Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Soglin, who served as Madison’s mayor twice before, dating back to the 1970s, began his third stint at City Hall in April 2011. Walker had taken office as governor in January of that year.
On the June 18, 2017 edition of "Upfront with Mike Gousha," a talk show on WISN-TV in Milwaukee, Soglin contrasted himself with Walker on how best to create jobs. And he suggested Madison is responsible for most new jobs in the state, saying:
I happen to believe that the public works in partnership and that means public investment. That’s what’s happened in Madison. We have invested in education, we have invested in infrastructure. That creates jobs. But more importantly, it creates private investment.
And if you look at the Madison tax rolls, if you look at the population growth, if you look at the fact that when Governor Walker and I both took office in 2011, within three months of one another, 60,000 new jobs have been created in this state -- 40,000 of them were created in Madison and the Madison area. Clearly, we’re doing something right. And that’s not the state government or the university growing, because the governor’s cut those back.
So, Soglin is referring to private-sector jobs. We wondered whether the 60,000 figure was accurate and whether Madison and the surrounding area created two-thirds of the new jobs in Wisconsin over the past seven years.
Jobs, not labor force
Soglin told us he based his claim on figures from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) for the civilian labor force. But that’s not a count of jobs. The labor force is the number of people who are employed plus the number who are unemployed and looking for work.
Other BLS figures show a much larger increase in jobs than Soglin claimed and that the Madison area does not account for two-thirds of them.
The seasonally adjusted figures show there were 2,330,000 nonfarm private-sector jobs in Wisconsin in April 2011 and 2,539,900 jobs in May 2017, the latest figures available.
That’s an increase of 209,900 jobs.
For the Madison area, the seasonally adjusted figures are available only for total non-farm jobs -- meaning public and private sector jobs added together. There were 361,100 jobs in April 2011 and 401,900 in May 2017.
That’s an increase of 40,800. But, again, that’s counting public sector and private sector jobs, when Soglin was citing only private sector jobs.
So, the Madison area produced far less than two-thirds of the new private-sector jobs.
As for the labor force, the measure Soglin cited, there were 3,062,326 people either employed or unemployed and looking for work in Wisconsin in April 2011. In May 2017, the figure was 3,136,701. (These figures are not seasonally adjusted.)
That’s an increase of 74,375.
The figures for the Madison area (April 2017 is the latest available) were 359,132 and 389,259, an increase of 30,127.
That means the Madison area accounted for about 40 percent, not two-thirds, of the increase in the labor force.
Soglin says that since he and Walker took office in 2011, "60,000 new jobs have been created in this state -- 40,000 of them were created in Madison and the Madison area."
But Soglin was citing figures for the number of people in the labor force -- that is, people who are employed plus people who are unemployed but looking for jobs. That’s not a count of jobs.
The actual net increase in jobs in Wisconsin, comparing April 2011 versus May 2017, is much higher: 209,900. And the Madison area accounted for less than half of the increase.
We rate Soglin’s statement False.
WISN-TV, Paul Soglin interview (3:30), June 18, 2017
Interview, Paul Soglin, June 21, 2017
Email, Paul Soglin spokeswoman Melissa Mulliken, June 21, 2017
Email, University of Wisconsin-Madison Center on Wisconsin Strategy associate director Laura Dresser, June 22, 2017
Interview, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics press officer Gary Steinberg, June 22, 2017
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, State and Area Employment, Hours, and Earnings (seasonally adjusted) for Wisconsin, accessed June 22, 2017
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, State and Area Employment, Hours, and Earnings (seasonally adjusted) for Madison area, accessed June 22, 2017
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Labor Force statistics (not seasonally adjusted) for Wisconsin and Madison area, accessed June 22, 2017
Email, Scott Walker spokesman Tom Evenson, June 21, 2017
PolitiFact Wisconsin, "Mark Pocan claim: Seven years later, Scott Walker has not met his jobs promise from first campaign," June 23, 2017
PolitiFact Wisconsin, "Pocan wrongly claims 'in the last decade, 73% of new jobs' in Wisconsin 'have come from Madison,’" Jan. 19, 2017
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.