Facts are under assault in 2020.
We can't fight back misinformation about the election and COVID-19 without you. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact
I would like to contribute
A conspiracy theory that said former FBI director James Comey was covering up the source of leaked Democratic National Committee emails for Hillary Clinton is based on a single source that has admitted he had no evidence.
The headline on a May 16, 2017, post on PatriotCrier.com read, "Bombshell: Comey knew murdered DNC staffer, Seth Rich, was WikiLeaks source & covered it up for Hillary." Facebook users flagged the story in an effort to identify potential fake news.
The post is based on a persistent and unfounded conspiracy theory about how the website WikiLeaks came by thousands of internal DNC emails during last year’s presidential election.
Seth Rich was a 27-year-old voter access projects staffer for the DNC who was shot and killed near his Washington home on July 10, 2016. The case is still unsolved, but Washington police said it was probably a botched robbery.
WikiLeaks published thousands of emails a few days after Rich’s death. Some conspiracy theorists have concluded that Rich must have been the one who leaked the emails, and was killed to scare other potential leakers. WikiLeaks offered $20,000 for more information about Rich’s death, drawing some attention to the scenario.
WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange has never said Rich was the source.
On May 15, Rod Wheeler, a private investigator hired by Rich’s family, claimed he could prove Rich was indeed the source of the leak. He told Washington-area Fox affiliate WTTG that sources in the FBI said they had evidence proving it.
The next day, Fox News reported an anonymous federal investigator backed up what Wheeler was saying. This official said the FBI had determined Rich had been in contact with WikiLeaks, sending them more than 40,000 DNC emails.
Most of the PatriotCrier.com conspiracy theory is based on this unfounded insistence that the FBI has proof of this connection.
"It’s apparent that Wheeler was being guarded in giving his statement, but the fact is the FBI has been in possession of Rich’s laptop and the agency’s director at the time, James Comey, locked down the contents to protect either certain people at the DNC, or members of Hillary’s campaign team, or Hillary Clinton, or likely all three," the PatriotCrier.com post read.
It’s quite a stretch to pin on an anonymous federal investigator that Comey examined the evidence, drew a conclusion that proved Rich was the WikiLeaks source and then hid it specifically to protect Clinton.
Wheeler didn’t even mention the former FBI director, and we didn’t find any evidence of Comey commenting on Rich’s death. The entire conspiracy theory had been under the radar, confined to corners of the Internet, until Wheeler’s story emerged, by which time Comey had been fired by President Donald Trump.
But the more egregious problem with the PatriotCrier.com post is that it didn’t include what happened next: Wheeler admitted to CNN on March 16 that he had actually gotten the information from the Fox News reporter to whom he had discussed the issue.
The FBI has not officially acknowledged conducting an investigation (a WhiteHouse.gov petition demanding Comey get involved was created in January 2017, but has so far only garnered about 1,000 signatures).
Some media outlets have reported that anonymous FBI and law enforcement officials confirmed the agency is not investigating Rich’s death, and that Washington police never gave them Rich’s laptop and therefore the agency hadn’t examined its contents.
An FBI spokeswoman confirmed only that Rich's death was being investigated by the Metropolitan Police Department.
What the FBI did do is alert the DNC of a data breach prior to the WikiLeaks release, and subsequently connected the breach to hackers with Russian ties.
The only other source even remotely supporting the idea Rich was involved is a hacker living in New Zealand named Kim Dotcom. He said someone going by the name of Panda had contacted him in 2014 to get help starting a political group in the United States. Dotcom said he is certain Panda was actually Rich, and knows that Rich was the WikiLeaks source. He has not shown any proof.
Dotcom is currently facing extradition to the United States on a host of conspiracy and racketeering charges levied by the Justice Department. Rich’s family also has denied the link Dotcom is making between Rich and WikiLeaks, and has said Dotcom actually tried to plant bogus evidence implicating Rich. And in any event, the PatriotCrier.com post didn’t make any mention of Dotcom or his claims.
The Metropolitan Police Department, meanwhile, is still investigating Rich’s death as a homicide.
PatriotCrier.com said, "Comey knew murdered DNC staffer, Seth Rich, was WikiLeaks source and covered it up for Hillary."
The website’s assertion that Comey knew Rich was WikiLeaks’ source of the DNC emails and hid the evidence to protect Clinton is a wild assumption based on refuted evidence. A private investigator had claimed that the FBI had analyzed Rich’s laptop and found proof that he had given the emails to WikiLeaks, but then recanted his story. Fox News and its network affiliate, which had broadcast the story, later retracted it.
There’s no evidence there’s any link between Rich and WikiLeaks. The FBI has indirectly denied investigating the case, which Washington police consider a robbery gone wrong.
With no concrete proof of this far-fetched claim, we rate it Pants On Fire!
Editor's note: Shortly after this fact-check was published, an FBI spokeswoman officially confirmed that Rich's death was being investigated by the Metropolitan Police Department. The text has been updated.
PatriotCrier.com, "Bombshell: Comey knew murdered DNC staffer, Seth Rich, was WikiLeaks source & covered it up for Hillary," May 19, 2017
WhiteHouse.gov, "President Donald Trump must order FBI Director Jim Comey to open an investigation on the death of DNC staffer Seth Rich," Jan. 25, 2017
WWTG-TV, "Family's private investigator: There is evidence Seth Rich had contact with WikiLeaks prior to death," May 15, 2017
Fox News, "Seth Rich, slain DNC staffer, had contact with WikiLeaks, say multiple sources," May 16, 2017
Washington Post, "Family of slain Seth Rich says reports that he fed DNC info to WikiLeaks are untrue," May 16, 2017
CNN, "Family of slain DNC staffer demands retractions from Fox News, local TV station," May 17, 2017
WWTG-TV, "Rod Wheeler backtracks statements about Seth Rich investigation," May 17, 2017
Washington Post, "A conspiratorial tale of murder, with Fox News at the center," May 17, 2017
NBC News, "DNC Staffer’s Murder Draws Fresh Conspiracy Theories," May 17, 2017
Newsweek, "FBI not probing DNC staffer Seth Rich’s murder, despite WikiLeaks claim," May 17, 2017
NPR, "Unproved Claims Re-Emerge Around DNC Staffer's Death: Here's What You Should Know," May 17, 2017
Washington Post, "The Seth Rich conspiracy shows how fake news still works," May 20, 2017
ABC News, "FBI is not involved in Seth Rich case despite 'conspiracy theories,' officials say," May 22, 2017
AOL.com, "FOX News retracts story about murdered DNC staffer Seth Rich," May 23, 2017
PolitiFact, "The baseless claim that slain DNC staffer Seth Rich gave emails to WikiLeaks," May 23, 2017
Newseek, "Seth Rich’s family on Kim Dotcom claims: ‘Ridiculous, manipulative’ and ‘non-credible’," May 23, 2017
Washington Post, "The life and death of the Seth Rich conspiracy theory," May 24, 2017
Interview, FBI spokeswoman Minique Crump, May 26, 2017
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.