Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Former First Grandma Marian Robinson just can’t catch a break from fake news.
First Michelle Obama’s mother was wrongly accused in fake stories of drawing a federal pension for taking care of grandchildren Sasha and Malia. Now she’s the victim of a new round of false reports that claim she’s being charged with a crime for doing so since former President Barack Obama left office.
"Obama’s mother-in-law charged with larceny and fraud," reads the headline on several Internet posts that started appearing on or after March 16, 2017. The posts all read roughly the same, claiming that Robinson was charged "for accepting money from the federal government under false pretenses."
The story stokes reader ire by admonishing Robinson for attempting to take money she didn’t deserve.
"While it may not have been her idea to ask for a $160K pension for being the Obama daughters’ ‘caretaker,’ she was the one who filled out the paperwork and signed her name," the posts read.
Several of these links were flagged by Facebook users for being potentially fake, as part of the social media company’s efforts to prune fake news from readers’ news feeds. The various links that repurpose the same post have been shared on Facebook at least 17,000 times.
We know this particular claim is fake, because it comes from a website that makes up its content.
It was originally posted on March 16 at TheLastLineOfDefense.org, which has been the source of several fake news stories that we’ve previously checked. These kinds of posts end up being passed around on multiple websites, often without attribution about its origin.
TheLastLineOfDefense.org doesn’t indicate this or any other story is fake, but its About Us link notes that "all articles should be considered satirical and any and all quotes attributed to actual people complete and total baloney."
Moreover, the whole idea that Robinson was at all eligible for a federal pension for being a caretaker of the former first family’s children is entirely wrong.
Robinson was a former bank secretary and stay-at-home mother to Michelle Obama and her brother Craig. She did move into the White House in 2009, and has helped raise her granddaughters. But she didn’t draw a salary and wasn’t on any kind of government payroll for doing that. Since she was never a federal employee, she doesn’t qualify for any government pension.
The post on TheLastLineOfDefense.org is building on a claim from October 2016 that originated on BostonTribune.com. That website said Robinson was allowed to collect the $160,000 pension once the Obamas left the White House.
Despite the story being shared on several other fake news sites, there’s no actual pension for Robinson to collect. We rated that statement Pants On Fire!
TheLastLineOfDefense.org report appears to acknowledge there is no pension for the first grandma (or at least not a legal one). Instead, the post unleashes outrage over Robinson’s alleged attempt to collect money not owed to her.
What we have here is one fake news website posting a contrived follow-up to another fake news website’s false report. Robinson is not collecting a pension, and she hasn’t been charged with a crime for trying to collect a pension.
We rate this claim Pants On Fire!
FlashNewsCorner.com, "BREAKING: Obama’s Mother-In-Law Charged With Larceny And Fraud," March 17, 2017
TheLastLineOfDefense.org, "BREAKING: Obama’s Mother In Law Charged With Larceny And Fraud," March 16, 2017
PolitiFact, "Fake news: First grandma Marian Robinson is not getting $160,000 annual pension," Jan. 10, 2017
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.