Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
Ivanka Trump and Jared Kushner work in the White House along with Giuliani’s son and Barr’s son-in-law. Barr’s oldest daughter works in the Treasury Department.
Eric and Donald Trump Jr. have continued conducting international business on behalf of the Trump Organization.
Ivanka Trump accepted Chinese trademarks related to her fashion business. The Saudi grants in question went to a World Bank fund she helped inspire, not to her.
President Donald Trump and his Republican allies have attacked former Vice President Joe Biden’s son Hunter for riding his family name to a fortune in Ukraine. But a viral post floating around social media suggests the same charges should be thrown in Trump’s direction.
The picture, a spin-off of a 2016 cartoon showing Trump hoarding bags of cash, tags Trump’s daughter Ivanka, her husband Jared Kushner, and the children of Trump personal lawyer Rudy Giuliani and Attorney General William Barr as benefactors of Trump’s presidency.
"Trump’s daughter works at the White House," the text says. "Her husband works at the White House. Rudy’s son works at the White House. Barr’s son-in-law works at the White House. Barr’s daughter works at Treasury. Trump’s sons do foreign business. Trump’s daughter is getting Chinese patents and Saudi grants. But sure, let’s talk about Hunter Biden."
The image has been circulating on Facebook and Twitter since at least early December, when the House was moving toward impeaching Trump after a whistleblower complaint sounded alarms about Trump’s efforts to get Ukraine to announce an investigation into the Bidens.
The posts were flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat potential false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook.)
We decided to break down the family claims one by one.
Trump, Barr and Giuliani all have family members working in top positions at the White House and other government agencies, according to LinkedIn, news reports and the White House’s latest annual report to Congress on its personnel. Here’s what we found:
• Ivanka Trump, Donald Trump’s daughter, works as an adviser to the president and makes no salary.
• Jared Kushner, Ivanka Trump’s husband, works as an assistant and senior adviser to the president. He also takes no salary.
• Andrew Giuliani, Giuliani’s son, works as a special assistant to the president and associate director of the office of public liaison. He’s paid $95,000 per year.
• Tyler McGaughey, Barr’s son-in-law, works as an associate in the White House counsel’s office with an annual salary of $125,792.
Ivanka Trump and Kushner have had White House roles since the early months of Donald Trump’s presidency, with Ivanka Trump formally occupying her position in March 2017 and Kushner swearing in just days after Trump’s inauguration.
Kushner’s appointment came after the Justice Department wrote a memo concluding that the White House was exempt from violating federal anti-nepotism laws.
Andrew Giuliani and his former girlfriend, Olympic figure skater Sarah Hughes, at the world premiere of 'The Other Guys' in New York on Monday, Aug. 2, 2010. (AP/Agostini)
McGaughey, who’s married to Barr’s youngest daughter, and Daly, Barr’s oldest daughter, separately transitioned out of Justice Department jobs as Barr awaited Senate confirmation on his nomination to take over as attorney general, according to CNN.
Mary Daly poses for photographs at the Department of Justice in Washington on April 6, 2018. (AP/Ceneta)
Other administrations, including under Presidents George W. Bush and Barack Obama, have seen relatives of high-ranking party leaders and administration officials in government positions.
The image also takes aim at Eric and Donald Trump Jr. for their management of the Trump Organization, as well as at Ivanka Trump for her own business interests.
In October 2019, Eric Trump said, "When my father became commander in chief of this country, we got out of all international business." We rated that claim Pants on Fire.
When Donald Trump became president, he transferred ownership of the Trump Organization to his sons and pledged that "no new deals" would be done during his time in office.
But as we’ve documented, the Trump sons have put almost no stops to their overseas business dealings. They have traveled the globe, managing properties and moving on deals they insist were signed or in-the-works before their father moved into the White House.
Congratulations to our extraordinary @TrumpScotland team! Minutes ago, we received full & total approval for a new phase of development to include 500 homes, 50 cottages, sports center, retail & more. We also received approval to build a 2nd golf course! Very proud of them! pic.twitter.com/odVxomGdmf— Eric Trump (@EricTrump) September 26, 2019
As for Ivanka Trump, it’s misleading to say she’s "getting Chinese patents and Saudi grants."
The president’s daughter kept her international fashion business going for 18 months after her father’s election before shutting it down. Amid trade talks with China in 2018, she received a number of trademarks from the country related to her products. She added more in 2019, as well.
Trademarks are slightly different from patents. According to the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, a trademark protects a symbol, logo, design, name or word meant to identify the person or company behind a product, while a patent protects a person or company’s new invention.
In May 2017, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates announced their pledge to contribute $100 million to a World Bank fund meant to help women entrepreneurs and small-business owners around the world, according to reports. The fund was Ivanka Trump’s idea.
But as Snopes noted, she does not have a hands-on role with the project, nor is she lining her pockets because of it.
A viral image said: "Trump’s daughter works at the White House. Her husband works at the White House. Rudy’s son works at the White House. Barr’s son-in-law works at the White House. Barr’s daughter works at Treasury. Trump’s sons do foreign business. Trump’s daughter is getting Chinese patents and Saudi grants."
The post gets the White House and government positions right, as well as the fact that the Trump sons are still conducting business internationally.
Where it errs is in its portrait of the Saudi grants delivered to the World Bank for a project Ivanka Trump proposed. She does not stand to benefit from them financially.
We rate this claim Mostly True.
Occupy Democrats on Facebook, Dec. 8, 2019
Cagle Cartoons, "Lock Him Up," Dec. 22, 2016
Executive Office of the President, "Annual Report to Congress on White House Office Personnel," June 28, 2019
Mary Daly on LinkedIn, accessed Feb. 10, 2020
U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, "Trademark, Patent, or Copyright?" accessed Feb. 10, 2020
The Atlantic, "What Does Rudy Giuliani’s Son Do?" Nov. 18, 2019
CNN, "Daughter and son-in-law of AG nominee leaving the Justice Department," Feb. 13, 2019
Eye on the News, "Stepping Into the Fire," Jan. 11, 2019
The Atlantic, "The Ivanka Fund," May 9, 2018
Snopes, "Did Saudi Arabia Give Ivanka Trump a $100 Million Donation?" May 30, 2017
The Wall Street Journal, "Saudi Arabia, U.A.E. Pledge $100 Million to World Bank’s Women Entrepreneurs Fund," May 21, 2017
The Guardian, "Ivanka Trump brand secures China trademarks on day US president met Xi Jinping," April 19, 2017
C-Span, "Swearing-in of White House Staff," Jan. 22, 2017
The Justice Department, "Application of the Anti-Nepotism Statute to a Presidential Appointment in the White House Office," Jan. 20, 2017
The New York Times, "Ivanka Trump, Shifting Plans, Will Become a Federal Employee," March 29, 2017
Politico, "Family ties aid Obama applicants," May 11, 2009
The New York Times, "Mary Barr, Michael Daly," March 13, 2007
PolitiFact, "Eric Trump’s false claim that the Trump family ‘got out of all international business,’" Oct. 18, 2019
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.