Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Following this year’s Thanksgiving dinner, a lone Twitter profile alleged that CNN was serving up something difficult to stomach — a half-hour of hardcore pornography. Apparently starved for content, the media ate it up.
Around 10:30 p.m. ET on Nov. 24, 2016, Twitter user @solikearose tweeted from Boston that the scheduled episode of Anthony Bourdain: Parts Unknown was not appearing on CNN. She said there was an explicit sex scene showing on the network, instead.
The user shared several images with TiVo digital programming information included, tagging from Boston-area cable provider RCN.
(Image via Mediaite)
Twitter being Twitter, rumors of explicit sex on a cable news channel spread quickly. Other users included the hashtag "#BourdainPorn" while sharing the images and discussing the alleged incident.
By 9:54 a.m. ET the next day, cable provider RCN responded to the tweets. They said there had been no similar reports of pornography shown on CNN.
At some point, major media outlets picked up on the subject and started posting stories based on @solikearose’s tweets. It’s not exactly clear what media outlet first wrote up a story, because so many have since edited their postings. (The Verge contends it was the U.K.’s Independent, which was then sent out by The Drudge Report with a tweet that read, "CNN accidentally airs 30 minutes of trans porn…")
Other outlets that wrote posts about the supposed network nookie included the Daily Mail, Fox News, The Wrap, Esquire, Maxim, the New York Post, the New York Daily News and more, on down to smaller sites like Sputnik News and RT.com.
The porn star in the photos, whom Twitter users identified as Riley Quinn, acknowledged the alleged exposure on Twitter.
Variety even quoted a CNN representative as saying the event indeed happened. "The RCN cable operator in Boston aired inappropriate content for 30 minutes on CNN last night. CNN has asked for an explanation."
But while the story was shared far and wide in less than a day, it appeared by Friday evening that no one else had witnessed the same thing @solikearose had.
On Friday evening, BuzzFeed News posted an interview with the purported original Twitter user, whom they only identified as a Boston woman named Rose.
"I initially posted because I wanted to see if anyone else in Boston had been affected," she said. "I think it was a broadcasting error that affected only my house."
The person BuzzFeed News interviewed assured the site that the incident was real, and that she had conversed with a customer service representative who advised her to restart her digital cable converter. The pornography then stopped, she said. She said had made her Twitter account private because she had been harassed online.
BuzzFeed News quoted RCN Boston general manager Jeff Carlson as saying there had been no other complaints about the event.
The account @solikearose has since been deleted, and most of the posts on the incident have since been updated, many of them calling the incident a "hoax."
When we contacted CNN, the network gave us the same response it gave other outlets on Nov. 25: "Despite media reports to the contrary, RCN assures us that there was no interruption of CNN’s programming in the Boston area last night."
CNN also noted to us that while many media outlets referred to the network airing the footage, the CNN feed is the same nationwide. That means every market gets the same programming, and any difference would be through the local cable provider.
Shortly after the BuzzFeed News interview was posted, RCN wrote on their Facebook page about the flap. When we contacted RCN, they referred us to the same statement, attributing it to Carlson.
Bloggers said CNN accidentally aired 30 minutes of pornography in Boston on Thanksgiving night.
Every account of this incident, which undoubtedly would have given thousands of viewers indigestion, relies on tweets from a single Twitter user. Media accounts appear to have spread based on the same information, despite no other reported complaints to the cable provider.
The single customer’s cable equipment may have malfunctioned somehow, the provider said, but the person’s account is working properly. Media outlets that repeated the story have since backtracked on their single-source posts.
For lack of evidence, we rate this distasteful claim False.https://www.sharethefacts.co/share/7aa26997-acf3-4b7e-bc66-36778b96cc8b
The Verge, "The CNN porn scare is how fake news spreads," Nov. 25, 2016
The Independent, "CNN denies airing 30 minutes of hardcore porn," Nov. 25, 2016
Twitter.com, @RCNconnects tweets, Nov. 25, 2016
Twitter.com, @DRUDGE_REPORT tweet, Nov. 25, 2015
Variety, "CNN, RCN Deny Reports of Porn Airing on Channel in Boston," Nov. 25, 2016
BuzzFeed News. "This Woman’s Cable Box Showed Porn On CNN — Then It Became This Whole Big Thing," Nov. 25, 2016
Mediaite, "Did the Media Fall For a Fake Story About CNN Airing 30 Minutes of Hardcore Porn Last Night?," Nov. 25, 2016
Interview with Barbara Levin, CNN spokeswoman, Nov. 28, 2016
Interview with Amy Murphy, RCN spokeswoman, Nov. 28, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.