Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
Kelly, the son of two police officers, has said he does not want to defund police departments.
Kelly said that reforms in policing are needed, including independent oversight and more transparency.
Republican Arizona Sen. Martha McSally claimed that if her Democratic challenger Mark Kelly gets elected, he’d "ram through the most radical agenda in our life." Kelly and Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden want to defund the police, she claimed.
"This race is what stands in the way of the radical Left from gaining power," McSally tweeted Aug. 18. "While we are on the cusp of a Great American Comeback, Mark Kelly & Joe Biden want to raise taxes on hardworking Arizonans and defund the police."
We’ve previously fact-checked exaggerations about Biden’s tax plan, which would raise taxes on wealthier Americans and corporations. It’s also False that Biden wants to defund the police; he said he’s against that effort.
What about Kelly — does he want to defund the police? No. Kelly, the son of two police officers, has said he does not want to defund police departments. He has said, however, that changes in policing are needed. McSally’s campaign did not provide evidence that supported her claim.
Kelly, a retired U.S. Navy pilot and astronaut, is seeking to oust McSally from the U.S. Senate seat she was appointed to after the resignation of Sen. John Kyl. McSally is a former U.S. House member and retired Air Force pilot who lost a 2018 Senate bid.
In June, Jim Sharpe of KTAR News 92.3 FM asked Kelly where he stood on calls to defund the police: "Some in your party have called for defunding or even dismantling the police, do you agree with either of these solutions, and if not, what do you think the solutions are?"
Kelly started by saying he was horrified by the killing of George Floyd. He hoped the arrest of the officers involved is "a first step on a path to justice," he said. Kelly added that there were "deep systemic" issues with racism in the country and that there should be justice and accountability.
"But I do not agree that we should defund the police, or defund police departments, that’s not the approach here, we need reform of policing," Kelly said. "I’m the son of two cops. I understand the difficulty of this job, but that’s not the approach. More reporting, more transparency, independent oversight, investigations, these are common sense things we can do to get to the point where we don't see situations like these repeatedly in our country."
KTAR News 92.3 posted two tweets on June 12 based on the interview with Kelly, reinforcing that Kelly was against defunding the police. "Taking money away from police departments is not a recipe for community success, but changing enforcement tactics is, Democratic Senate candidate Mark Kelly told @AZMorningNews," one of the tweets said.
Also in June, Kelly’s campaign spokesperson Jacob Peters reiterated in the Arizona Republic that Kelly "believes we need to reform policing, not defund police departments."
Peters told PolitiFact, "Mark has been clear, he does not support defunding the police."
We found no social media posts or other media interviews from Kelly that supported McSally’s claim. In a series of tweets related to Floyd on June 6, Kelly said he supported peaceful protests, called for "accountability and a just system that doesn't discriminate against anyone because of race" and said "urgent action and long term commitment" was needed. His tweets did not say he supported defunding the police.
McSally said Kelly wants to "defund the police."
Kelly has opposed defunding the police. Kelly, the son of police officers, told an Arizona radio station in June that defunding police departments was not the approach needed. Reforms in policing are needed, including more transparency and oversight, he said.
McSally’s statement is baseless and inaccurate. We rate it Pants on Fire.
Twitter, @MarthaMcSally tweet, Aug. 18, 2020
Twitter, @CaptMarkKelly tweets, June 6, 2020
KTAR.com, Defunding police isn’t solution, Senate candidate Mark Kelly says, June 12, 2020
The Arizona Republic, Where Senate rivals Martha McSally and Mark Kelly stand on calls to 'defund the police', June 12, 2020
PolitiFact, The death of George Floyd: What you need to know, May 29, 2020; No, Joe Biden will not ‘abolish’ police or prisons, as Donald Trump said, July 17, 2020; No, Joe Biden isn’t 'on board with defunding police', Aug. 5, 2020; Ad attacking Joe Biden’s tax plan takes his comments out of context, Aug. 20, 2020; Facebook post wrongly claims Biden would hike tax rates for family earning $75,000; Aug. 20, 2020
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.