Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
- New York City banned whole milk in schools in 2006, and the federal government banned whole milk nationally — and therefore in all of New York state — in 2010.
Milk may not be the most urgent issue for school administrators these days, but the issue came up in a New York state Senate hearing earlier this year.
During a Feb. 24 hearing of the New York Senate Agriculture Committee, agricultural law attorney and dairy producer Lorraine Lewandrowski called for a greater investment in dairy farms and rural communities.
Lewandrowski prefaced her testimony by describing several issues that dairy farmers are struggling with. Including New York state’s strict laws on milk pricing.
Lewandrowski said dairy farmers face strict production limits, reducing their bargaining power. "Our food model is based on faraway sources while we throw our rural communities away," she said.
One of the points Lewandrowksi made in her testimony is that public school students in the state should be able to consume whole milk.
"Make it legal for a New York state student to have a glass of fresh whole milk," Lewandrowski said. "A beautiful food from a beautiful land."
Is whole milk really prohibited in New York public schools? Basically, yes.
In 2006, New York City school districts underwent a far-reaching rebranding of their student lunch programs, focusing on improving the meals’ nutritional values. As a result, whole milk was removed and ultimately banned by the city's education board.
The options left on the menu were 1% milk, skim, and skim chocolate milk.
Then, in 2010, the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act was passed by Congress. The law altered school lunch programs nationally by banning whole milk, 2% white milk, 2% flavored milk, and 1% flavored milk. This left students’ milk options to flavored skim, white skim, or white 1%.
During the 2017-18 school year the regulations were loosened and Congress allowed schools to offer 1% flavored milk with proof of operational hardship. By 2018-19, schools were allowed to offer the 1% flavored milk without citing an operational concern, according to the USDA. But whole milk remains unavailable.
In March of 2021, Reps. Glenn Thompson, R-Pa., and Antonio Delgado, D-N.Y., introduced the Whole Milk for Healthy Kids Act of 2021. It would allow flavored and unflavored whole milk back into school cafeterias.
New York state Sen. George Borrello, a member of the Agriculture Committee, told PolitiFact that he "wholeheartedly" supports efforts to return whole milk to schools. He said that doing so would provide children in New York with another option at lunch while also aiding the state’s dairy industry.
Dairy farmers want to be able to sell whole milk in addition to the other types because they contend that it’s more nutritional and cuts down on waste by students who don’t like the taste of lower-fat milk.
Food Waste Warrior, a project of the World Wildlife Fund, found that as much as 45 million gallons of milk were wasted in 2019 in school lunchrooms, a value of $138 million. The study predicted that total food waste in schools could cost as much as $9.7 million per day or $1.7 billion per school year.
"We are losing an entire generation of students who don't know about appreciating a good glass of flavorful milk," said Lewandrowksi "How could this be good? If food is given to students, wouldn't choosing foods that children prefer be better?"
Lewandrowski said it’s not currently "legal for a New York State student to have a glass of fresh whole milk."
New York City banned providing whole milk in schools in 2006, and the federal government banned whole milk nationally — and therefore in all of New York state — in 2010.
We rate this statement True.
New York State Senate Agriculture Committee, Facebook Live Senate Agriculture Committee Tour Session 2 , February 24, 2021
The Daily Yonder, NY Senate Ag Hearing: Ag Law Attorney Shares Her Concerns for Family Dairy Farms, March 29, 2021
The New York Times, In New York Schools, Whole Milk Is Cast From the Menu, February 2, 2006
PolitiFact, Are federal policies to blame for drop in student milk consumption?, June 12, 2019
USDA-FNS, Nationwide Waiver to Allow Specific School Meal Pattern Flexibility for School Year 2021-2022, April 20, 2021
Library of Congress, S.1810 - 116th Congress (2019-2020): MILK Act of 2019, June 12, 2019
Library of Congress, H.R.832 - 116th Congress (2019-2020): Whole Milk for Healthy Kids Act of 2019, January 29, 2019
US Law Justia, Article 26 - § 396-RR Price gouging; milk, 2015
Email interview with Lisa Hill, director of communications for Sen. George Borrello, April 15, 2021
Email interview with Lorraine Lewandrowski, agricultural law attorney and dairy producer, April 15, 2021
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.