Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
In the hours between this week’s chemical weapons attack in Syria and President Donald Trump’s retaliatory missile strike, conspiracy theorists worked to discredit the civilian deaths. They called it a "false flag" operation designed to trigger American involvement in the country’s civil war.
Bloggers, political leaders and even Dilbert cartoonist Scott Adams all questioned the reason behind the toxic gas attack on April 4 in Khan Sheikhoun, a rebel-controlled area in northwestern Syria.
The attack reportedly killed at least 86 people, and came less than a week after U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations Nikki Haley said that removing Syrian President Bashar al-Assad was no longer a "focus" of diplomatic policy.
On the evening of April 6, Trump ordered two Navy warships to fire 59 Tomahawk missiles at a Syrian airfield to retaliate against the attack, killing at least six.
So, was the chemical attack a hoax orchestrated to draw the United States into Syria’s civil war?
We found no credible evidence of it. While doubters have raised eyebrows, asked questions and offered theories, there’s little in the way of proof that their claims are anything more than speculation.
Here are the charges some are alleging.
The rebel conspiracy
Chief among the skeptics was Alex Jones’ InfoWars website, which questioned the validity of the attack in an April 5 post that blamed a group called the White Helmets for arranging the attack for nefarious reasons.
The White Helmets, officially known as Syria Civil Defence, is a group of ostensibly nonpartisan volunteers who aid civilian victims of the civil war. The group has been accused of being pro-rebel, and InfoWars contends they are an al-Qaida affiliate funded by George Soros and the British government.
The website’s story says the White Helmets have staged rescue videos as propaganda, and helped spread a false narrative of the gas attack. The site linked to a 2016 video in which rescue workers were conducting a "mannequin challenge" during a staged recovery scene, a failed PR stunt for which the group later apologized.
The BBC reported that the pro-opposition Edlib Media Center said the White Helmets may have been targeted by Syrian warplanes in the attack.
These same sites further wondered why rescue workers in gas attack videos weren’t using what they deemed proper procedures, that they treated victims without wearing protective clothing themselves and how they had time to take video and photographs of the aftermath.
They also wondered why Islam and the White Helmets received gas masks prior to the attack.
On April 6, after Trump ordered the missile attack, InfoWars editor-at-large Paul Joseph Watson criticized the president, tweeting:
Former U.S. Rep. Ron Paul of Texas said April 5 that the hypothesis that Assad attacked his own people with chemical weapons didn’t add up.
"It doesn’t make any sense for Assad under these conditions to all of a sudden use poison gases," Paul said. "I think it’s zero chance he would have done this deliberately."
He added that neoconservatives who had pushed for intervention in Syria stood to gain the most from such an attack, not Assad, who was seeing progress against both the Islamic State and opposition rebels. Attacking civilians with chemical weapons would be counterproductive. Paul’s Twitter account later tweeted out the video with the term "false flag" in all caps.
U.S. Rep. Thomas Massie, R-Ky., also questioned who really orchestrated the attack during a CNN interview, telling CNN anchor Kate Bolduan on April 5 that he wasn’t convinced it was Assad.
"It’s hard to know exactly what’s happening in Syria right now," Massie said. "I’d like to know specifically how that release of chemical gas, if it did occur, and it looks like it did, how that occurred. Because frankly I don’t think Assad would have done that. It does not serve his interest, it would tend to draw us into that civil war even further."
Bolduan asked Massie whom he thought did commit the attack, and he reiterated that he didn’t think such an attack would serve Assad, so he continued to question who was behind it.
One site called RootClaim.com said there was a 52 percent chance that forces opposing the Assad regime had carried out a false flag operation on civilians. Syriana Analysis, a YouTube channel run by Kevork Almassian, a Syrian living in Germany, released a video declaring the Syrian government wasn’t responsible for using chemical weapons in the attack.
Dilbert cartoonist Adams wrote on his blog April 6 that the attack had "the look of a manufactured event." He blamed the "mainstream media" for helping orchestrate an event that made it appear Assad wanted to "commit suicide-by-Trump." The attack was so heinous, Trump would have no choice but to respond, lest he be excoriated by the media for his inaction, Adams wrote.
Adams also tweeted that the calls for a swift response to the attack (citing conservative commentator Bill Kristol’s support for Trump) proved his point.
He wrote another blog post April 7 outlining why he thought Trump’s response would not lead to all-out war.
The false flag theory also was championed by far-right blogger Mike Cernovich, a Trump supporter who worried that the gas attack was coordinated to provoke a military response from Trump — which it did.
Cernovich put in hours online to convince readers the gas attack was a hoax "sponsored by deep state." Deep state is the alt-right belief in a network of government officials that secretly runs things, and in America is currently trying to bring down the Trump presidency. Cernovich alleged that the media, to which he referred as "the fake news media," is in cahoots with deep state to start World War III.
Cernovich stayed online for a multi-hour livestream starting April 6, questioning whether U.S. Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., had armed ISIS with gas and saying the attack had been planned by the United States since 2013 to escalate intervention.
White nationalist and AltRight.com blogger Richard Spencer agreed with Cernovich that the far right did not want war in Syria, tweeting on April 6 that the alt-right wants "good relations with Bashar al-Assad, and we urge Trump to halt the rush to war."
After the missile strike, Spencer tweeted out a photo of the Syrian president and his wife Alma, with the hashtag #StandWithAssad.
YouTube, "White Helmets Mannequin Challenge," Nov. 21, 2016
CNN, "Syria's White Helmets apologize for Mannequin Challenge video," Nov. 25, 2016
HeatSt.com, "‘Doctor’ Accused of Kidnapping Western Journalists Helped By UK Charity," Dec. 31, 2016
New Yorker, "There is no deep state," March 20, 2017
Reuters, "U.S. priority on Syria no longer focused on 'getting Assad out': Haley," March 30, 2017
InformationClearinghouse.Info, "Something is Not Adding Up In Idlib Chemical Weapons Attack," April 4, 2017
Twitter, @DrShajulIslam, April 4, 2017
AlMasdarNews.com "Jumping to conclusions; something is not adding up in Idlib chemical weapons attack," April 4, 2017
New York Times, "Worst Chemical Attack in Years in Syria; U.S. Blames Assad," April 4, 2017
YouTube, "False Flag Chemical Attack in Syria?," April 4, 2017
World Health Organization, "WHO alarmed by use of highly toxic chemicals as weapons in Syria," April 5, 2017
Twitter, @InfoWars, April 5, 2017
YouTube, "Syria Gas Attack: Assad's Doing...Or False Flag?," April 5, 2017
InfoWars.com, "Report: Soros-linked group behind chemical attack in Syria," April 5, 2017
Twitter, @RonPaul, April 5, 2017
YouTube, "Rep. Massie on Syria: the power to declare war is vested with Congress," April 5, 2017
RootClaim.com, "What caused the chemical calamity in Khan Sheikhoun, Syria on April 4, 2017?," April 6, 2017
VeteransToday.com, "Swedish Medical Associations Says White Helmets Murdered Kids for Fake Gas Attack Videos," April 6, 2017
Blog.Dilbert.com, "The Syrian Gas Attack Persuasion," April 6, 2017
Twitter, @ScottAdamsSays, April 6, 2017
Twitter, @Cernovich, April 6, 2017
OccupyDemocrats.com, "The Far Right Claims The Syrian Gas Attack Is A Hoax. Guess Where This Originated," April 6, 2017
Twitter, @RVAwonk, April 6, 2017
Twitter, @RichardBSpencer, April 6, 2017
Periscope, "Pro-Trump, anti-war activists shut down White House Comment line 202-456-1111 doesn't work," April 6-7, 2017
Blog.Dilbert.com, "The Syrian Air Base Attack," April 7, 2017
Twitter, @PrisonPlanet, April 7, 2017
New York Times, "U.S. Missile Attack on Syria: What We Know and Don’t Know," April 7, 2017
BBC, "Syria 'chemical attack': What we know," April 7, 2017