Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
A Dallas-area school leader concerned about state education aid zeroed in on what he characterized as a ridiculous claim by Gov. Rick Perry.
In an interview with KRLD-AM’s Scott Braddock posted online March 22, Doug Otto, superintendent of the Plano school district, said the district would adjust to any state reductions by cutting administrative and teaching posts. Asked about whittling first outside classrooms, Otto replied: "Well, certainly we’re going to do that as much as we can... But it’s disingenuous, as the governor says, that somehow we have one administrator for every teacher. That’s idiocy."
Otto’s claim about Perry came to our attention after a reader asked us to check a May follow-up interview the governor gave the radio host.
Perry, stressing school districts will ultimately decide which employees to shed due to tight budgets, said in the May 11 interview: "In Texas now, we’ve hired a huge number of non-teachers into our public schools — administrators, et cetera."
Braddock then asked: "Do you stand by the number you gave previously, that there was (a) 1-to-1 ratio of administrators to teachers?"
Perry: "That is absolutely correct."
Later, Braddock told us he posed his question that way because of Otto’s earlier characterization of Perry’s view. But we found no evidence that Perry has ever cited a 1-to-1 ratio of teachers to administrators.
What Perry did say, in early March, was that non-classroom positions are on the rise. "Over the course of the last decade, we have seen a rather extraordinary amount of non-classroom employees added to (Texas public) school rolls," he told reporters.
We checked that statement and found that from 1998-99 to 2009-10, the number of non-classroom employees — especially in support and administrative staff — outpaced growth in student enrollment and teachers, though whether this growth qualifies as "extraordinary" is open to debate. Nevertheless, we rated Perry’s statement Mostly True.
Perry spokeswoman Catherine Frazier said by email the governor meant to say just that in the May interview -- that the ratio of non-teachers to teachers is 1-to-1.
Similarly, in March 2010 we rated Mostly True a statement saying there were about the same number of teachers as non-teachers in Texas in 2008-09. Non-teaching staff is a broad category that includes administrators, typically superintendents, principals, registrars, tax assessor-collectors and athletic and personnel directors and the like, as well as other school employees ranging from custodial staff to librarians.
In 2009-10, according to the Texas Education Agency, teachers filled half of the state’s 661,286 full-time school district posts. Administrators accounted for 4 percent of the remaining positions.
By email, Otto told us he thinks he saw Perry’s 1-to-1 claim in a newspaper story.
Jim Hirsch, another Plano administrator, provided links to news stories. A March 18 Fort Worth Star-Telegram article attributed that erroneous 1-to-1 claim to the Texas Young Republican Federation, but none quoted Perry saying there’s a teacher for every administrator.
We rate Otto’s statement False.
Scott Braddock, web page, "Plano Superintendent: Governor Perry’s Claims on School Funding ‘Disingenuous’ and ‘Idiocy’," March 22, 2011
Email, response to PolitiFact Texas, Jim Hirsch, Associate Superintendent for Academic and Technology Services, Plano school district, June 3, 2011
Email, response to PolitiFact Texas, Doug Otto, superintendent, Plano school district, June 2, 2011
Fort Worth Star-Telegram, news article, "Schools dispute conservative group's claim of 1-to-1 administrator-teacher ratio," March 18, 2011
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.