Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
State Rep. David Simpson says the state budget lawmakers sent to Gov. Rick Perry spends money in the wrong places — such as on Walmart commercials.
"Despite conservative boasts of cost cutting, not raising taxes and not using the Economic Stabilization Fund, or ‘rainy day fund,’ the budget still preserves about $500 million of pork for special interests including film and music makers, video games and commercials for Fortune 500 companies," the Longview Republican said in a June 5 op-ed in the Longview News-Journal.
It’s well-reported that the state promotes music, film and even video games. But this is the first we’ve heard about funding TV spots for the top 500 U.S. companies that Fortune magazine ranks by revenue every year.
To back up the statement, Simpson aide Michael Bullock noted that the 2012-13 budget the House approved on May 28 appropriates $32 million for film and music marketing, a program overseen by the governor’s office. The budget provides $16 million each year to "market Texas as a film location and promote the Texas music industry," according to the May 26 House-Senate conference committee report.
What does that have to do with Fortune 500 TV spots?
Bullock pointed us to a March report by the Texas state comptroller analyzing the state’s economic development incentives for 2010. According to the report, lawmakers in 2007 revised the Film Industry Incentive Program, created in 2005, so its grants could be extended to companies working in "the entire moving image industry," sweeping in makers of commercials, TV programs and video games.
In 2009, the Legislature appropriated $64 million in incentives for the biennium.
According to the report, from April 2009 through August 2010, the Texas Film Commission approved 152 applications to help fund the production of commercials, awarding $2 million to grantees who, all told, said they’d spend $37.4 million in Texas.
And did any of the commercials promote Fortune 500 companies? The report lists a handful.
As of Aug. 31, the company Action Figure No. 1. Inc., had received more than $8,000 for an AT&T television commercial, which was one of three commercials made for AT&T, a Fortune 500 company, by three different companies using state grants totaling about $25,600, the report says. Also, the company Radical Media received $32,000 in grant money to make a commercial for Walmart, another Fortune 500 company, and the company Modern Times received $11,133 to make a commercial for the TV show "Friday Night Lights." That show aired on NBC, a network owned by the Fortune 500 company General Electric.
We wondered if each Fortune 500 company benefits from grants going to separate production companies. Perry spokeswoman Lucy Nashed told us the grants can go to either the production company, advertising agency or the client — such as a Fortune 500 company — involved in a supported TV ad.
Lastly, we turned to the Texas Film Commission, which says on its website that certain commercials — such as ads for state agencies or those that portray Texas negatively — aren’t eligible for incentives.
Otherwise, state law permits incentives for a TV commercial project of up to 5 percent of the amount spent on the project in the state, according to the commission. To qualify, the maker must spend at least $100,000 in Texas, at least 60 percent of its shooting days must be completed in the state and at least 70 percent of the paid crew, cast and extras must be Texas residents.
Nashed told us TV commercial projects will continue to be eligible for incentives in 2012-13.
We rate Simpson’s statement True.
Rep. David Simpson’s Longview News-Journal op-ed, June 5, 2011
House Bill 1, accessed June 6, 2011
Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts, An analysis of Texas economic development incentives, 2010
Fortune 500 2011 ranking
Texas Film Commission, Moving Image Industry Incentive Program - Commercial Projects, accessed June 14, 2011
Interview with Michael Bullock, administrative assistant for Rep. David Simpson, June 6, 2011
Interview with Lucy Nashed, deputy press secretary for Gov. Rick Perry, June 15, 2011
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.