Stand up for the facts!

Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.

More Info

I would like to contribute

Joshua Gillin
By Joshua Gillin May 22, 2014

Amendment 'allows a teenager to get a recommendation for medical marijuana without the consent of a parent'

Family Feud time! Today’s question: Name something most teenagers cannot do.

Vote? Ding! See R-rated movies alone? Ding! Buy beer? Ding!

Score some weed without a hitch under Florida’s proposed medical marijuana amendment? BUZZZZ!

An anti-marijuana coalition operating the website has claimed as much. Among the talking points was the assertion, "The amendment allows a teenager to get a recommendation for medical marijuana without the consent of a parent."

There’s already plenty of debate over the legalities of Amendment 2, which is on the November ballot. But can teens easily score a nickel bag solo should it pass? We’ll have to take our own survey and see what it says.

A minor hitch

Amendment 2 calls for the state to allow patients with cancer, glaucoma, AIDS, hepatitis C, ALS, Crohn’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, multiple sclerosis and unspecified "other conditions" to obtain medical marijuana with a doctor’s written recommendation. Technically, the physicians won’t write prescriptions, because marijuana would still be illegal under federal law. If 60 percent of voters ratify the amendment, the state must set up a dispensary system and write regulations for growing and selling the drug.

The Don’t Let Florida Go To Pot website lists more than 40 "coalition partners." The Orlando Sentinel reported the site is run by Save Our Society From Drugs, a St. Petersburg-based lobbying group, and the Florida Sheriffs Association. The sheriffs association’s tax status prevents it from actively lobbying for people to vote against Amendment 2, but the group publicly opposes the measure.

The sheriff’s association and Save Our Society did not answer our questions about why they think teens will be free to roll up spliffs without asking mom and dad first. Others have complained the measure’s language doesn’t set a minimum age, and therefore targets minors.

But the vague amendment language is by design, according to the organization behind the amendment. United for Care attorney Jon Mills told PolitiFact Florida that by not addressing the age issue, a topic that was discussed while drafting the proposal, the amendment allows state law to take precedent on the issue of age.

Currently, a parent or guardian must provide consent for medical treatment for a minor, except in emergencies or other unusual circumstances, such as when the Department of Children and Family Services must get involved.

The absence of an age limit is to allow the state freedom to write the rules as they see fit, should the amendment pass and become part of the state Constitution.   

"If we put a minimum age in we’d never be able to modify it," Mills said, referring to how the amendment will change the state’s Constitution, rather than creating a new statute, as many medical marijuana states do.

Featured Fact-check

There are 21 states with laws that allow medical cannabis. Only three (California, Washington and Massachusetts) make no mention of minors in their language, as in the Florida amendment. Karen O’Keefe, director of state policies for the Marijuana Policy Project, which favors measures to allow medical marijuana, said all three still require parental involvement in some way.

Minnesota, which will soon be the 22nd state to allow it, also doesn’t include language about children.

Three other states (Connecticut, Delaware and Illinois) specifically exclude allowing minors to use the drug -- and Illinois is on the brink of changing its law concerning kids. The other 15 allow children access to the drug to some degree but only with parental consent.

"In Florida, I think there is no way that minors will actually ultimately be allowed to sign up for medical marijuana without their parent or guardian’s support. In fact, the rules may be even more strict than they are in most states," O’Keefe said. She compared Amendment 2 to Massachusetts’ 2012 law, which didn’t mention minors. The state ended up heavily regulating use by children.

Vanderbilt Law School professor Robert Mikos pointed out that any teenager would have to go through the same vetting process as adults. That means they would undergo whatever examination, registration and regulation process the state creates.

"Does this mean a 13-year-old could just go in and get a certification? That’s not the case in any state," he said. "There’s nothing about the Florida proposal that says Florida would be worse than any other state."

So if concerns about minors are unfounded, could Don’t Let Florida Go To Pot potentially mean 18- or 19-year-olds? They’re technically teenagers.

Mikos says if that’s what Don’t Let Florida Go To Pot is saying, "it’s a very misleading statement meant to scare people." He points out that 18-year-olds are allowed to buy tobacco and are allowed prescriptions to Oxycontin, so marijuana probably shouldn’t be treated any differently.

Douglas Berman, an Ohio State University law professor who edits a marijuana policy blog, says the opposition’s concern about teen use could possibly be better illustrated by the possibility of those older teens exploiting the system.

"There’s nothing in this to stop college kids on spring break to go into the doctor’s office and saying, ‘My back hurts,’ and getting some, not for medicinal purposes, but because they want to have fun," Berman said. But focusing on that angle in medical legislation is a dubious argument.

"There’s nothing else in medicine that we go to a 19-year-old and say, ‘Hey, you need your parents’ permission," Berman added.

Our ruling

Don’t Let Florida Go To Pot says "the amendment allows a teenager to get a recommendation for medical marijuana without the consent of a parent." The group didn’t offer us any specifics on what it meant.

The amendment is actually silent on the issue of minors. The proposal’s framers say they specifically didn’t include minors in its language in order to let state law reign supreme. Policy experts said state regulations usually dictate parental consent is necessary, and there’s no reason to think Florida would be any different. We should note that in all probability, 18- and 19-year-olds would have access like any other adult.

We rate the claim Half True.

Our Sources

Dont Let Florida Go To Pot, "Facts vs. Myths," accessed May 20, 2014

The Florida Bar, "Legal Hurdles to Leap to Get Medical Treatment for Children," January 2006

Florida Sheriffs Association, "Florida Sheriffs Pass Resolution to Oppose the Legalization of Marijuana," Jan. 16, 2014

PolitiFact Florida, "Pam Bondi says amendment would make Florida one of the most lenient medical marijuana states," Dec. 17, 2013

PolitiFact Florida, "Pam Bondi says medical marijuana is illegal under federal law, with or without amendment," Dec. 17, 2013

PolitiFact Florida, "Medical marijuana ballot initiative requires doctors' input but not a prescription for 'debilitating' conditions," Feb. 21, 2014

Tampa Bay Times, "Surveys yet to link medical marijuana and teen drug abuse," March 29, 2014

Marijuana Policy Project, "The Twenty-One States and One Federal District With Effective Medical Marijuana Laws," April 18, 2014

Associated Press, "Florida sheriffs campaigning against medical marijuana," April 27, 2014

First Coast News, "Don't let Florida go to Pot' campaign underway," April 28, 2014

Orlando Sentinel, "Sheriffs take lead against legalizing medical pot," May 1, 2014

Associated Press, "Minnesota lawmakers agree to legalize medical marijuana under tight restrictions," May 15, 2014

Tampa Bay Times, "PTA meeting ends with anti-medical marijuana pamphlets," May 16, 2014

Associated Press, "Minnesota to become 22nd state to legalize medical marijuana," May 20, 2014

Constitutional Amendment Petition Form, "Use of Marijuana for Certain Medical Conditions," accessed May 20, 2014

Florida Senate, "2012 Florida Statutes: SECTION 0645, Other persons who may consent to medical care or treatment of a minor," accessed May 22, 2014

California Department of Public Health, Proposition 215 text, accessed May 22, 2014

Washington State Legislature, "Chapter 69.51a RCW MEDICAL CANNABIS (Formerly Medical marijuana)," accessed May 22, 2014

Secretary of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, "Chapter 93J Massachusetts Right to Repair Act," accessed May 22, 2014

Commonwealth of Massachusetts, "Implementation of an Act for the Humanitarian Medical Use of Marijuana," accessed May 22, 2014

Marijuana Policy Project, "Illinois: Important bill protecting patients with seizure conditions continues to advance!," accessed May 22, 2014

Interview with Ben Pollara, United for Care campaign manager, May 21, 2014

Interview with Jon Mills, United for Care attorney, May 21, 2014

Interview with Karen O’Keefe, Marijuana Policy Project director of state policies, May 21-22, 2014

Interview with Robert Mikos, Vanderbilt Law School director of Program in Law and Government, May 22, 2014

Interview with Douglas Berman, Ohio State University Moritz College of Law professor, May 22, 2014

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Joshua Gillin

Amendment 'allows a teenager to get a recommendation for medical marijuana without the consent of a parent'

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up