Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump switched over the weekend from lambasting Hillary Clinton’s email policies to criticizing how President Barack Obama has handled the economy.
"Obama is the first president in modern history not to have a single year of 3 percent growth," Trump said during an Oct. 28 campaign rally in Manchester, N.H.
We decided to look back at the economic data and found that Trump was right, as long as you're looking at the economic statistics a specific way.
ABCs of GDP
The Trump campaign didn’t respond to our requests for more specifics, but we can make a couple of assumptions.
When Trump talked of growth, he likely meant the percent change in gross domestic product, called GDP, which is the total value of goods and services in the country. The time frame he’s using is indistinct, but "a single year" probably relates to the annual change in GDP.
Looking at the economic statistics under those guidelines, Trump would be correct. But the comparison he's making about Obama provides a narrow view of the economy.
"I suppose he’s using year-over-year data, with which the claim is true but misleading," Princeton economist Alan Blinder told PolitiFact Florida. Blinder and another Princeton economics professor, David Watson, examined GDP growth during presidential administrations in a July 2014 study.
There are any number of historical vagaries that color what affects GDP during any administration, Obama included. Obama has overseen the country climbing out of a historical recession that left the housing market depressed, wages low, and businesses wary of investing. He’s also had a Congress that has largely pushed an austerity agenda against his wishes. And global crises like instability in the Middle East and slowed growth in China and Europe have lowered demand for U.S. products and pushed the dollar higher.
"The fact that the economy has steadily improved is actually fairly remarkable, considering what else has been happening," said Christian Weller, a University of Massachusetts Boston public policy professor and a fellow at the left-leaning Center for American Progress.
Annual figures on GDP growth goes back to 1929, and often is used to back up the same talking point on conservative media outlets that Obama has not had a full calendar year of aggregate GDP growth of at least 3 percent.
U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis data shows Herbert Hoover, who was inaugurated in March 1929 and left office in March 1933, was the last president to have this distinction. Hoover presided over an economy mired in the Great Depression that shrank during his term.
Every president since then has seen at least one calendar year with annual GDP growth of at least 3 percent or higher. The best average growth in a single calendar year under Obama is 2.6 percent in 2015, and never 3 percent or more. No president has experienced that since Hoover.
But experts said Trump’s use of "modern history" is vague, and using the annual change in GDP is perhaps not the best measure. The best data goes back to 1947, when the federal government started tracking GDP by quarter.
That would give a more nuanced picture of the data — the economy in the first quarter of a presidency is often attributed to the preceding administration, for example. It also would coincide with the historical boom in the nation’s economy after World War II.
Going by quarters, growth within a year was higher than 3 percent during two periods during Obama’s presidency, Blinder said. Between the third quarters of 2009 and 2010, GDP growth was 3.4 percent. From the first quarters of 2014 and of 2015, it was 3.3 percent.
Overall growth rates for several administrations have exceeded 3 percent, but Weller said context is important.
Without complete data for 2016, the average growth rate during Obama’s two terms was 2 percent, Weller said. That was on par with George H.W. Bush’s term and faster than George W. Bush’s average.
Trump said, "Obama is the first president in modern history not to have a single year of 3 percent growth."
Although Trump’s light on specifics, that’s accurate if he is looking solely at year-over-year figures for GDP growth going back to the Hoover administration. Experts told us that presenting the stats the way Trump did doesn't tell the whole story. And if we examine the data annually by quarters, Obama has presided over periods of growth topping 3 percent.
We rate the statement Mostly True.
Donald Trump, Campaign speech in Manchester, N.H., Oct. 28, 2016
Princeton University, "Presidents and the U.S. Economy: An Econometric Exploration," July 2014
PolitiFact, "Donald Trump gets claim about U.S. GDP doubly wrong," June 16th, 2015
PolitiFact, "Hillary Clinton: Recessions more frequent under Republicans than Democrats," Sept. 22nd, 2015
CNSNews.com, "U.S. Has Record 10th Straight Year Without 3% Growth in GDP," Feb. 26, 2016
PolitiFact, "No, GDP growth was not zero, as Donald Trump said in Miami GOP debate," March 11th, 2016
PolitiFact Arizona, "Does the economy always do better under Democratic presidents?," April 6th, 2016
National Review, "Obama’s Pretty Words Cannot Beautify His Ugly Economy," May 6, 2016
CNSNews.com, "Obama May Become First President Since Hoover Not to See 3% GDP Growth," July 29, 2016
RedState.com, "Obama Will Be The Only President In US History To Never Achieve A Year Of 3% GDP Growth," Aug. 2, 2016
Time, "Read Donald Trump’s Remarks on the Hillary Clinton Email Investigation," Oct. 28, 2016
U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, Gross Domestic Product statistics, accessed Oct. 31, 2016
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, Real Gross Domestic Product, accessed Oct. 31, 2016
Interview with Alan Blinder, Princeton University economics and public affairs professor, Oct. 31, 2016
Interview with Christian Weller, University of Massachusetts Boston public policy professor, Oct. 31, 2016
Interview with Jeffrey Frankel, Harvard University government and economics professor, Oct. 31, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.