Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Alabama state Sen. Bill Hightower raised a few eyebrows during a debate among Republican candidates for governor when he traced a large portion of crime to a small portion of families in Mobile.
Joining Hightower at the April 18 debate were Huntsville Mayor Tommy Battle and evangelist Scott Dawson, all of whom are hoping to replace incumbent Gov. Kay Ivey as the Republican nominee after the June 5 primary. Ivey, who stepped into the role after former Gov. Robert Bentley resigned, did not participate in the debate.
One AL.com reader asked the candidates, "As the mom of a third grader who had a classmate say he would bring a gun to school, what will you be doing to keep our kids safe?"
Hightower proposed placing police officers in schools so that they got to know students and prevent crime.
"We know who the difficult students are, more often than not, through their truancy and through their actions," Hightower said. "In Mobile, it’s something like, 1,700 families generate 80 percent of the crime. We know who those families are."
Mobile has a population of about 193,000. Is a small fraction of families generating a majority of crime?
Not so fast.
It sounded like Hightower was talking about the outsized effects of organized crime in Mobile. But Hightower’s campaign told us he was citing a statistic about school suspensions.
That statistic is 15 years old and is the latest study available.
In 2003, the Mobile County district attorney researched school suspensions and found that of the 65,000 students in the district, only 1,500 students were responsible for 75 to 80 percent of serious school infractions. The district attorney then cross-referenced the students with home addresses to identify 1,200 households.
The office did not study all of the reasons for a suspension, just those that were considered serious — such as burglary or having drugs or weapons on campus. John Tyson, the former district attorney who did the research, emphasized the behavior did not constitute crime under a criminal justice definition.
Tyson said there is not a similar data point for more recent years.
Still, criminologists were not surprised by the finding.
"The general idea that a few people are engaged in a lot of problem behavior and criminal behavior makes a lot of sense and would be consistent with what we see with a lot of other types of crime," said Adam Lankford, an associate professor of criminology and criminal justice at the University of Alabama.
Sexual assault on campus came to mind, where the number of reported incidents often heavily outweighs the number of offenders.
"A small percentage of the population is responsible for a large percentage of crimes. The same is true of families as criminal behavior often runs within families," said James Fox, a criminology professor at Northeastern University.
Lankford took issue with Hightower’s description of the role of families. While social factors play a role in problematic behavior, the research identified correlation, not causation. It did not place blame on a small proportion of families for crime.
In fact, Tyson warned against using the word "crime" to describe the behavior, as the research looked at addressing school suspensions and absences to address potential future crime, not actual crime.
Tyson said the research was not very relevant for his office. But he did use it as a starting point for the ongoing Helping Families Initiative, which he continues to lead.
The initiative pairs K-12 public school students who are identified as at-risk for crime with law enforcement and community resources, such as child services, public health officials and domestic violence experts. The aim is to reduce misdemeanors committed on campus and other criminal acts.
The program is active in six districts, including Mobile.
Hightower said, "In Mobile, it’s something like, 1,700 families generate 80 percent of the crime."
Hightower’s point is roughly related to available research. But he did not describe it correctly.
He oversimplified research findings of the Mobile County District Attorney’s office about school suspensions.
The office learned kids from 1,200 households were responsible for 75 to 80 percent of school infractions in Mobile’s public schools. It did not go so far as to examine the role of the families in those households.
Also, it’s important to know the research was from 2003, and we don’t know if the percentage still holds up. And importantly, the study centered on school suspensions and not "crime," in a literal or legal sense.
Because the statement is partially accurate but missing critical context, we rate this statement Half True.
Reckon, GOP Governor’s debate, April 18, 2018
Interview with Chris Brown, political strategist for Bill Hightower, April 20, 2018
Interview with Natalie Todak, criminal justice professor at the University of Alabama at Birmingham, April 19, 2018
Phone interview with John Tyson, former Mobile district attorney and Helping Families founder, April 20, 2018
Montgomery Advertiser, Helping Montgomery Families Initiative seeks comprehensive approach to truancy, suspensions, March 9, 2018
Phone interview with Adam Lankford, professor of criminology and criminal justice at The University of Alabama, April 20, 2018
Email interview with James Fox, Lipman Family Professor of Criminology, Law, and Public Policy at Northeastern University, April 19, 2018
Email interview with Robyn Bradley Bryan, ALEA Public Information office, April 19, 2018
Email interview with Hyeyoung Lim, associate professor at University of Alabama at Birmingham, April 20, 2018
Email interview with Lesley Williams Reid, University of Alabama Department of Criminology & Criminal Justice professor and chair, April 19, 2018
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.