Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
Donald Trump named Oakland and Ferguson among the "most dangerous" cities in the world in a recent New York Times magazine interview.
Reporter Robert Draper asked Trump to name the most dangerous place in the world he’s been. "Brooklyn," the Queens-native-turned-Manhattanite joked. Then he said."There are places in America that are among the most dangerous in the world. You go to places like Oakland. Or Ferguson. The crime numbers are worse. Seriously."
Trump’s right that a few places in the United States have some of the highest murder rates across the globe — but Oakland and Ferguson are not among them. Experts also pointed out that homicide and other crimes in these cities disportionately affect certain demographics, so it’s not a one-danger-fits-all scenario.
Factoring in other security concerns, such as war, terrorism, kidnappings, natural disasters, and other types of violence, even high-crime American cities start looking pretty safe compared to the rest of the world.
Murder he tweeted
Before we dive into the data, we should note that comparing crime across countries is difficult and discouraged due to disparities in legal definitions, incident reporting and data collection, and social and political contexts. Homicide rates, however, are generally safe to compare.
The Mexico-based nonprofit Consejo Ciudadano para la Seguridad Publica y la Justicia (CCSP) compiles an annual list of the highest murder rates in the world in cities with more than 300,000 inhabitants. Out of the 50 cities in its 2015 rankings, 21 are in Brazil, eight are in Venezuela (including the murder capital of the world, Caracas), and five are in Mexico.
At No. 15, St. Louis is the top-ranking U.S. city in 2015 with a rate of 59.23 per 100,000 inhabitants. Baltimore comes in at No. 19, Detroit is No. 28 and New Orleans is No. 32.
Though Trump highlighted one specific murder near Oakland last year on Twitter (the shooting death of Kathryn Steinle in San Francisco) and repeatedly warned of riots in Ferguson following the shooting death of Michael Brown in 2014, the homicide rates in both places are nowhere near as high as the places listed by CCSP.
According to FBI data from 2014 (the latest complete year on record), Oakland reported 80 murders for a population of 410,000 for a rate of 19.51. Ferguson, with two murders for 21,000 people, had a rate of 9.48. Oakland and Ferguson do not appear in the CCSP ranking of the highest murder rates in the world.
Here’s how the two cities cited by Trump stack up next to the top 50:
Oakland Mayor Libby Schaaf blasted Trump’s claim on Twitter, writing, "The most dangerous place in America is Donald Trump's mouth."
But Trump would have actually been right about Oakland in 2012, when it placed at No. 43 on CCSP’s list with a homicide rate of 33.10. That was a peak year for Oakland though, and the city didn’t rank in 2011, 2013 or 2014 either.
In 2012, four more U.S. cities (Flint, Mich.; Jackson, Miss.; Newark, N.J.; and Birmingham, Ala.) with populations of 100,000 or more had a higher murder rate than the No. 50 city of Barranquilla, Colombia, with its rate of 29.41.
Ferguson’s crime rates, meanwhile, are nowhere near the higher reaches of violent crime in the United States, let alone the world. Because of its small population size, its murder rates vary wildly from any given year. For example, there were five murders in 2011 giving it a rate of 23.5 but the town reported no murders in 2010 for a rate of 0. Ferguson is also part of the greater St. Louis area.
Frank Zimring, a crime expert at the University of California, Berkeley, noted that most high-crime American cities have a high concentration of African-Americans, who are also the vast majority of the victims. At its peak in 2006, Zimring noted, only six of Oakland’s 149 homicide victims were non-Hispanic whites.
"Whether or not a city is dangerous to you because of the homicide rate, you have to look at who’s being killed," said Matthew Bradley, the regional security director for the Americas at the travel security company, International SOS. "It is the profile of the person who’s there that matters."
Make America Safe Again?
Of course, murder isn’t the only danger people face. Overall, no American city is "among the most dangerous in the world."
International SOS is the world’s largest travel-security firm and operates in around 1,000 cities in 90 countries including conflict zones like Baghdad, Iraq, and high-crime cities like Caracas, Venezuela.
"We don’t have any city in the United States rated as high or even medium risk — all are low risk," Bradley said. "I can name at least 20 cities more dangerous than St. Louis."
It’s not just about risk; it’s also about the ability to mitigate risk, Bradley explained. So International SOS looks at a variety of factors beyond crime rates like anecdotal evidence, news and social media reports and the capabilities of local authorities.
For example, after the Paris terrorist attacks in November 2015, the likelihood of more bombings was still very low because French authorities responded swiftly with hundreds of raids. However, International SOS raised Istanbul’s risk to medium after a series of bombings in the city that authorities had not been able to deter.
Despite high crime rates in certain hotspots in specific U.S. cities, police and other authorities are typically responsive and able to contain emergencies.
"The national security apparatus of the United States provides resources that can’t be matched by any place in the world. No country can match that," Bradley said.
Global consulting firm Mercer, which releases an annual ranking of quality of life standards around the world, shared its safety rankings with PolitiFact. Out of 230 cities, the lowest-ranked U.S. cities were Atlanta, Detroit and St. Louis, all tied at No. 107. Meanwhile, San Francisco tied with Chicago, Honolulu and Houston as the safest U.S cities at No. 54.
So where are the most dangerous places in the world?
Mercer named Baghdad as the least-safe city in the world. Other war-torn and terrorized cities like Damascus, Syria, Nairobi, Kenya, and Tripoli, Libya, rounded out the 20 least-safe places.
The consulting firm’s list matches up with the U.S. State Department’s list of travel warnings. As of May 25, the State Department is discouraging visiting 37 countries for a number of security reasons, from pervasive violence in Venezuela and the Congo to war zones in Syria and Iraq.
International SOS, meanwhile, currently has an evacuation status in place for Syria, Yemen, Libya and a few other countries ravaged by conflict. Unlike Caracas, Baghdad and Johannesburg, mitigating risk in a city like Damascus is difficult if not near impossible. Travelers there face improvised explosive devices and other unpredictable threats.
In short, there are definitely more dangerous places than Oakland, Ferguson and other American cities.
"I don’t have my head on a swivel in Doylestown, Pa.," Bradley said. "If I ever walked outside my house in Honduras — well, I never did."
Trump said, "There are places in America that are among the most dangerous in the world. You go to places like Oakland. Or Ferguson. The crime numbers are worse. Seriously."
Four American cities — though not Oakland or Ferguson — have some of the highest murder rates in the world. However, experts told us homicide rates alone are not enough to gauge whether a city is dangerous or not.
In considering other security threats like war, terrorism, kidnappings, and other violence as well as the ability to mitigate risks, U.S. cities are nowhere near the most dangerous in the world.
We rate Trump’s claim False.
New York Times Magazine, "Mr. Trump's Wild Ride," May 18, 2016
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, "Compiling and comparing International Crime Statistics," accessed May 24, 2016
Politico, "Some places in America are most dangerous in world," May 18, 2016
Washington Post, "Donald Trump somehow thinks Ferguson and Oakland are dangerous like Iraq," May 18, 2016
Consejo Ciudadano para la Seguridad Publica y la Justicia, "The 50 Most Violent Cities in the World 2015 Position City Country Homicides Inhabitant," accessed May 23, 2016
Twitter, Donald J. Trump, July, 31, 2015
Twitter, Donald J. Trump’s Ferguson tweets, November 2015
FBI, Uniform Crime Reports: California, 2014
Twitter, Libby Schaaf, May 18, 2016
Consejo Ciudadano para la Seguridad Publica y la Justicia, "The 50 Most Violent Cities in the World 2015," accessed May 23, 2016
Consejo Ciudadano para la Seguridad Publica y la Justicia, "The 50 Most Violent Cities in the World 2014," accessed May 23, 2016
Consejo Ciudadano para la Seguridad Publica y la Justicia, "The 50 Most Violent Cities in the World 2013," accessed May 23, 2016
Consejo Ciudadano para la Seguridad Publica y la Justicia, "The 50 Most Violent Cities in the World 2012," accessed May 23, 2016
Consejo Ciudadano para la Seguridad Publica y la Justicia, "The 50 Most Violent Cities in the World 2011," accessed May 23, 2016
FBI, Uniform Crime Statistics data tool query, accessed May 24, 2016
Mercer, 2016 Quality of Life Survey Personal Safety Ranking, Feb. 23, 2016
State Department, "Alerts and Warnings," accessed May 25, 2016
Email interview with Consejo Ciudadano para la Seguridad Publica y la Justicia, May 24, 2016
Email interview with Mladen Adamovic, founder of Numbeo, May 24, 2016
Email and phone interview with Pooja Jhunjhunwala, spokesperson at the State Dept., May 24, 2016
Email interview with Sarah Reilly, spokesperson at Mercer, May 24, 2016
Email interview with Frank Zimring, law professor at UC Berkeley, May 24, 2016
Interview with Matthew Bradley, regional security director for the Americas at International SOS, May 25, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.