Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
U.S. Rep. Steve Southerland's office recently sent direct mail to constituents with a multiple-choice survey, telling them: "Make your voice heard in Washington."
The mailer also offered a snapshot of the Panama City Republican's priorities: Create jobs. Lower taxes. Cut government spending.
In a note on the back, Southerland explained how those ideas fit together. He begins:
The fact is, over 2.4 million jobs have been lost since the 'Stimulus' bill was signed into law in February of 2009."
So, more government spending, fewer jobs.
One of those neighbors sent us the mailer, asking us to check the facts.
Here's Southerland's whole message, under the headline "Listening to you. Working for you."
The fact is, over 2.4 million jobs have been lost since the "Stimulus" bill was signed into law in February of 2009. Over 15,800 construction, manufacturing, and retail jobs were lost during August 2011 and overall our country continues to face a 9.1 percent unemployment rate. Higher taxes, record spending, and bigger government have failed to create jobs or boost economic growth.
As Congress debates the next steps we must take toward job creation and economic growth, I invite you to fill out the attached questionnaire. Your concerns are of utmost importance to me, and your feedback and suggestions will be the driving force behind my work as your Representative in Congress.
Rep. Steve Southerland
The 2.4 million jobs lost figure Southerland cited comes from employment data kept by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Southerland calculated the net change in jobs between February 2009 and August 2011. (We should note that the bureau did revise its estimate down to 2.3 million from 2.4 million.)
Also of note: If Southerland included jobs numbers through October 2011 -- which he could have done and still got his mailer out on time -- the net jobs figure would be different.
Measuring from February 2009 to October 2011, the net reduction is 1.98 million jobs.
That's 18 percent fewer jobs lost since February 2009 than the August number Southerland's mailer used. Still, it's right in thrust — the country has around 2 million fewer jobs since February two years ago. And Southerland's full statement did include a reference to "August 2011," which provides readers additional context.
If the statement had been, "The fact is, over 2.4 million jobs have been lost since February of 2009," we would be done. Southerland used mainstream stats correctly, even if they were a few months old.
But it also included this phrase: "since the 'Stimulus' bill was signed into law."
At PolitiFact, when we evaluate statistical claims, we also examine the underlying point. Often, the claim implies blame.
The claims have two parts: Were the numbers right? And: Was the politician to blame?
Southerland's claim implies the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 didn't help job creation. Later, he explains: "Higher taxes, record spending, and bigger government have failed to create jobs or boost economic growth."
What does the evidence say?
The most recent report from the White House's Council of Economic Advisers, released in July, estimates the Recovery Act "raised employment by 2.4 to 3.6 million jobs relative to what it otherwise would have been." Don't trust White House advisers to evaluate the president's policies? It's not just their handiwork. The March report cited four independent analyses by the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office and three by private economic analysis companies, IHS/Global Insight, Macroeconomic Advisers and Moody's Economy.com. Estimates ranged from 1.3 million to 2.45 million jobs created or saved.
In November, the Congressional Budget Office released the most recent report, estimating that in the third quarter of 2011, Recovery Act policies:
• Raised real gross domestic product by between 0.3 percent and 1.9 percent.
• Lowered the unemployment rate by between 0.2 percentage points and 1.3 percentage points.
• Increased the number of people employed by between 0.4 million and 2.4 million.
• Increased the number of full-time-equivalent jobs by 0.5 million to 3.3 million. (Increases in FTE jobs include shifts from part-time to full-time work or overtime and are thus generally larger than increases in the number of employed workers.)
So, since the stimulus bill passed through August 2011, 2.4 million jobs were lost. But without it, 2.8 million to 4.8 million people might be out of work, according to the nonpartisan CBO and private economic analysts.
Southerland's mailer accurately cites government employment data when it says that since February 2009, 2.4 million jobs have been lost. But it misleads when it says those jobs were lost "since the 'Stimulus' bill was signed into law" — even saying later that the approach "failed to create jobs." The reality is that government and independent economic analysts say policies in the Recovery Act salvaged half a million to 2.4 million jobs. Southerland can argue the stimulus wasn't worth what it cost, but it's inaccurate to say it didn't do anything for the economy. On balance, we find his claim Half True.
E-mail interview with Matt McCullough, communications director for Steve Southerland, Dec. 19-20
Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employment, Hours, and Earnings from the Current Employment Statistics survey, accessed Dec. 20, 2011
Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employment situation summary, Dec. 2, 2011
PolitiFact Virginia, "Babur Lateef says unemployment up 150 percent since Corey Stewart became Prince William chairman," March 30, 2011
PolitiFact Georgia, "Isakson: Obama policies fuel higher gas prices," March 23, 2011
Congressional Budget Office, "Estimated Impact of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act on Employment and Economic Output from July 2011 Through September 2011," November 2011
Council of Economic Advisers, "The Economic Impact of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009," July 1, 2011
Council of Economic Advisers, "The Economic Impact of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009," March 18, 2011
PolitiFact Oregon, "Greg Walden says stimulus hasn't helped Oregon gain jobs," Nov. 30, 2011
PolitiFact Virginia, "The stimulus created 'zero jobs," Oct. 13, 2011
PolitiFact, "Obama says stimulus is responsible for 2 million jobs saved or created," Feb. 17, 2010
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.