Stand up for the facts!

Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.

More Info

I would like to contribute

By Dan Clark November 5, 2017

Progressive group accuses Senate splinter group of cashing in with donors

A progressive advocacy group says eight Democrats in the New York State Senate accepted money from campaign donors who typically support Republicans.

A video released by The Creative Resistance targets the Independent Democratic Conference, a faction of Democrats aligned with Republicans instead of the other 23 Democrats in the Senate.

"IDC members also get tons of campaign money from real estate, charter school, and health care lobbyists, some of whom are Republicans with connections to Trump," the narrator says.

Outside groups often give to the majority party in each chamber. Republicans now hold a majority of 40 members, including IDC members and a Democrat who sits with the Republican conference.

The video claims members of the IDC cashed in with donors who also contributed to GOP lawmakers. Is that true?

Giving money in the Senate

Special interest groups can give money to support candidates in two ways: to candidates directly or to a political party committee. In the State Senate, the Republicans, Democrats and IDC each has its own campaign account.

The list of donors The Creative Resistance sent us to support its claim is long. Filings from the state Board of Elections show its claim is accurate -- the IDC did get money from real estate, charter school and health care lobbyists. But so did both Republicans and Democrats.

Some health care examples:

  • The Greater New York Hospital Association since 2011 has given $1.3 million to the Senate Republican Campaign Committee, $625,000 to the Senate Democrat Campaign account and $311,000 to the IDC.
  • Individual members of the IDC outpaced Democrats in donations from the association. They collectively received $16,500 since 2011. Individual Democrats collected $6,000 from the organization while Republicans received about $39,000.
  • The Healthcare Association of New York State has given about $810,000 to Republicans between their conference’s campaign account and individual members since 2011. The IDC took a total of about $113,000 from the group. Democrats were given $105,000.
  • Both organizations supported more Democrats than Republicans in the State Assembly, suggesting its money goes to whomever is in power.

Charter schools

Republicans in the State Legislature are more likely to support legislation that benefits charter schools. That’s reflected through donations they receive from charter school groups.

Two of those groups, New Yorkers for Putting Students First and the Coalition for Public Charter Schools, have not given to mainline Senate Democrats since 2011.

They gave about $167,000 to the IDC and its members and about $233,000 to Republicans.

Featured Fact-check

Eva Moskowitz, the founder of Success Academy Charter Schools, has favored the IDC over Democrats in the Senate.

Her political action committee, Great Public Schools, has given about $66,000 to the IDC and its members since 2011. The PAC gave $114,000 to Senate Republicans, while six members of the mainline Democratic conference were given about $38,000 from the group.

Real estate

Some IDC donors from the real estate industry have ties to President Donald Trump, the video claims.

The largest real estate donor on the group’s list is the Real Estate Board of New York, a statewide group that advocates for real estate developers.

The Creative Resistance says the group is tied to Trump through his children. Both Eric and Ivanka Trump are members of  the board.

The board has given slightly more than $1 million to the Senate Republican campaign account and members since 2011. The IDC has received about $480,000 while mainline Democrats were given about $207,000.

The IDC's response

The IDC responded to the group's claim with its own analysis of major donors from health care, charter school and real estate lobbyists.

"An honest review of campaign finance donations of all Democrats in New York illustrates that these same donors contribute to Democrats across the state, and the Senate's minority Democratic conference is no exception," IDC spokesperson Candice Giove said.

Our ruling

The Creative Resistance said in a video "IDC members also get tons of campaign money from real estate, charter school, and health care lobbyists, some of whom are Republicans with connections to Trump."

The IDC and its members do get money from donors in the lobbyists. But so do mainline Democrats, even if it’s less than their IDC colleagues. It's not true the IDC members benefit while Democrats do not. 

The statement is accurate but needs clarification and additional information. We rate it Mostly True.

Share the Facts
PolitiFact rating logo PolitiFact Rating:
Mostly True
"IDC members also get tons of campaign money from real estate, charter school, and health care lobbyists, some of whom are Republicans with connections to Trump"
New York
Tuesday, October 24, 2017

Our Sources

Video: "Lulu Land", Oct. 24, 2017, The Creative Resistance

Email conversation with Eric Rockey, spokesperson for The Creative Resistance

All contribution data obtained through the New York State Board of Elections website, Oct. 27 - 30, 2017

"Shaping the Westchester skyline", The Real Deal, Jan. 1, 2017

REBNY Member Directory, showing Ivanka and Eric Trump. Queried Oct. 31, 2017

"New Vision for Catskill Development, Without Cards", New York Times, May 8, 2008

"The Donald to develop condo tower in White Plains, N.Y.", National Real Estate Investor, 2004

"Just How High Should Progress Go?", New York Times, 2006

"Donald Trump Taps Richard LeFrak, Steven Roth To Lead New Infrastructure Council", Forbes, Jan. 17, 2017

"President Trump Gives Up On Infrastructure Council", Fortune, Aug. 17, 2017

JCOPE Filing for DelBello Donnellan Weingarten

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Dan Clark

Progressive group accuses Senate splinter group of cashing in with donors

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up