Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
If Rep. Robert Pittenger has his way, the primary election for his seat will become a contest over loyalty to President Donald Trump.
Pittenger, a Republican from the Charlotte area, faces an opponent in Rev. Mark Harris, who came within 134 votes of beating him for the District 9 seat in June 2016.
The winner of the GOP primary faces the winner of the Democratic primary between Christian Cano and Dan McCready, as well as Libertarian Jeff Scott.
Harris has attempted to position himself to the right of Pittenger. So Pittenger recently released an ad that casts Harris as a critic of Trump, who carried the district with 54 percent of the vote in 2016.
In the ad, a newspaper headline appears on screen and reads, "Mark Harris worked to stop a Trump presidency."
The ad’s narrator says, "Mark Harris worked to stop Trump from being president."
In a news release accompanying the ad, Pittenger strategist Paul Shumaker said Harris "led the ‘Stop Trump’ campaign" before the GOP convention.
Harris, for his part, told The Charlotte Observer that there’s "no record whatsoever that I was part of a Stop Trump movement."
PolitiFact reached out to the Pittenger campaign about the claim. The campaign directed us to a WBT Radio clip from March 10, 2016, in which Harris talks about his support of Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas.
A radio interview
"He’s gonna be the next president of the United States," Harris said of Cruz during the interview.
"It does seem that Donald Trump does have somewhat of a ceiling," Harris said. "And in these close primaries, he loses most of the time. So I think that’s an interesting aspect. So I think coalescing behind Ted Cruz is a way to stop Donald Trump and go into the convention, get our nominee and come out and beat Hillary Clinton in the fall.
The radio host then asks Harris if he’d support Trump if Trump were to become the Republican nominee.
"That’s an interesting question," Harris responds. "I think everyone is weighing that out and considering that."
"To be honest, it’s a very concerning decision that will have to be made because we’re looking at one entire generation of Supreme Court justices being nominated that will affect us and I’m truly concerned most of all of Hillary Clinton or Bernie Sanders having that ability to choose," Harris continued. "I feel somewhat better about Donald Trump making those appointments but I can’t tell you I feel great about that by any stretch of the imagination."
Lawrence Shaheen, a spokesman for Pittenger, provided a link to a story in the Independent in April 2016 that reported Harris campaigning for Cruz. He also pointed to Harris’ Facebook and Twitter accounts to argue that Harris was never enthusiastic about Trump. Those accounts show very few pro-Trump tweets until Trump won the presidency.
Supporting Cruz at the primary
PolitiFact contacted the Harris campaign about the radio clip. Spokesman Andy Yates acknowledged in an email that Harris had concerns about Trump prior to his nomination.
But, Yates added, so did "the 60 percent of NC primary voters who voted for someone other than Donald Trump for president in the March primary, including Congressman Pittenger who was still supporting outspoken Trump opponent Marco Rubio."
The North Carolina primaries took place on March 15, 2016. That’s when Trump won a plurality of the votes, with 40 percent, and Cruz was the runner-up with 36 percent.
Yates provided a link to Pittenger’s Feb. 3 endorsement of Rubio and defended the "stop Trump" comment, pointing out that the radio interview took place four months prior to the Republican National Convention.
"Dr. Harris was fully supporting President Trump well before the convention and never engaged in any efforts to try to stop President Trump from receiving the nomination he had won," Yates said.
The Baptist Press reported in July that Harris was slated to attend the Republican National Convention as a Cruz delegate, but had to withdraw "to be with a ‘father in the ministry’ who has entered hospice care."
When did his support shift?
So, about four months before the Republican National Convention in Ohio, Harris said "coalescing behind Ted Cruz" was the best way to "stop Trump" and beat Democratic nominee Clinton. Does that mean Harris "worked" to stop Trump from being president?
Certainly, campaigning for another candidate can be considered "working against" another. So how long did it take for Harris to support Trump?
Harris "switched his support to Trump when it became clear to him that Trump had secured the delegates necessary to win the Republican nomination," Yates said. "Mark said that if he remembered correctly it was around the time of the California primary."
The California primary in 2016 was held on June 7. By June 27 of that year, The Charlotte Observer wrote a story casting Harris as a defender of Trump’s.
"There’s more than just a four-year term for a president at stake," Harris said, referring to Trump’s critics. "I think there’s a 40-year generation at stake. Decisions will be made by the next president that will affect us for 40 years."
Pittenger, for his part, shifted his support to Trump that May. Shaheen forwarded an email that Pittenger sent to the Charlotte Observer on May 4. Pittenger was then quoted as supporting Trump in the Charlotte Agenda later that month.
By the time November rolled around, the Daily Beast wrote a story that referred to Harris as "part of Trump’s North Carolina spiritual advisory group." Yates said Harris ultimately traveled to six states to support Trump and that he endorsed Trump from the pulpit at Charlotte First Baptist, where he was a pastor.
He sent a clip of Harris speaking at a Trump rally. The video didn’t give a date for the rally but was published on Jan. 28, 2017.
Pittenger said, "Mark Harris worked to stop Trump from being president." He has a point that Harris supported Ted Cruz for president until Trump became the nominee. But he left out the important context that Pittenger also supported another candidate.
It’s disingenuous to cast Harris as someone who tried to sabotage Trump without providing context that Harris not only supported Trump after he became the nominee, but was reported to be among his spiritual advisors. We rate this claim Mostly False.
Email correspondence with Lawrence Shaheen, spokesman for Rep. Robert Pittenger.
Email correspondence with Andy Yates, spokesman for Rev. Mark Harris.
Stories by The Charlotte Observer, "NC congressman accuses his GOP opponent of trying to ‘stop Trump,’’’ published Feb. 19, 2018; and "Some North Carolina delegates still skeptical of Donald Trump," published June 27, 2016.
Audio of a WBT Radio clip from March 10, 2016, provided by the Pittenger campaign.
Story by McClatchy DC, "North Carolina Republicans duel over who’s most loyal to Trump," published Nov. 8, 2017.
Story by The Independent, "Ted Cruz supports one of the most controversial and discriminatory anti-LGBT laws in recent history," published April 15, 2016.
A Feb. 3, 2016 news release from Rep. Robert Pittenger declaring his support for Sen. Marco Rubio.
Story by The Baptist Press, "GOP picks Trump; Lucifer invoked in race," published July 20, 2016.
Story by Charlotte Agenda, "Congressman Robert Pittenger on the national debt, HB2 and the upcoming election," published May 31, 2016.
Story by The Daily Beast, "Pastors to God: Make This Horrible Election End," published Nov. 6, 2016.
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.