grade, 86 percent of African-American boys and 82 percent (of) Hispanic boys are reading below proficiency level." Government data backs up that depressing statistic, though it’s worth noting that the U.S. has at least seen improvements across all races since the early 1990s. We rate the statement True.
Statement by Rep. Louise Slaughter via Twitter, Feb. 27, 2014
CNN, Transcript: Obama announces 'My Brother's Keeper," Feb. 27, 2014
The Nation’s Report Card, "What proportions of student groups are reaching Proficient?" accessed Feb. 28, 2014
The Nation’s Report Card, About The Nation's Report Card, accessed Feb. 27, 2014
The Nation’s Report Card, The NAEP Reading Achievement Levels by Grade, accessed Feb. 27, 2014
Institute of Education Statistics, NAEP Data Explorer, accessed Feb. 27-28, 2014
Email interview with Eric Schultz, White House spokesman, Feb. 27, 2014
Email interview with Eric Walker, spokesman for Rep. Slaughter, Feb. 27, 2014
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.