Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
State Rep. Peter G. Palumbo was on WHJJ’s "Helen Glover Show" recently to talk about his latest attempt to crack down on illegal immigration in Rhode Island.
The Cranston Democrat has submitted legislation in the General Assembly that would require companies with three or more employees to check on the immigration status of any job applicants using the federal E-Verify database.
During his talk-radio appearance March 20, Palumbo told Glover that not only is E-Verify the "simplest way to curb illegal immigration," it’s also a program that has broad public support.
"Every poll you see, the overwhelming majority of people want the bill," he said.
Does E-Verify really have such overwhelming support?
E-Verify is a federal government program that allows companies to check on a worker’s immigration status through an online database. The program compares information on the worker’s Form I-9 to records from the Social Security Administration and the Department of Homeland Security. If the records match, there’s no problem. If the records don’t match, the worker may be in the country illegally.
When we asked Palumbo to show us some polls on E-Verify, he referred to only one, conducted a year ago by Brown University’s Taubman Center for Public Policy & American Institutions. We found that poll, but it didn’t ask any questions about E-Verify.
The closest was a question about the controversial law in Arizona that requires local police forces to enforce federal immigration laws. Fifty-four percent of the Rhode Islanders in the survey were in favor of such a law.
We did our own research and found many polls that asked about a variety of illegal- immigration questions, but few that asked specifically about E-Verify. The one poll that supporters of E-Verify around the country most frequently cite was conducted by Rasmussen Reports, a nationally recognized polling firm. That poll of 1,000 likely voters was conducted May 27-28, 2011.
The poll asked this question: "The federal government maintains an E-Verify system which allows employers to determine the immigration status of potential employees. Before hiring a new employee, should businesses be required to check and make sure that each potential employee is in the country legally?"
Eighty-two percent of respondents answered yes, 12 percent said no and the remaining 6 percent were undecided. That is an overwhelming majority in favor of E-Verify.
But that’s only one poll. What about others? NumbersUSA, a group that opposes illegal immigration and also advocates for limits on legal immigration, last month released the results of a poll it commissioned from Pulse Opinion Research, a subsidiary of Rasmussen Research.
The poll asked: "On the issue of illegal immigration, do you favor or oppose mandating that all employers electronically verify the immigration status of their workers?" Seventy-eight percent were in favor, 12 percent were opposed and 9 percent were unsure.
The Federation for American Immigration Reform, another group opposed to illegal immigration that also seeks to curb legal immigration, released the results last year of a poll it also commissioned from Pulse Opinion Research. According to FAIR, 88 percent of respondents supported the use of an "electronic verification system to check worker eligibility," while 11 percent were opposed.
A 2010 poll of 616 Arizona residents conducted by The Arizona Republic newspaper found that 66 percent supported a state law that would require employers "to prove that all their workers are U.S. citizens or have valid work visas."
As for Rhode Island, we found two polls, both conducted in 2008 by Rhode Island College’s Bureau of Government Research and Services, that asked voters about then-Gov. Donald Carcieri’s executive order to use E-Verify to screen state workers and employees of companies that do business with the state.
In the first poll, done that June, 75 percent of the 500 Rhode Islanders in the survey agreed with the governor’s order. In the second poll the following September, 73 percent agreed with it.
Palumbo said that "every poll" shows "overwhelming support" for E-Verify. Obviously, we can’t guarantee that we found every poll on E-Verify. But we did find several, some conducted by independent pollsters, others financed by groups that favor stronger enforcement of immigration laws.
All of the polls that we found -- both national surveys and others conducted in Rhode Island -- showed strong support for E-Verify, ranging from 66 percent of respondents in favor to 88 percent.
We rule Palumbo’s statement True.
(Get updates from PolitiFactRI on Twitter. To comment or offer your ruling, visit us on our PolitiFact Rhode Island Facebook page.)
RILIN.State.RI.US, "An Act Relating to Labor and Labor Relations," introduced March 8, 2012, accessed March 20, 2012
920WHJJ.com, "Helen Glover Show -- Palumbo," March 20, 2012, accessed March 20, 2012
Interview, Peter G. Palumbo, Rhode Island state representative, March 21, 2012
News.Brown.Edu, "Rhode Islanders divided on immigrants and immigration policy," March 7, 2011, accessed March 21, 2012
RasmussenReports.com, "61% Favor A State Law That Would Shut Down Repeat Offenders Who Hire Illegal Immigrants," May 31, 2011, accessed March 21, 2012
NumbersUSA.com, "New Poll Confirms Huge E-Verify Popularity," Feb. 28, 2012, accessed March 21, 2012
FAIRUS.org, "FAIR’s National Poll Shows Overwhelming Support for E-Verify," June/July 2011, accessed March 21, 2012
AZCentral.com, "Poll: Worker verification even more popular," July 25, 2010, accessed March 21, 2012
The Providence Journal, "RIC poll: 75% support governor on immigration," July 7, 2008, accessed March 21, 2012
The Providence Journal, "Campaign 2008 -- Obama’s lead shrinks in new RIC poll," Sept. 26, 2008, accessed March 21, 2012
RIC.edu/BGRS, "July 1, 2008 Survey Results," Rhode Island College Bureau of Government Research and Services, accessed March 22, 2012
RIC.edu/BGRS, "September 20, 2008 Survey Results," Rhode Island College Bureau of Government Research and Services, accessed March 22, 2012
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.