Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
Apple and Google have teamed up to create a system that notifies cellphone users when they’ve been exposed to a COVID-19 patient.
The system aims to help public health officials slow the spread of the coronavirus by limiting the amount of time infected people who don’t have symptoms can unknowingly spread the virus.
iPhone and Android users must opt in to the feature, and personal information like location data will not be shared.
Only a few states have said they will use the technology.
You may have noticed there are new settings on your phone for tracking COVID-19. What’s that all about?
Not an unauthorized surveillance plot, as one popular social media rumor suggests.
"Remember a few days ago when everyones phone was acting crazy?" reads a June 24 Facebook post, which is a screenshot of a comment on a live video. "Well they put a covid tracker on every phone. Go look its there on your phone right now."
This post was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook.) Similar claims have been shared widely by other Facebook and Instagram users, including a rapper with more than 420,000 followers.
Having a health tracker installed on every Android and iOS device may sound invasive, so we wanted to investigate.
(Screenshot from Facebook)
We’re not sure what the Facebook post means when it says phones were "acting crazy," but Snopes reported that a network outage June 15 affected primarily T-Mobile customers.
While there are settings on your iPhone for "COVID-19 Exposure Logging," you must opt in to the feature, which is aimed at helping contact tracers slow the spread of the coronavirus. Few states have said they will use the technology, which comes with a slew of privacy restrictions.
Apple and Google have created technology to help public health officials. But the subtext of the Facebook post — that the companies are tracking users without their knowledge — is inaccurate.
In April, Apple and Google announced they were building a tracking system for iOS and Android mobile operating systems. The feature, samples of which were released in early May, uses Bluetooth Low Energy signals to automatically send users notifications when they have come in contact with someone who tested positive for COVID-19 and who has also enabled the technology. Apple rolled out the new settings with iOS 13.5 on May 20.
The feature would work like this:
Say you’re diagnosed with COVID-19. You have a contact tracing app from your local public health department on your phone, so you report your diagnosis. Then, with your consent, the app uses your phone’s Bluetooth data to find other cellphone users you’ve been in contact with over the past 14 days (which is how long people could spread the virus without showing symptoms). Finally, if those people have consented to using the technology, the system notifies them that they were potentially exposed to the coronavirus.
(Screenshot from Google)
The tracking system is aimed at helping public health officials conduct contact tracing, which the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says is a key part of reopening the country.
Contact tracing tasks public health workers with learning as much as they can about who a patient has been in contact with so they can be notified about their potential exposure. One way to think about the process is a series of "disease investigations."
"That’s like the nickname for them. It’s investigative work — you’ve got to learn everything about this person that you can, and you have to help them recall what they did over the last 14 days," Jerne Shapiro, a lecturer in the Department of Epidemiology at the University of Florida, previously told PolitiFact. "This is called ‘shoe-leather epidemiology.’"
Some public health experts have extolled the potential of the Apple-Google partnership in helping epidemiologists quickly track down potential COVID-19 patients. The thinking is that, by limiting the amount of time someone is unknowingly spreading the coronavirus, the number of new cases would decrease.
"Once we have the capability to test as many people as want to get tested, the capability of the human resource side — to put somebody in isolation who is positive, to find out who their contacts were and put them into quarantine — that is your strongest tool to prevent the spread of the disease," Shapiro said.
Some social media users and experts have raised concerns over how cellphone users’ data could potentially be misused by Apple, Google and public health authorities. But the contact tracing system has some built-in privacy settings that aim to safeguard users’ data.
First, to participate in the tracking programs, users must install one of the authorized public health apps and then choose to turn on the COVID-19 exposure notifications (which they can turn off at any time). Second, location data is not stored in the system — just Bluetooth identifiers, which change frequently and do not give other users, Apple or Google the identities of their owners.
Finally: "Only public health authorities will have access to this technology, and their apps must meet specific criteria around privacy, security and data control," according to an FAQ about the feature. Apple and Google have said they will shut down the feature once the pandemic ends.
As of June 5, few states have said they will use the contact tracing system.
9to5Mac, a website that writes about Apple products, polled all 50 state governors’ offices and health departments in late May to see if any were planning to use the technology. Only four — Alabama, North Dakota, South Carolina and Virginia — said they would. Seventeen states said they would not use the system, and the rest did not respond.
A poll from Business Insider had similar results. Many states told the publication that they intended to rely on human contact tracers. Other challenges facing Apple and Google’s technology: It’s hard to get people to download apps from public health officials, the federal government hasn’t endorsed the approach, and it’s unclear whether Bluetooth contact tracing systems have been effective in other countries, such as Norway.
We reached out to Google for a comment, but we haven’t heard back.
A social media rumor claims that Google and Apple "put a covid tracker on every phone."
The technology companies created a system that notifies cellphone users when they’ve been exposed to a COVID-19 patient who was enabled the same technology. The system aims to help public health officials slow the spread of the coronavirus by limiting the amount of time infected people who don’t show symptoms unknowingly spread the virus.
But the subtext of the Facebook post — that the companies are using the system to track users without their knowledge — is inaccurate. iPhone and Android users must opt in to the feature, and personal information like location data will not be shared. Only a few states have said they will use the technology to support their contact tracing efforts.
The Facebook post is partially accurate but leaves out important details or takes things out of context. We rate it Half True.
Apple, Privacy-Preserving Contact Tracing, accessed June 24, 2020
Business Insider, "Apple and Google's ambitious COVID-19 contact-tracing tech can help contain the pandemic if used widely. But so far only 3 states have agreed — and none has started to use it." June 10, 2020
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Contact Tracing, accessed June 24, 2020
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Symptoms of Coronavirus, accessed June 24, 2020
Email from Apple, June 24, 2020
Facebook post, June 20, 2020
Facebook post, June 21, 2020
Facebook post, June 24, 2020
Google, Exposure Notification: Frequently Asked Questions, May 2020
Instagram post, June 19, 2020
Marketwatch, "‘This could be abused.’ Privacy experts take cautious approach to Apple and Google’s coronavirus contact-tracing technology," April 16, 2020
PolitiFact, "Contact tracing: How it's used to fight COVID-19," April 17, 2020
Snopes, "Did a Phone Service Outage Enable COVID-19 Tracking Apps To Be Placed in Phones?" June 23, 2020
The Verge, "Apple and Google are building a coronavirus tracking system into iOS and Android," April 10, 2020
The Verge, "Apple and Google pledge to shut down coronavirus tracker when pandemic ends," April 24, 2020
The Verge, "Apple and Google show what their exposure notification system could look like," May 4, 2020
The Verge, "How humans are beating machines in the effort to fight the spread of COVID-19," June 16, 2020
World Health Organization, Contact tracing, May 9, 2017
WXYZ-TV, "Your iPhone can help with COVID-19 contact tracing – here's how," June 19, 2020
9to5Mac, "Which U.S. states are using Apple’s Exposure Notification API for COVID-19 contact tracing?" June 5, 2020
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.