Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
"So the Confederate flag is not racist, huh?"... That’s how an April 1 Facebook post begins, followed by a sketched portrait of a man and two quotes.
The first quote:
"As a people we are fighting to maintain the Heaven-ordained supremacy of the white man over the inferior or colored race."
And the second quote:
"As a national emblem, it (the Confederate flag) is significant of our higher cause, the cause of the superior race."
The statements are attributed to William T. Thompson, who the post identifies as the Confederate flag’s designer.
The post was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook.)
Let’s just cut to the chase: Yes, William T. Thompson said these things. The problem with this claim, though, is that he isn’t the designer of what we know today to be the Confederate flag.
First you should know that the flag has evolved over time. The first official flag of the Confederacy was adopted in March 1861, according to the Los Angeles Times. It had red and white stripes and a circle of stars against a blue background in the upper left corner.
In May 1863, the Confederate Congress approved a new national flag—the so-called Stainless Banner. As John Coski, a historian at the American Civil War Museum, writes in the New York Times, this flag "was a plain white field emblazoned with what was already a powerful and famous Confederate symbol, the Southern Cross, the star-bedecked blue saltire, or diagonal cross, that had been a famous battle flag since the fall of 1861."
A third flag, which was adopted soon before the Confederacy fell, resembled the second flag only it had a red bar on the right edge.
Next, let’s look at what we today think of as the Confederate flag: the Confederate battle flag. It was designed by Confederate politician William Porcher Miles, not William T. Thompson, as the Facebook post claims. Miles chaired the Committee on the Flag and Seal, and though his design was never officially adopted by the Confederacy, it was "taken up by the Confederate army," the Washington Post notes, "not to mention ‘The Dukes of Hazzard’ and alleged Charleston shooter Dylann Storm Roof." (Roof has since been convicted and sentenced to death in the 2015 killing of nine African-American churchgoers in South Carolina.)
Miles’ design was also incorporated into the Stainless Banner, that second national flag that the Confederate Congress approved in 1863. William T. Thompson is often said to be the designer of the "Stainless Banner." The Los Angeles Times, for example, described him as that flag’s designer in its 2015 story about the Confederate flag’s evolution. Also that year, The Washington Post said putting the battle flag on a field of white was "his idea." Going even farther back, "Our Flag: Origin and Progress of the Flag of the United States of America," an 1872 book by American naval officer George Henry Preble notes that Thompson "suggested a white flag with the Southern cross or battle flag for its union, as a national ensign for the Confederacy" and then asked Capt. Wm. Ross Postell to make a colored drawing of his proposed flag.
But Coski questions whether Thompson was really that flag’s designer. He told PolitiFact in an email that he thought others had previously suggested putting the battle flag on a field of white. When we asked if he could confirm, he said "without substantial research, I don’t think it is possible to confirm that he was the designer."
"At this point," he added, "it is only a hypothesis."
We reached out to other historians about Thompson’s credit as the Stainless Banner’s designer but the two who responded pointed us back to Coski. One called him one of two experts on the flag (we couldn’t reach the other).
Coski could confirm the quotes.
Thompson, as it turns out, was the editor of the Savannah Morning News. According to the book "Our Flag," in an April 1863 editorial, he wrote:
Our idea is simply to combine the present battle flag with a pure white standard sheet; our Southern cross, blue on a red field, to take the place on the white flag that is occupied by the blue union in the old United States flag or the St. George’s cross in the British flag. As a people, we are fighting to maintain the heaven-ordained supremacy of the white man over the inferior or colored race; a white flag would thus be emblematic of our cause."
He objected to efforts to add a blue stripe to the center of the white field, according to the book, and after the idea was dropped, he wrote on May 4, 1863:
The flag as adopted is precisely the same as that suggested by us a short time since, and it is, in our opinion, much more beautiful and appropriate than either the red and white bars or the white field and blue bar as first adopted by the senate. As a national emblem it is significant of our higher cause the cause of the superior race, and a higher civilization contending against ignorance, infidelity and barbarism.
Coski said Thompson’s editorials are well-known and regularly quoted. But, he said: "most historians consider his a somewhat lone voice and don’t regard his comments as in any way official or representative of the Confederate government."
William T. Thompson has been credited with designing the Stainless Banner, one of several flags used by the Confederacy. But not everyone agrees that Thompson was the Banner’s designer; Coski said it’s not possible to prove without substantial research. What’s more, Thompson didn’t design the flag that Americans today think of when they hear "Confederate flag." That flag is the Confederate battle flag, and while it was incorporated into the Stainless Banner, it was William Porcher Miles who designed it.
Thompson did say what the Facebook post claims. However, he was describing the "Stainless Banner," not the battle flag.
We rate this post Half True.
Facebook post, April 1, 2019
Los Angeles Times, "What you should know about the Confederate flag’s evolution," July 9, 2015
PBS News Hour, "8 things you didn’t know about the Confederate flag," June 21, 2015
The New York Times, "The bird of the ‘Stainless Banner,’" May 13, 2013
Britannica, "Flag of the Confederate States of America," visited April 8, 2019
Smithsonian National Museum of American History, Confederate battle flag, visited April 10, 2019
The New York Times, "The Confederate Battle Flag," April 3, 2005
The Washington Post, "The Confederacy’s pathetic case of flag envy," June 23, 2015
Email interview with John Coski, historian, The American Civil War Museum, April 8, 2015
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.