Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
A news story that said a tuna fish recall came after workers at a canning company cooked a man and added him to the product is mash-up of two real stories under a fake headline.
"Massive Bumble Bee recall after 2 employees admit cooking a man and mixing him with a batch of tuna," read the headline on an April 6, 2017, post on BlueLineStrong.net.
Facebook users flagged the post as being potentially fabricated as part of the social media site’s efforts to combat fake news.
The story itself isn’t entirely made up — but it has been repurposed with a bogus headline for a few years.
The BlueLineStrong.net post is largely an excerpt from an April 28, 2015, Associated Press article.
Here’s what happened.
The Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office charged two men at a Bumble Bee Foods plant for violating safety regulations in the death of a fellow employee.
Jose Melena, 62, was performing maintenance inside a 35-foot-long oven at a plant in Santa Fe Springs, Calif., on Oct. 11, 2012. He was trapped and died when workers filled the oven with six tons of canned tuna and turned it up to 270 degrees to cook and sterilize the food.
Angel Rodriguez, the plant operations director; Saul Florez, the safety manager; and Bumble Bee Foods all faced three counts of violating Occupational Safety and Health Administration rules. Bumble Bee Foods settled the case in August 2015 for $6 million.
To be clear, no one chopped up Melena and put his remains in the meat.
A website called TheRacketReport.com posted the story excerpt on April 28, 2015, the same day the AP story was published. It carried the headline, "Massive Bumble Bee Recall After 2 Employees Admit Cooking A Man And Mixing Him With A Batch Of Tuna."
The story doesn’t mention anyone being mixed in with the fish, despite the headline. The site’s About Us link noted that "the articles and stories may or may not use real names, always a semi real and/or mostly, or substantially, fictitious ways."
Fast forward to the following year.
On March 16, 2016, Bumble Bee Foods did issue a real recall for "process deviations," and not for the incident related Melena.
Fake news site News4KTLA.com recycled the AP story about the workers being charged in Melena’s death the next day. The post also re-used the fake headline "Massive Bumble Bee Recall After 2 Employees Admit Cooking A Man And Mixing Him With A Batch Of Tuna."
The site attempts to look like a real media outlet, but does not give an indication it is fake, saying it covers "southern Louisiana and the surrounding area." The real KTLA TV station is based in Los Angeles. The fake headline has been passed around ever since.
We rate the headline Pants on Fire.
BlueLineStrong.net, "Massive Bumble Bee Recall After 2 Employees Admit Cooking A Man And Mixing Him With A Batch Of Tuna," April 6, 2017
Los Angeles Times, "Details emerge about how Bumble Bee worker died in pressure cooker," May 10, 2013
Associated Press, "Tuna company, 2 managers charged in death of worker in oven," April 28, 2015, accessed via Nexis
TheRacketReport.com, "Massive Bumble Bee Recall After 2 Employees Admit Cooking A Man And Mixing Him With A Batch Of Tuna," April 28, 2015
USA Today, "Bumble Bee Foods charged after man cooked with tuna," April 28, 2015
USA Today, "Bumble Bee forced to pay $6M for worker cooked alive," Aug. 13, 2015
BumbleBee.com, "Bumble Bee Foods, LLC issues voluntary recall on 3 production codes of canned Chunk Light tuna due to possible health risk," March 16, 2016
News4KTLA.com, "Massive Bumble Bee Recall After 2 Employees Admit Cooking A Man And Mixing Him With A Batch Of Tuna," March 17, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.